Regulatory Authority
Ethics Committee
Clinical Trial Lifecycle
Sponsorship
Informed Consent
Investigational Products
Specimens
Quick Facts
Health Canada
As per the CanadaFDA, the CanadaFDR, and the G-CanadaCTApps, Health Canada (HC) is the competent authority responsible for clinical trial approvals, oversight, and inspections in Canada. The G-CanadaCTApps states that the HC grants permission for clinical trials to be conducted in the country, and regulates the sale and importation of drugs for use in clinical trials in accordance with the CanadaFDR provisions.
As per CAN-29, HC is one (1) of five (5) federal agencies within Canada’s “Health Portfolio” overseen by the Minister of Health. As delineated in CAN-23, HC’s Health Products and Food Branch (HPFB) is the national authority that regulates, evaluates, and monitors therapeutic and diagnostic product safety, efficacy, and quality, and reviews the information submitted in the clinical trial application. Per CanadaFDA, if the Minister believes on reasonable grounds that the use of a therapeutic product, other than the intended use, may present a risk of injury to health, the Minister may, by order, establish rules in respect of the importation, sale, conditions of sale, advertising, manufacture, preparation, preservation, packaging, labeling, storage, or testing of the therapeutic product for the purpose of preventing, managing, or controlling the risk of injury to health.
Per CAN-16, HPFB’s activities are carried out by nine (9) Directorates, including the Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (PDD) and the Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (BRDD). Per CAN-18, PDD regulates pharmaceutical drugs for human use. Specifically, PPD:
- Reviews scientific information to assess the safety, efficacy, and quality of a prescription drug
- Assesses the potential benefits and risks of a prescription drug
- Reviews clinical trial applications for prescription drugs to ensure that the studies are well-designed and that participants will not be exposed to undue risk
- Monitors the evolving safety of drugs in development through the review of adverse reaction reports
- Makes non-marketed drugs available to health professionals for patients when conventional therapies have failed, are not suitable, or are not available
- Provides Canadians with science-based medical information they need to make informed choices
CAN-17 indicates that the BRDD regulates biological drugs, radiopharmaceuticals, and cells, tissues, and organs for human use, including clinical trials.
In addition, the G-CanadaCTApps indicates that the PDD’s Office of Clinical Trials (OCT) and the BRDD’s Office of Regulatory Affairs (ORA), among others, are directly involved with the clinical trial review and approval process for pharmaceutical, biological, and radiopharmaceutical drugs. CAN-18 states that the PDD Director General's Office oversees pharmaceutical clinical trials. Per the G-MDSA, the Therapeutic Products Classification Committee (TPCC) may be consulted when it is not clear whether a product should be classified as a drug or device. The committee makes recommendations on the classification of a product as either a drug, medical device, or combination product. When appropriate, other regulatory areas of HC may be asked to participate in the committee's discussion.
As per CAN-41, HC has established a regulatory innovation agenda, which aims to provide more regulatory flexibility to support innovative research and health product development. For more details, see CAN-41.
International Alignment
Per CAN-10, Canada is an official member of the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH). CAN-50 indicates that HC adopted the ICH Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52). The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence. More generally, CAN-50 notes HC-implemented ICH guidance takes precedence over other HC guidance when they are inconsistent. Also see CAN-50 for details on all the ICH guidelines implemented by HC. For any questions or comments, contact HC’s ICH Coordinator via email at ich@hc-sc.gc.ca.
Contact Information
According to the G-MDSA and CAN-18, Health Canada PDD contact information is as follows (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
Office of Clinical Trials
Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate
Health Canada
Holland Cross, Tower B
1600 Scott Street, 5th Floor
Address Locator: 3105A
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
K1A 0K9
Phone (General Enquiries): 613-957-0368
Fax (General Enquiries): 613-952-7756
General Inquiries: oct.enquiries-requetes.bec@hc-sc.gc.ca
Pre-CTA Meeting Requests: oct.pre.cta-dec.bec@hc-sc.gc.ca (per G-MDSA)
Per G-MDSA, the following is the contact information for biologic clinical trials:
Office of Regulatory Affairs
Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate
Health Products and Food Branch
Health Canada
Tunney’s Pasture
100 Eglantine Driveway
Address Locator: 0601C
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
K1A 0K9
Phone: 613-957-1722
E-mail: brdd.ora@hc-sc.gc.ca
This profile covers the role of the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)’s Food & Drug Administration (FDA) in reviewing and authorizing investigational new drug applications (INDs) to conduct clinical trials using investigational drug or biological products in humans in accordance with the FDCAct, 21CFR50, and 21CFR312. Regulatory requirements for federally funded or sponsored human subjects research, known as the Common Rule (Pre2018-ComRule and RevComRule), which the HHS and its Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP) implements in subpart A of 45CFR46, are also examined. Lastly, additional HHS requirements included in subparts B through E of 45CFR46 are described in this profile, where applicable, using the acronym 45CFR46-B-E. (Please note: ClinRegs does not provide information on state-level requirements pertaining to clinical trials.)
Food & Drug Administration
As per the FDCAct, 21CFR50, and 21CFR312, the FDA is the regulatory authority that regulates clinical investigations of medical products in the United States (US). According to USA-92, the FDA is responsible for protecting public health by ensuring the safety, efficacy, and security of human and veterinary drugs, biological products, and medical devices.
An overview of the FDA structure is available in USA-33. Several centers are responsible for pharmaceutical and biological product regulation, including the Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) and the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER). Additionally, per USA-88, the Office of Clinical Policy (OCLP) develops clinical research policies, regulation, and guidance in collaboration with the FDA’s medical product centers.
Office for Human Research Protections and Common Rule Agencies
Per USA-93, the OHRP provides leadership in the protection of the rights, welfare, and well-being of human research subjects for studies conducted or supported by the HHS. The OHRP helps ensure this by providing clarification and guidance, developing educational programs and materials, maintaining regulatory oversight, and providing advice on ethical and regulatory issues in biomedical and social-behavioral research.
USA-65 states that the Common Rule (Pre2018-ComRule and RevComRule) outlines the basic provisions for institutional ethics committees (ECs) (referred to as institutional review boards (IRBs) in the US), informed consent, and Assurances of Compliance. See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on US departments and agencies that follow the Common Rule, which are referred to as Common Rule departments/agencies throughout the profile.
The RevComRule applies to all human subjects research that is federally funded or sponsored by a Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-65), and: 1) was initially approved by an EC on or after January 21, 2019; 2) had EC review waived on or after January 21, 2019; or 3) was determined to be exempt on or after January 21, 2019. (Per USA-74, the RevComRule is also known as the “2018 Requirements.”) For 2018 Requirements decision charts consistent with the RevComRule, including how to determine if research is exempt, see USA-74. For more information about the RevComRule, see USA-66.
Per the RevComRule, the Pre2018-ComRule requirements apply to research funded by a Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-65) that, prior to January 21, 2019, was either approved by an EC, had EC review waived, or was determined to be exempt from the Pre2018-ComRule. Institutions conducting research approved prior to January 21, 2019 may choose to transition to the RevComRule requirements. The institution or EC must document and date the institution's determination to transition a study on the date the determination to transition was made. The research must comply with the RevComRule beginning on that date. For pre-2018 Requirements decision charts consistent with the Pre2018-ComRule, including how to determine if research is exempt, see USA-74.
USA-65 indicates that the FDA, despite being a part of the HHS, is not a Common Rule agency. Rather, the FDA is governed by its own regulations, including the FDCAct and 21CFR50. However, the FDA is required to harmonize with the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule whenever permitted by law.
If a study is funded or sponsored by HHS, and involves an FDA-regulated product, then both sets of regulations will apply. See G-RevComRule-FDA for additional information.
International Alignment
Per USA-16, the US is a member of the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH). The FDA has implemented the Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) in US-ICH-GCP, along with other ICH guidance. See USA-19 for the implementation status of all ICH guidelines. Additionally, see USA-22 and USA-47 for links to ICH guidance documents implemented by the FDA.
Contact Information
Food & Drug Administration
As per USA-81, USA-90, and USA-91, the contact information for the FDA is as follows (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
Main FDA Telephone (general inquiries): (888) 463-6332
Food and Drug Administration
Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER)
10903 New Hampshire Avenue
Silver Spring, MD 20993-0002
CBER Telephone: (800) 835-4709 or (240) 402-8010
CBER Email (manufacturers assistance): Industry.Biologics@fda.hhs.gov
CBER Email (imports): CBERimportinquiry@fda.hhs.gov
CBER Email (exports): CBERExportCert@fda.hhs.gov
Food and Drug Administration
Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER)
Office of Drug Information
10903 New Hampshire Avenue
Building 51, Room 1109
Silver Spring, MD 20993
CDER Telephone (drug information): (301) 796-3400
CDER Email: druginfo@fda.hhs.gov
Office for Human Research Protections
Per USA-82, the contact information for the OHRP is as follows:
Office for Human Research Protections
1101 Wootton Parkway, Suite 200
Rockville, MD 20852
Telephone: (866) 447-4777 or (240) 453-6900
Email (general inquiries): OHRP@hhs.gov
Department of Health & Human Services
According to USA-83, the contact information for the HHS is as follows:
US Department of Health & Human Services
Hubert H. Humphrey Building
200 Independence Avenue, S.W.
Washington, D.C. 20201
Call Center: (877) 696-6775
Overview
In accordance with the CanadaFDA, Health Canada (HC) reviews, evaluates, and approves applications for clinical trials using authorized therapeutic products. HC also approves the sale or importation of drugs for use in clinical trials. (See the Manufacturing & Import section for additional information on importation.) As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, institutional ethics committee (EC) review is required for each clinical trial site and may occur in parallel with HC’s clinical trial application (CTA) review and approval. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100. See CAN-23 for background information on how HC reviews drugs in Canada.
Per the CanadaFDA, a “therapeutic product” is defined as a drug or device, or any combination of drugs and devices, but does not include natural health products; and “therapeutic product authorization” refers to a license that is approved for the import, sale, advertisement, manufacture, preparation, preservation, packaging, labeling, storage, or testing of a therapeutic product. As per the G-CanadaCTApps, a drug is defined as a pharmaceutical, biologic, gene therapy, blood product, vaccine, and radiopharmaceutical for human use that is to be tested in a clinical trial. HC’s scope of assessment includes clinical trials (Phases I - III) using:
- Drugs not authorized for sale in Canada in development and in comparative bioavailability studies
- Marketed drugs where the proposed use of the drug for one (1) of the following is different: indication(s) and clinical use; target patient population(s); route(s) of administration; or dosage regimen(s)
Clinical Trial Review Process
As set forth in the G-CanadaCTApps and CAN-23, HC’s Health Products and Food Branch (HPFB) coordinates the CTA approval process. The G-CanadaCTApps and CAN-23 state that prior to initiating the trial, the sponsor must file a CTA to the appropriate HPFB Directorate. CTAs involving pharmaceutical drugs should be sent to the Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (PDD), and CTAs involving biologics and/or radiopharmaceuticals should be sent to the Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (BRDD).
The G-CanadaCTApps indicates that upon receipt of a CTA, the HPFB Directorate (PDD/BRDD) screens the application package for completeness. If deficiencies are found, the Directorate sends the sponsor a Request for Clarification or a Screening Rejection Letter. If the Directorate finds the application complete, an acknowledgement letter is issued to indicate the 30-day default review period commenced on the date of receipt. See CAN-23 for more information.
Per the G-CanadaCTApps, once a clinical trial is authorized, the sponsor is allowed to sell or import a drug for use in a trial, if a CTA has been filed with HC and has not received an objection within 30 days. If the clinical trial is authorized, a No Objection Letter (NOL) is issued. If the CTA is rejected, a Not Satisfactory Notice (NSN) is issued. During the review period, the Directorate may request additional information from the sponsor, who has two (2) calendar days to provide such information. Please see the G-CanadaCTApps for special requirements regarding reviews of comparative bioavailability studies and joint reviews of clinical trials covering a combination of devices, biologics, and pharmaceuticals. See the Submission Process section for detailed application submission requirements. See CAN-23 for more information.
Per the G-CanadaCTApps, soon after HC issues an NOL, it will publish the following information about the clinical trial in HC’s publicly accessible database:
- Protocol number
- Protocol title
- Drug name
- Medical condition
- Study population
- Authorization date
- Sponsor name
- HC control number
- Trial start and end dates, if known
The CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps also delineate that a clinical trial application-amendment (CTA-A) is required for proposed changes to a previously authorized study when the changes to clinical trial drug supplies affect the quality or safety of the drug, or when the changes to an authorized protocol alter the risk to clinical trial participants, or both. CTA-As must be authorized by HC prior to implementation of the changes. However, if the sponsor is required to immediately implement changes because the clinical trial or the use of the clinical trial drug endangers the health of participants or other persons, the sponsor may immediately make the amendment without prior review by HC. Sponsors must notify HC of this change, provide the relevant rationale in support of the immediate implementation, and file a CTA-A that clearly identifies the change and rationale for immediate implementation of the change within 15 days after the amendment implementation date. In addition, sponsors may make the following changes immediately if it notifies HC in writing within 15 days after the date of the change: a change to the chemistry and manufacturing information that does not affect the quality or safety of the drug; or a change to the protocol that does not alter the risk to the health of a participant.
As per the G-Dcntrl, HC requires information about decentralized elements in the clinical trial application to review whether these elements were designed to minimize risk to participants, support appropriate oversight and monitoring throughout the trial, and help achieve trial objectives. Additionally, sponsors must attest that the trial, including all decentralized elements, will be conducted according to good clinical practice (GCP). Depending on the decentralized elements and activities within the proposed trial known at the time of application, HC will review how participant visits and clinical trial activities will be conducted (e.g., in person, by telephone or telehealth platform, or through third parties or vendors). See G-Dcntrl for more details about clinical trials with decentralized elements.
As delineated in the CanadaFDA and the G-Inspections, HC is authorized to implement an inspection strategy and to ensure compliance with CanadaFDA. The G-Inspections states that HC’s Regulatory Operations and Enforcement Branch (ROEB) monitors compliance, which is assessed through inspections and other compliance and enforcement activities, such as compliance verifications. Compliance verifications of clinical trials may be initiated when there are reasonable grounds to believe that non-compliance may have occurred or is occurring and that enforcement measures may be necessary (e.g., complaints received regarding specific trials, reports of adverse drug reaction(s), or reports from other regulatory authorities). The Clinical Trial Compliance Program within ROEB is responsible for clinical trial site selection for inspections in collaboration with the PDD and the BRDD. A risk-based approach is applied in the site selection process to minimize the potential health risks inherent to clinical trials involving human participants. The selection of sites for inspection is based on a variety of criteria to select sites throughout all levels of the drug assessment and regulatory approvals process. For clinical trial sites with decentralized elements, G-Dcntrl states that the main location of the clinical trial site associated with the qualified investigator (QI) is the primary point of contact for an inspection. HC inspectors may request documentation from sponsors and QIs to demonstrate adequate coordination, oversight, and monitoring of delegated parties, as well as the measures in place to protect participant safety. See the Risk-Insp for a risk classification guide used by ROEB; this guide describes how inspectors classify risk-based observations and assign a rating, promotes consistency, and provides examples of inspection observations.
Per the CanadaFDR, HC will suspend the authorization to sell or import a drug for clinical trial purposes if it has reasonable grounds to believe that:
- The sponsor has contravened any relevant laws or regulations
- Any information submitted in respect of the drug or clinical trial is false or misleading
- The sponsor has failed to comply with GCP
- The sponsor has failed to provide information or samples as required by the regulation
See the CanadaFDR for additional details on HC’s suspension and cancellation responsibilities.
Expanded Access Clinical Trial
The Expd-CTs explains that in Canada, an expanded access clinical trial is a type of clinical trial that provides access to investigational products (IPs) that have the potential to treat people living with medical conditions who do not qualify for other clinical trials or are not able to participate in one. When appropriate, expanded access clinical trials can use more flexible protocols and a decentralized model to facilitate access for a larger, potentially more diverse population of participants, in more accessible settings. Since expanded access clinical trials are a type of clinical trial under the CanadaFDR, they require a CTA for review by HC. HC will review applications for the sponsor’s evidence from previous studies that the proposed use of the IP would not endanger the health and safety of participants. HC assesses all CTAs on a case-by-case basis. CTAs for expanded access clinical trials follow the same review processes and timelines as other clinical trials. HC scientists and physicians review expanded access CTAs to assess whether:
- The risks in using the drug in the trial are considered and would not endanger health and safety
- The best interests of those taking part in the trial have been considered, including that drugs are used in the right way for the participants being studied
- The goals of the trial can be met
Per the Expd-CTs, group-level access to a drug in Canada is available only through an expanded access clinical trial and not through the individual-patient Special Access Program. Therefore, sponsors wishing to include a Canadian arm in an international expanded access program for multiple patients must do so through an expanded access clinical trial.
Overview
In accordance with the FDCAct, 21CFR50, and 21CFR312, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has authority over clinical investigations for drug and biological products regulated by the agency. 21CFR312 specifies that the scope of the FDA’s assessment for investigational new drug applications (INDs) includes all clinical trials (Phases 1-4). Based on 21CFR56 and 21CFR312, institutional ethics committee (EC) review of the proposed clinical investigation may be conducted in parallel with the FDA review of the IND. However, EC approval must be obtained prior to the sponsor being permitted to initiate the clinical trial. (Note: Institutional ECs are referred to as institutional review boards (IRBs) in the United States (US)).
As delineated in 21CFR312 and USA-42, sponsors are required to submit an IND to the FDA to obtain an agency exemption to ship investigational drug(s) across state lines to conduct drug or biologic clinical trial(s). An IND specifically exempts an investigational drug or biologic from FDA premarketing approval requirements that would otherwise be applicable. 21CFR312 states that “‘IND’ is synonymous with ‘Notice of Claimed Investigational Exemption for a New Drug.’"
According to USA-42, the FDA categorizes INDs as either commercial or non-commercial (research) and classifies them into the following types:
- Investigator INDs - Submitted by physicians who both initiate and conduct the investigation, and who are directly responsible for administering or dispensing the investigational drug.
- Emergency Use INDs - Enable the FDA to authorize experimental drugs in an emergency situation where normal IND submission timelines cannot be met. Also used for patients who do not meet the criteria of an existing study protocol, or if an approved study protocol does not exist.
- Treatment INDs - Submitted for experimental drugs showing potential to address serious or immediately life-threatening conditions while the final clinical work is conducted and the FDA review takes place.
Per the G-PharmeCTD, non-commercial products refer to products not intended to be distributed commercially and include the above listed IND types.
As indicated in the G-IND-Determination, in general, human research studies must be conducted under an IND if all of the following research conditions apply:
- A drug is involved as defined in the FDCAct
- A clinical investigation is being conducted as defined in 21CFR312
- The clinical investigation is not otherwise exempt from 21CFR312
The G-IND-Determination states that biological products may also be considered drugs within the meaning of the FDCAct.
Further, per 21CFR312 and the G-IND-Determination, whether an IND is required to conduct an investigation of a marketed drug primarily depends on the intent of the investigation and the degree of risk associated with the use of the drug in the investigation. See 21CFR312 and the G-IND-Determination for detailed exemption conditions for marketed drugs.
Clinical Trial Review Process
As delineated in 21CFR312, the FDA's primary objectives in reviewing an IND are to ensure human participant safety and rights in all phases of the investigation. Phase 1 submission reviews focus on assessing investigation safety, and Phase 2 and 3 submission reviews also include an assessment of the investigation’s scientific quality and ability to yield data capable of meeting marketing approval statutory requirements. An IND may be submitted for one (1) or more phases of an investigation.
As per USA-41 and USA-94, the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) and the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER) receive IND submissions for drugs, therapeutic biological products, and other biologicals. Per the FDCAct and 21CFR312, an IND automatically goes into effect 30 calendar days from receipt, unless the FDA notifies the sponsor that the IND is subject to a clinical hold, or the FDA has notified the sponsor earlier that the trial may begin. A clinical hold is an order the FDA issues to delay or suspend a clinical investigation. If the FDA determines there may be grounds for imposing a clinical hold, an attempt will be made to discuss and resolve any issues with the sponsor prior to issuing the clinical hold order. See 21CFR312, the G-InvstgtrHold, and the G-HoldResp for more information on clinical holds.
According to USA-41, with respect to sponsor-investigators, once the FDA receives the IND, an IND number will be assigned and the application will be forwarded to the appropriate reviewing division. A letter will be sent to the sponsor-investigator providing notification of the assigned IND number, date of receipt of the original application, address where future submissions to the IND should be sent, and the name and telephone number of the FDA person to whom questions about the application should be directed.
As indicated in 21CFR312, the FDA may at any time during the course of the investigation communicate with the sponsor orally or in writing about deficiencies in the IND or about the FDA's need for more data or information. Furthermore, at the sponsor's request, the FDA will provide advice on specific matters relating to an IND.
21CFR312 indicates that once an IND is in effect, a sponsor must submit a protocol amendment if intending to conduct a study that is not covered by a protocol already contained in the IND, there is any change to the protocol that significantly affects the safety of subjects, or a new investigator is added to carry out a previously submitted protocol. A sponsor must submit a protocol amendment for a new protocol or a change in protocol before its implementation, while protocol amendments to add a new investigator or to provide additional information about investigators may be grouped and submitted at 30-day intervals. See 21CFR312 for more information on protocol amendments.
As per 21CFR312, if no subjects are entered into a clinical study for a period of two (2) years or more under an IND, or if all investigations under an IND remain on clinical hold for one (1) year or more, the IND may be placed by the FDA on inactive status. An IND that remains on inactive status for five (5) years or more may be terminated. See 21CFR312 for more information on inactive status.
21CFR312 indicates that the FDA may propose to terminate an IND based on deficiencies in the IND or in the conduct of an investigation under an IND. If the FDA proposes to terminate an IND, the agency will notify the sponsor in writing and invite correction or explanation within a period of 30 days. If at any time the FDA concludes that continuation of the investigation presents an immediate and substantial danger to the health of individuals, the FDA will immediately, by written notice to the sponsor, terminate the IND. See 21CFR312 for more information on FDA termination.
As stated in 21CFR312, the FDA will accept, as support for an IND, a well-designed and well-conducted foreign clinical study not conducted under an IND. The study must have been conducted in accordance with good clinical practice (GCP), and the FDA must be able to validate the data from the study through an onsite inspection if the agency deems it necessary. Although the FDA will not accept a study that does not meet those conditions as support for an IND, the FDA will still examine data from such a study. See 21CFR312 and the G-FrgnCT for more details on submitting data from a foreign clinical study not conducted under an IND as support for an IND.
For more information on CDER and CBER internal policies and procedures for accepting and reviewing applications, see USA-96 and USA-95, respectively.
Per the G-BiorsrchInspct, the FDA developed a Bioresearch Monitoring (BIMO) program to assess the quality and integrity of data submitted to the FDA in support of regulatory decision-making, as well as to provide for protection of the rights, safety, and welfare of human trial participants involved in FDA-regulated research. The BIMO program, which involves on-site inspections, investigations, and remote regulatory assessments, assesses compliance with statutory requirements and the FDA’s regulations governing the conduct of nonclinical and clinical studies, as well as applicable postmarketing activities. See the G-BiorsrchInspct and USA-20 for more information on FDA inspections and the BIMO program.
Expedited Processes
USA-84 further indicates that the FDA has several approaches to making drugs available as rapidly as possible:
- Breakthrough Therapy – expedites the development and review of drugs which may demonstrate substantial improvement over available therapy
- Accelerated Approval – allow drugs for serious conditions that fill an unmet medical need to be approved based on a surrogate endpoint
- Priority Review – a process by which the FDA’s goal is to take action on an application within six (6) months
- Fast Track – facilitates the development and expedites the review of drugs to treat serious conditions and fill an unmet medical need
See USA-84 and USA-85 for more information on each process. Additionally, see the FDCAct, as amended by the FDORA, for changes to the accelerated approval process.
Other Considerations
The G-RWDRWE-Reg, issued as part of the FDA’s Real-World Evidence (RWE) Program (see USA-17), discusses the applicability of the 21CFR312 IND regulations to various clinical study designs that utilize real-world data (RWD). See the G-RWDRWE-Reg for more information.
For information on the appropriate use of adaptive designs for clinical trials and additional information to provide the FDA to support its review, see G-AdaptiveTrials. Additionally, see the G-ExplrtryIND for FDA guidance regarding exploratory studies in humans.
For research involving cellular and gene therapy, see the guidance documents at USA-80.
According to CAN-56, there are no fees to submit a clinical trial application in Canada.
Food & Drug Administration
The Food & Drug Administration (FDA) does not levy a fee to review investigational new drug submissions.
However, per the FDCAct, the FDARA, and USA-45, the FDA has the authority to collect user fees from persons that submit certain human drug applications for review or that are named in approved applications as the sponsor of certain prescription drug products. See USA-45 for more information.
Overview
As indicated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, Canada has a decentralized process for the ethical review of clinical trial applications, and requires the sponsor to obtain institutional ethics committee (EC) approval for each participating trial site. (Note: institutional ECs are referred to as Research Ethics Boards (REBs) in Canada.) Canadian provinces may have varying requirements, and, therefore, the sponsor should consult with the applicable province(s) for more information.
Per CAN-35 and CAN-13, all proposed or ongoing research involving human participants carried out by, funded by, or otherwise under the auspices of Health Canada (HC) or the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) must obtain approval from a joint EC representing those two (2) agencies—as well as complying with the CanadaFDR and the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. This joint EC is known as the HC-PHAC REB. Further, if an institution is conducting an HC- or PHAC-funded project, the HC-PHAC REB must review and approve the research even if it has been previously reviewed and approved by another EC. See CAN-35 for details on the HC-PHAC REB’s development, responsibilities, and composition. HC’s operational policy (CAN-13) outlines policies and procedures that the joint HC-PHAC REB must follow when reviewing clinical trials.
Institutional ECs are required to comply with the provisions delineated in the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, and CAN-52. Note that per CAN-50, HC-implemented ICH guidance takes precedence over other HC guidance when they are not consistent. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100. In addition, institutional ECs are guided by the G-TCPS2. Jointly developed by Canada’s three (3) federal research agencies: the Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR), the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), and the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council (SSHRC), the G-TCPS2 is a policy that sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ECs. However, only CIHR-, NSERC-, and SSHRC-funded institutions are required to comply with this guideline as a condition of funding. According to CAN-14, the CIHR, the NSERC, and the SSHRC created the Panel on Research Ethics (PRE) to promote the ethical conduct of research involving human participants. The PRE develops, interprets, and implements the G-TCPS2.
Ethics Committee Composition
As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, institutional ECs must have at least five (5) members representing a mixed gender composition, the majority of which are Canadian citizens or permanent residents, and must include:
- Two (2) members from a scientific discipline, with broad experience in the relevant research methods and areas, one (1) of whom is from a medical or dental discipline
- One (1) member knowledgeable in ethics
- One (1) member knowledgeable in relevant Canadian biomedical research laws
- One (1) member from a nonscientific discipline
- One (1) community representative
The G-TCPS2 mirrors these EC composition requirements, and also requires a Chair who is responsible for ensuring that the ethics review process conforms to the requirements of G-TCPS2. The Chair provides overall leadership for the EC and facilitates the review process based on institutional policies and procedures and the G-TCPS2. The Chair should monitor the EC’s decisions for consistency and ensure that these decisions are recorded accurately and communicated clearly to researchers in writing as soon as possible by the Chair or designate. Institutions must provide the necessary resources and adequate administrative support to enable the EC Chair to fulfill their responsibilities. As mentioned earlier, only CIHR-, NSERC-, and SSHRC-funded institutions are required to comply with this guidance as a condition of funding.
Also, see CAN-52 for additional guidance on EC composition, functions, and operations. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Terms of Reference, Review Procedures, and Meeting Schedule
According to G-TCPS2, institutions must have in place written procedures for the appointment, renewal, and removal of EC members, including Chairs. Further, institutions must have clear written policies describing the mandate of each EC. An institution may wish to use different models for the ethics review of research conducted under its auspices.
The G-TCPS2 states that an EC should have adequate expertise, experience, and training to understand the disciplines, methodologies, and approaches of the research that it considers for research ethics review. Institutions should ensure that all EC members receive appropriate education and training in ethics review of research involving humans, to enable them to fulfill their duties. This includes providing training opportunities for all members in core principles and understanding of the G-TCPS2, basic ethics standards, applicable institutional policies, and legal or regulatory requirements. It includes an understanding of the role and mandate of ECs and responsibilities of EC members. Training should be tailored to the types and complexities of the research that the EC reviews.
Per the G-TCPS2, when there is less than full attendance, decisions requiring full review should be made only when the members present have the specific expertise, relevant competence, and knowledge necessary to provide an adequate ethics review. Ad hoc advisors, observers, research ethics administration staff, and other attendees must not be counted toward quorum or permitted to vote; decisions made without quorum are not valid or binding. ECs must hold regular meetings and normally meet face to face to review research not assigned to delegated review. Where members are geographically dispersed or exceptional circumstances prevent attendance, participation by phone, videoconference, or other technology may be acceptable, provided quorum is maintained and the Chair ensures active participation. A schedule of EC meetings should be communicated to researchers, and ECs should establish a process for reaching decisions requiring full review, such as consensus or, where necessary, a vote.
G-TCPS2 indicates that proportionate review means the level of EC review is determined by the level of foreseeable risk to participants: the lower the risk, the lower the level of scrutiny through delegated review; the higher the risk, the higher the level of scrutiny through full-board review. Full EC review should be the default requirement for research involving humans. Where research is determined to involve minimal risk, an EC may authorize delegated review in accordance with its institutional policies and written procedures. Delegated reviewers may refer proposals to the full EC, and any proposed negative decision must be reviewed and endorsed by the full EC before it is communicated to the researcher. Delegated decisions must be well documented and formally reported to the full EC, which remains responsible for the ethics of all research involving humans within its jurisdiction. ECs must function impartially, provide researchers with a fair hearing, and provide reasoned and appropriately documented opinions and decisions. Approvals and refusals must be communicated in writing. Where members disagree, an effort should be made to reach consensus; if disagreement persists, the decision must be made in accordance with the EC’s agreed-upon and documented process. The EC makes the final determination regarding the nature and frequency of continuing research ethics review using a proportionate approach. At minimum, continuing review consists of an annual status report for multi-year projects and an end-of-study report for projects lasting less than one (1) year.
Regarding records, G-TCPS2 indicates that ECs must prepare and maintain comprehensive records, including all documentation related to the projects submitted to the EC for review, attendance at all EC meetings, and accurate minutes reflecting EC decisions. Where the EC denies ethics approval for a research proposal, the minutes must include the reasons for this decision. When deciding the retention period of their files, ECs should be guided by their institutional record-keeping policies and other relevant legal or regulatory requirements. Files, minutes, and other relevant documentation must be accessible to authorized representatives of the institution, researchers, sponsors, and funders when necessary to assist internal and external audits, or research monitoring, and to facilitate reconsideration or appeals. The minutes of EC meetings must clearly document the EC’s decisions, any dissents, and the reasons for them. EC decisions should be supported by clear references (e.g., date of decision, title of project), documentary basis for decision, the plan for continuing ethics review and timelines, reasons for decisions, and any conditions or limitations attached to the approval. Providing reasons for EC decisions is optional when ethics approval is granted. ECs should have written procedures for its management of record keeping and other submitted reports. EC must maintain reports and decisions on unanticipated issues or changes to approved research.
For examples of EC SOPs, see CAN-13 for the HC-PHAC REB operational policy.
Overview
As indicated in 21CFR50, 21CFR56, and 21CFR312, the United States (US) has a decentralized process for the ethics review of clinical investigations. The sponsor must obtain institutional level ethics committee (EC) approval for each study. (Note: Institutional ECs are referred to as institutional review boards (IRBs) in the US.)
As set forth in 21CFR50, 21CFR56, and 21CFR312, all clinical investigations for drug and biological products regulated by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) require institutional EC approval.
The Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule also require that human subjects research receive institutional EC approval. However, note that these regulations’ definition of “human subject” does not include the use of non-identifiable biospecimens. Therefore, the use of non-identifiable biospecimens in research does not, on its own, mandate the application of the Pre2018-ComRule to such research. However, the RevComRule does require federal departments or agencies implementing the policy to work with data experts to reexamine the meaning of “identifiable private information” and “identifiable specimen” within one (1) year of the effective date and at least every four (4) years thereafter. In particular, these agencies will collaboratively assess whether there are analytic technologies or techniques that could be used to generate identifiable private information or identifiable specimens.
(See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
Per the RevComRule, for non-exempt research (or exempt research that requires limited EC review) reviewed by an EC not operated by the institution doing the research, the institution and the EC must document the institution's reliance on the EC for research oversight and the responsibilities that each entity will undertake to ensure compliance with the RevComRule. Compliance can be achieved in a variety of ways, such as a written agreement between the institution and a specific EC, through the research protocol, or by implementing an institution-wide policy directive that allocates responsibilities between the institution and all ECs not operated by the institution. Such documentation must be part of the EC’s records. The G-HHS-Inst-Engagemt can help an institution to determine if a research study can be classified as non-exempt.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on EC composition, functions, and operations.
Ethics Committee Composition
As stated in 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, an EC must be composed of at least five (5) members with varying backgrounds to promote complete and adequate research proposal review. The EC must be sufficiently qualified through member experience, expertise, and diversity, in terms of race, gender, cultural backgrounds, and sensitivity to issues such as community attitudes, to promote respect for its advice and counsel in safeguarding human participants’ rights and welfare. EC members must possess the professional competence to review research activities and be able to ascertain the acceptability of proposed research based on institutional commitments and regulations, applicable laws, and standards. In addition, if an EC regularly reviews research involving vulnerable populations, the committee must consider including one (1) or more individuals knowledgeable about and experienced in working with those participants. See the Vulnerable Populations section for details on vulnerable populations.
At a minimum, each EC must also include the following members:
- One (1) primarily focused on scientific issues
- One (1) focused on nonscientific issues
- One (1) unaffiliated with the institution, and not part of the immediate family of a person affiliated with the institution
No EC member may participate in the initial or continuing review of any project in which the member has a conflicting interest, except to provide EC requested information.
Additionally, 21CFR56 indicates that efforts must be made to ensure that no EC consists entirely of men or entirely of women, including the institution’s consideration of qualified persons of both sexes, so long as no selection is made to the EC on the basis of gender. No EC may consist entirely of members of one (1) profession.
Terms of Reference, Review Procedures, and Meeting Schedule
As delineated in 21CFR56, ECs must follow written procedures for the following:
- Conducting initial and continuing reviews, and reporting findings and actions
- Determining which projects require review more often than annually, and which projects need verification from sources other than the investigator that no material changes have occurred since the previous EC review
- Ensuring that changes in approved research are not initiated without EC review and approval except where necessary to eliminate apparent immediate hazards to participants
- Ensuring prompt reporting to the EC, institution, and FDA of changes in research activity; unanticipated problems involving risks to participants or others; any instance of serious or continuing noncompliance with these regulations or EC requirements or determinations; or EC approval suspension/termination
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, ECs must establish and follow written procedures for the following:
- Conducting initial and continuing reviews, and reporting findings and actions to the investigator and the institution
- Determining which projects require review more often than annually, and which projects need verification from sources other than the investigator that no material changes have occurred since the previous EC review
- Ensuring prompt reporting to the EC of proposed changes in research and ensuring that investigators conduct the research in accordance with the terms of the EC approval until any proposed changes have received EC review and approval, except where necessary to eliminate apparent immediate hazards to participants
- Ensuring prompt reporting to the EC, the institution, and the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)’ Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP) of any unanticipated problems involving risks to participants or others; any instance of serious or continuing noncompliance with these regulations or EC requirements or determinations; or EC approval suspension/termination
21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule further require that an institution, or where appropriate an EC, prepare and maintain adequate documentation of EC activities, including copies of all research proposals reviewed. The applicable records must be retained for at least three (3) years after completion of the research. For more details on the EC records included in this requirement, see the Pre2018-ComRule, the RevComRule, and 21CFR56.
See G-IRBProcs for detailed FDA guidance on EC written procedures to enhance human participant protection and reduce regulatory burden. The guidance includes a Written Procedures Checklist that incorporates regulatory requirements as well as recommendations on operational details to support the requirements.
Per 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, proposed research must be reviewed during convened meetings at which a majority of the EC members are present, including at least one (1) member whose primary concerns are nonscientific, except when an expedited review procedure is used. Research is only considered approved if it receives the majority approval of attending members.
Refer to the Pre2018-ComRule, the RevComRule, 21CFR56, the G-IRBProcs, and the G-IRBFAQs for detailed EC procedural requirements.
In addition, per the Pre2018-ComRule, the RevComRule, and the G-HHS-Inst-Engagemt, any institution engaged in non-exempt human subjects research conducted or supported by a Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-65) must also submit a written assurance of compliance to OHRP. According to USA-59, the Federalwide Assurance (FWA) is the only type of assurance of compliance accepted and approved by OHRP for HHS-supported or conducted non-exempt human subjects research. See USA-57 for more information on FWAs.
Overview
According to the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, and the G-TCPS2, the primary scope of information assessed by institutional ethics committees (ECs) (called Research Ethics Boards (REBs) in Canada) relates to maintaining and protecting the dignity and rights of human research participants and ensuring their safety throughout their participation in a clinical trial. ECs must also pay special attention to reviewing informed consent and protecting the welfare of certain classes of participants deemed vulnerable.
See the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which CAN-50 indicates that Health Canada (HC) has adopted, for additional EC responsibilities and requirements. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Role in Clinical Trial Approval Process
As per the CanadaFDR, HC must approve a clinical trial application (CTA) and an institutional EC(s) must give ethical clearance prior to a sponsor initiating a clinical trial. In addition, as delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, institutional EC review for each clinical trial site may occur in parallel with HC’s CTA review and approval. Once HC completes its review, the department issues a No Objection Letter (NOL) if the CTA is approved. However, per the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, CAN-6, and CAN-30, HC will not authorize the sponsor to begin the clinical trial until an institutional EC approval for each participating trial site is submitted. The sponsor should use the Clinical Trial Site Information Form (CAN-6) to submit the required information. The CanadaFDR also states that the EC must review and approve any protocol amendments prior to those changes being implemented.
The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ECs, requires EC review and approval of research involving living human participants and human biological materials. Further, ECs must have procedures in place to receive and respond to reports of new information, including, but not limited to, safety data, unanticipated issues, and newly discovered risks.
See TCPS2-InterpReview for the Panel on Research Ethics (PRE)’s interpretations of the G-TCPS2, including on the EC’s review of secondary use of non-identifiable information, delegated review of minimal risk studies, and ongoing review.
The G-TCPS2 lays out options, procedures, and considerations for the ethics review of multi-jurisdictional research either entirely within Canada, or in Canada and other countries. An institutional EC may approve alternative review models for research with multiple ECs and/or institutions but remains responsible for the ethics and conduct of research in its jurisdiction or under its auspices regardless of where the research is conducted. The SingleECRev provides guidance on the G-TCPS2’s single EC review model for multi-jurisdictional minimal risk, which seeks to streamline the research ethics review process where additional ethics reviews are not expected to add greater participant protections. In line with a proportionate approach to research ethics review, if research is of minimal risk and spans multiple jurisdictions, institutions that have approved the use of the single EC review model authorize the review of the research by one (1) EC. See the G-TCPS2 for more information about the various review models for multi-jurisdictional research.
Per CAN-8, an attestation must be completed by the EC that reviewed and approved the clinical trial. The completed attestation must be retained by the clinical trial sponsor for a period of 15 years. The attestation should not be submitted to HC unless requested. (See the Submission Process section for detailed submission requirements.)
G-Dcntrl indicates that for clinical trials with decentralized elements a single EC can approve activities at a clinical trial site as well as decentralized trial elements. However, sponsors and qualified investigators may need to obtain their own additional provincial or institutional approvals or permissions, or meet community-specific requirements, to use institutional resources or gain access to specific locations or populations, such as Indigenous communities.
The G-TCPS2 directs the researcher to submit an annual report to enable the EC to evaluate the continued ethical acceptability of the research. Per the G-CanadaCTApps, if an EC terminates or suspends any prior approval or favorable opinion, it must document its views in writing, clearly identifying the trial, the documents reviewed, and the date for the termination or suspension.
Overview
21CFR56, 21CFR312, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule state that the primary scope of information assessed by the institutional ethics committee (EC) (referred to as an institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) relates to maintaining and protecting the dignity and rights of research participants and ensuring their safety throughout their participation in a clinical trial. As delineated in 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the EC must also pay special attention to reviewing informed consent and to protecting the welfare of certain classes of participants deemed to be vulnerable. (See the Vulnerable Populations; Children/Minors; Pregnant Women, Fetuses, & Neonates; Prisoners; and Mentally Impaired sections for additional information about these populations). The EC is also responsible for ensuring a competent review of the research protocol, evaluating the possible risks and expected benefits to participants, and verifying the adequacy of confidentiality safeguards.
See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional EC responsibilities and requirements.
Role in Clinical Trial Approval Process
In accordance with 21CFR56 and 21CFR312, the FDA must review an investigational new drug application (IND) and an EC must review and approve the proposed study prior to a sponsor initiating a clinical trial. The institutional EC review of the clinical investigation may be conducted in parallel with the FDA review of the IND. However, EC approval must be obtained prior to the sponsor being permitted to initiate the clinical trial. According to 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the EC may approve, require modifications in (to secure approval), or disapprove the research.
21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule indicate that the EC must ensure the following requirements are met prior to approving the study:
- Risks to participants are minimized and are reasonable in relation to anticipated benefits
- Participant selection is equitable
- Informed consent will be sought from each prospective participant or legal representative/guardian, and will be appropriately documented (the RevComRule also requires information regarding whether informed consent was appropriately waived)
- The research plan makes adequate provision for monitoring the data collected to ensure the safety of participants, where appropriate
- Adequate provisions are made to protect participant privacy and maintain confidentiality of data, where appropriate (per the RevComRule, the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) will issue guidance to assist ECs in assessing what provisions are adequate to protect participant privacy and maintain the confidentiality of data)
Per the RevComRule, where limited EC review applies, the EC does not need to make the determinations outlined above. Rather, limited EC review includes determinations that broad consent will be/was obtained properly, that adequate protections are in place for safeguarding the privacy and confidentiality of participants, and (for secondary studies) that individual research results will not be returned to participants. See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
See 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule for additional details on criteria for EC approval of research.
Refer to the G-RevComRule-FDA for information on the impact of the RevComRule on studies conducted or supported by the HHS that must also comply with FDA regulations.
21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule indicate that changes in approved research may not be initiated without EC review and approval except where necessary to eliminate apparent immediate hazards to participants.
Per 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, the RevComRule, and the G-IRBContRev, an EC has the authority to suspend or terminate approval of research that is not being conducted in accordance with the EC’s requirements or that has been associated with unexpected serious harm to participants. Any suspension or termination of approval will include a statement of the reasons for the EC’s action and will be reported promptly to the investigator, appropriate institutional officials, and the department or agency head (e.g., the FDA). See the G-IRBContRev for additional information and FDA recommendations on suspension or termination of EC approval.
See the G-IRBResp for FDA guidance for ECs on reviewing the adequacy of investigators and research sites, and determining if an IND or investigational device exemption is required. The FDA’s G-SubRecruit also provides guidance for ECs on reviewing participant recruitment methods.
Per the FDA’s G-IRBReview, an EC may review studies that are not performed on-site. When an institution has a local EC, the written procedures of that EC or of the institution should define the scope of studies subject to review by that EC. A non-local EC may not become the EC of record for studies within that defined scope unless the local EC or the administration of the institution agree. Any agreement to allow review by a non-local EC should be in writing. For more information, see G-IRBReview.
As stated in the G-IRBWaiver, sponsors and sponsor-investigators may request a waiver of EC requirements for drug and biological product studies regulated by the FDA. The most common circumstance for which the FDA receives a waiver request is when a sponsor wishes to conduct a foreign clinical study under an IND. In this case, typically sponsors utilize an independent ethics committee (IEC) that operates in accordance with good clinical practice (GCP). See the G-IRBWaiver for more information.
Additionally, see the G-IRBTransfer for FDA guidance on the regulatory responsibilities of ECs, clinical investigators, and sponsors when oversight of a previously approved, ongoing clinical investigation under the FDA’s jurisdiction is transferred from one (1) EC to another EC.
Expedited Review
21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule indicate that the FDA and HHS maintain a list of research categories that may be reviewed by an EC through an expedited review procedure (see the G-IRBExpdtdRev for the list). An EC may use the expedited review procedure to review the following:
- Some or all of the research appearing on the list and found by the reviewer(s) to involve no more than minimal risk
- Minor changes in previously approved research during the period (of one (1) year or less) for which approval is authorized
- Under the RevComRule, research for which limited EC review is a condition of exemption
21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule specify that under an expedited review procedure, the review may be carried out by the EC chairperson or by one (1) or more experienced reviewers designated by the chairperson from among the EC’s members. In reviewing the research, the reviewers may exercise all of the authorities of the EC except that the reviewers may not disapprove the research. A research activity may be disapproved only after review in accordance with the EC’s non-expedited review procedure.
Continuing Review and Re-approval
21CFR56 and the G-IRBContRev state that any clinical investigation must not be initiated unless the reviewed and approved study remains subject to continuing review at intervals appropriate to the degree of risk, but not less than once a year. The G-IRBContRev notes that when continuing review of the research does not occur prior to the end of the approval period specified by the EC, EC approval expires automatically. A lapse in EC approval of research occurs whenever an investigator has failed to provide continuing review information to the EC, or the EC has not conducted continuing review and re-approved the research by the expiration date of the EC approval. In such circumstances, all research activities involving human participants must stop. Enrollment of new participants cannot occur after the expiration of EC approval.
In addition, per the G-IRBContRev, research that qualified for expedited review at the time of initial review will generally continue to qualify for expedited continuing review. For additional information and FDA recommendations regarding continuing review, see the G-IRBContRev.
The Pre2018-ComRule similarly indicates that the EC must conduct reviews at intervals appropriate to the degree of risk, but not less than once per year. However, the RevComRule provides the following exceptions to the continuing review requirement, unless an EC determines otherwise:
- Research eligible for expedited review
- Research reviewed by the EC in accordance with the limited EC review described in Section 46.104 of the RevComRule
- Research that has progressed to the point that it involves data analysis and/or accessing follow-up clinical data from procedures that are part of clinical care
Exemptions under the Revised Common Rule
Per the RevComRule, certain categories of research are exempt from EC review, and some “exempt” activities require limited EC review or broad consent. Users should refer to Section 46.104 of the RevComRule for detailed information on research categories specifically exempt from EC review, or exempt activities requiring limited EC review or broad consent.
Further, the RevComRule modifies what constitutes research to specifically exclude the following types of research:
- Scholarly and journalistic activities
- Public health surveillance activities authorized by a public health authority to assess onsets of disease outbreaks or conditions of public health importance
- Collection and analysis of information, biospecimens, or records by or for a criminal justice agency for criminal investigative activities
- Authorized operational activities in support of intelligence, homeland security, defense, or other national security missions
USA-32 notes that the regulations do not specify who at an institution may determine that research is exempt, and that institutions should implement exemption policies that most effectively address the local setting and programs of research. The HHS retains final authority as to whether a particular human subjects research study conducted or supported by HHS is exempt.
See the G-IRBFAQs, the G-OHRP-IRBApprvl, and USA-32 for frequently asked questions regarding EC procedures, approval with conditions, example research, expedited review, limited review, continuing review, and exempt research.
Cooperative Research Studies
In the event of multicenter clinical studies, also known as cooperative research studies, taking place at US institutions that are subject to the RevComRule, the institutions must rely on a single EC to review that study for the portion of the study conducted in the US. The reviewing EC will be identified by the Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-18 and USA-65) supporting or conducting the research or proposed by the lead institution subject to the acceptance of the department/agency. The exceptions to this requirement include: when multicenter review is required by law (including tribal law) or for research where any federal department or agency supporting or conducting the research determines that the use of a single EC is not appropriate.
Designed to complement the RevComRule, per the NIHNotice16-094 and the NIHNotice17-076, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) issued a final policy requiring all institute-funded multicenter clinical trials conducted in the US to be overseen by a single EC, unless prohibited by any federal, tribal, or state law, regulation, or policy.
For more information on multicenter research, see the FDA’s G-CentralIRB and G-CoopRes. For more information on how new sites added to ongoing cooperative research can follow the same version of the Common Rule, see the HHS’ Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP)’s G-ComRuleCnsstncy.
Institutional ethics committees (ECs) may independently decide whether to charge fees to conduct protocol reviews. For example, an institutional EC may require industry sponsors or other for-profit organizations to pay a fee. See specific examples of institutional fee requirements in CAN-3 and CAN-1.
Many institutional ethics committees (ECs) (referred to as institutional review boards (IRBs) in the United States (US)) charge fees to review research proposals submitted by industry-sponsored research or other for-profit entities. However, this varies widely by institution. Neither the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) nor the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) regulate institutional EC review fees. Because each EC has its own requirements, individual ECs should be contacted to confirm their specific fees.
There are no applicable regulations or guidance regarding the registration, auditing, and accreditation of institutional ethics committees (ECs).
Overview
As delineated in 21CFR56 and 45CFR46-B-E, the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) and the HHS’ Food & Drug Administration (FDA) have mandatory registration programs for institutional ethics committee (ECs), referred to as institutional review boards (IRBs) in the United States (US). A single electronic registration system (USA-28) for both agencies is maintained by HHS’ Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP).
Registration, Auditing, and Accreditation
In accordance with the G-IRBReg-FAQs and USA-61, EC registration with the HHS OHRP system (USA-28) is not a form of accreditation or certification by either the FDA that the EC is in full compliance with 21CFR56, or by the HHS that the EC is in full compliance with 45CFR46-B-E. Neither EC competence nor expertise is assessed during the registration review process by either agency.
Food & Drug Administration
According to 21CFR56 and the G-IRBReg-FAQs, the FDA requires each EC in the US, that either reviews clinical investigations regulated by the agency under the FDCAct or reviews investigations intended to support research or marketing permits for agency-regulated products, to register electronically in the HHS OHRP system (USA-28). Only individuals authorized to act on the EC’s behalf are permitted to submit registration information. Non-US ECs may register voluntarily. The G-IRBReg-FAQs also indicates that while registration of non-US ECs is voluntary, the information the FDA receives from them is very helpful.
As stated in 21CFR56 and the G-IRBReg-FAQs, any EC not already registered in the HHS OHRP system (USA-28) must submit an initial registration prior to reviewing a clinical investigation in support of an investigational new drug application (IND). The HHS OHRP system (USA-28) provides instructions to assist users, depending on whether the EC is subject to regulation by only the OHRP, only the FDA, or both the OHRP and the FDA.
21CFR56 and the G-IRBReg-FAQs indicate that FDA EC registration must be renewed every three (3) years. EC registration becomes effective after review and acceptance by the HHS.
See 21CFR56 and the G-IRBReg-FAQs for detailed EC registration submission requirements.
Office for Human Research Protections
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and RevComRule, institutions engaging in research conducted or supported by a Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-18 and USA-65) must obtain an approved assurance that it will comply with the Pre2018-ComRule or RevComRule requirements and certify to the department/agency heads that the research has been reviewed and approved by an EC provided for in the assurance.
Per USA-59, a Federalwide Assurance (FWA) of compliance is a document submitted by an institution (not an EC) engaged in non-exempt human subjects research conducted or supported by HHS that commits the institution to complying with Pre2018-ComRule or RevComRule requirements. FWAs also are approved by the OHRP for federalwide use, which means that other federal departments and agencies that have adopted the Federal Policy for the Protection of Human Subjects (Pre2018-ComRule or RevComRule) may rely on the FWA for the research that they conduct or support. Institutions engaging in research conducted or supported by non-HHS federal departments or agencies should consult with the sponsoring department or agency for guidance regarding whether the FWA is appropriate for the research in question.
See USA-57 for more information on FWAs.
As stated in 45CFR46-B-E and USA-61, all ECs that review human subjects research conducted or supported by HHS and are to be designated under an OHRP FWA must register electronically with the HHS OHRP system (USA-28). EC registration becomes effective for three (3) years when reviewed and approved by OHRP. Per 45CFR46-B-E, an individual authorized to act on behalf of the institution operating the EC must submit the registration information.
Per USA-59, an institution must either register its own EC (an “internal” EC) or designate an already registered EC operated by another organization (“external” EC) after establishing a written agreement with that other organization. Additionally, each FWA must designate at least one (1) EC registered with the OHRP. The FWA is the only type of assurance of compliance accepted and approved by the OHRP.
See 45CFR46-B-E, USA-58, and USA-61 for detailed registration requirements and instructions.
Overview
In accordance with the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, Canada requires the sponsor to obtain clinical trial authorization from Health Canada (HC) prior to initiating the trial. The sponsor must file a clinical trial application (CTA) to the appropriate Directorate within HC’s Health Products and Food Branch (HPFB). In addition, as delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, the sponsor may submit a CTA for clinical trial authorization to the HC in parallel with its submission to an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as a Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada) for a favorable ethical opinion. However, per the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, CAN-6, and CAN-30, HC will not authorize the sponsor to begin the clinical trial until an institutional EC approval (provided in the required Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) form (CAN-6)) for each participating trial site is submitted. See CAN-30 for instructions on filling out and submitting CAN-6.
CAN-19 provides a full list of HC’s forms for drug-related applications and submissions. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
Regulatory Submission
Per the G-CanadaCTApps, CTAs (CAN-4) should be sent directly to the appropriate HPFB Directorate for review—the Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (PDD) for pharmaceutical drugs or the Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (BRDD) for biological drugs and radiopharmaceuticals.
The G-MDSA and the G-CanadaCTApps indicate that sponsors may request a pre-submission/application meeting with the appropriate directorate within HC if they have any questions or concerns prior to filing a CTA. Additional details on requesting a meeting and meeting procedures are available in the aforementioned guidance documents. According to CAN-4, the submission can be in French or English. For CTAs that use pharmacometric approaches, sponsors should consider the policy statements in G-Pharmacometrics. Pharmacometrics is the science of using quantitative analysis and modelling and simulation approaches to inform and enhance drug development and regulatory review. In addition, see the G-CTACell for guidance on preparing CTAs for use of cell therapy products in humans.
Per the CanadaFDR, an application by a sponsor for authorization to sell or import a drug for the purposes of a clinical trial must be submitted to HC, signed and dated by the sponsor’s senior medical or scientific officer in Canada and senior executive officer. The sponsor’s clinical trial attestation must be submitted with the application (CAN-4). For guidance on completing CAN-4, see the G-DrugApp.
Electronic Common Technical Document (eCTD) Electronic Submission
As indicated in the G-eCTD, clinical trial applications in electronic common technical document (eCTD) format are recommended, not mandatory. However, once a sponsor files a regulatory activity in eCTD format, all additional information and subsequent regulatory activities for the same dossier must be filed in eCTD format. CAN-36 explains that prior to filing the first regulatory transaction for a dossier in eCTD format, the sponsor must request a dossier ID using the online dossier ID request. Per the ElecSubms, CAN-20 is the request form for biological clinical trial dossiers and CAN-21 is for pharmaceutical clinical trial dossiers. A request for a dossier ID should be sent a maximum of eight (8) weeks prior to submitting the CTA. In addition, applicants should review the Rules-eCTD for validation rules before submission. (Note: As per ElecSubms, G-eCTD and CAN-36 are only available upon request at no-reply.ereview.non-reponse@hc-sc.gc.ca. Please ensure the text 'Request for eCTD Guidance Document' is in the subject line of the email.)
Per the G-eCTD and CAN-28, all regulatory transactions in eCTD format must be sent via the Common Electronic Submissions Gateway (CESG) (CAN-25), except for those exceeding 10 gigabytes (GB) in size. The CESG allows users to submit secure regulatory transactions electronically to HC, including CTAs. The G-eCTD and CAN-36 describe how to file CTAs and other clinical trial regulatory transactions (e.g., CTA amendments, responses to requests for information, and other in-scope activities) in eCTD format to CESG. The G-eCTD clarifies that prior to using the CESG for sending transactions, sponsors must register as a trading partner. To access and use CESG, CAN-34 instructs sponsors to follow these steps:
- Register as a trading partner with the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) at the FDA Electronic Submissions Gateway Next Generation (ESG NextGen) (CAN-51) to be able to send a regulatory transaction (Note: CAN-54 indicates that the new version of the platform, ESG NextGen, continues to support HC submissions.)
- Send regulatory transactions to HC by selecting “HC” as the center on the FDA ESG system; CTAs intended for HC will be automatically redirected.
For detailed information on how to become a trading partner and send regulatory transactions, refer to CAN-54, CAN-51, and CAN-25.
As indicated in the G-eCTD, the following media formats are acceptable for eCTD transactions greater than 10 GB: Universal Serial Bus (USB) 2.0 or 3.0 drive; or portable external hard drive with USB 2.0 or 3.0 interfaces. (Contact HC at hc.ereview.sc@canada.ca for other media formats that may be acceptable at the time of filing.) A paper copy of the cover letter must accompany the media (unless otherwise indicated), and a pre-paid envelope must be provided if the media is to be returned. The complete regulatory transaction must be provided on a single drive, and the label on the drive should contain the following information:
- Stakeholder Name
- Brand Name
- Dossier ID, which is based on the protocol number
- Sequence (regulatory transaction) number
Media must be mailed to HC at the address below:
Health Canada
Finance Building
101 Tunney’s Pasture Driveway
Address Locator: 0201A1
Ottawa, Ontario
K1A 0K9
See the G-eCTD, CAN-54, CAN-34, CAN-36, CAN-25, and CAN-28 for details on registering as a trading partner for CESG transactions, how to use CESG, and submitting CTAs in eCTD format.
Non-eCTD Electronic Submission
For non-eCTD electronic submissions, G-Non-eCTD indicates that the CTA (CAN-4) must be provided in PDF format. Other files submitted should be in PDF format, unless otherwise specified in G-Non-eCTD. PDF documents should be generated from electronic source documents and not from scanned materials, except where access to an electronic source document is unavailable or where a signature is required. Documents that are more than 10 pages should be bookmarked. Sections, subsections, tables, figures, and appendices should be bookmarked, with no more than four (4) levels of bookmarks. Hyperlinks within the same PDF document are acceptable, but hyperlinks between different documents must not be used. Stakeholders are responsible for ensuring that hyperlinks function, and links must also include references to the applicable section or page. Documents that legally require signatures may be signed electronically, or the signature page may be printed, signed, scanned, and saved as a PDF. If only one (1) page of a multi-page document contains a signature, the scanned page should be included in the same location in the PDF. Each document should have only one (1) PDF file. The cover letter does not require a signature but should include the printed name, phone number, and email address of the contact person.
As explained in G-Non-eCTD, all regulatory transactions should be validated before being transmitted to HC. For the applicable requirements, including validation rules, see the Rules-Non-eCTD. Initial CTAs and CTA-As should be submitted on electronic media, accompanied by a paper copy of the cover letter, and sent directly to the Office of Clinical Trials within PDD for pharmaceuticals or the Office of Regulatory Affairs within BRDD for biologics and radiopharmaceuticals. The ElecSubms contains a zip file of the folder structure for clinical trial non-eCTD submissions. (Note: As per ElecSubms, G-Non-eCTD is only available upon request at no-reply.ereview.non-reponse@hc-sc.gc.ca. Please ensure the text 'non eCTD Guidance Document' is in the subject line of the email.)
Per the G-Non-eCTD, CTA submissions to the appropriate Directorate within HC’s HPFB must be in one (1) of these accepted media formats:
- Compact Disc-Recordable (CD-R) conforming to the Joliet specification
- USB 2.0 or 3.0 drive
- Digital Versatile Disc (DVD-RAM and DVD+R/-R) in Universal Disk Format (UDF) standard
All media should be labelled and contain the following information:
- Stakeholder Name
- Brand Name
Subsequent to burning the CD/DVD or transferring data to a drive, applicants should ensure that all files can be opened, files are not corrupted, and that "Thumb.db" files are removed.
As per the G-Non-eCTD, G-MDSA, CAN-18, and CAN-17, non-eCTD CTAs involving pharmaceutical drugs should be sent to PDD, and CTAs involving biologics and/or radiopharmaceuticals should be sent to BRDD at the addresses listed below (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
Office of Clinical Trials
Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate
Health Canada
5th Floor, Holland Cross, Tower B
1600 Scott Street
Address Locator: 3105A
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
K1A 0K9
General Inquiries E-mail: oct.enquiries-requetes.bec@hc-sc.gc.ca
Office of Regulatory Affairs
Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate
Health Products and Food Branch
Ground Floor, Health Canada Building 6
100 Eglantine Driveway
Tunney’s Pasture
Address Locator: 0601C
Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
K1A 0K9
Telephone: 613-957-1722
E-mail: brdd.ora@hc-sc.gc.ca
Per the G-Non-eCTD, if an applicant submits a non-eCTD CTA via email, they should meet the following requirements:
- The maximum email size accepted by the corporate mail server is 20 megabytes. If the clinical trial submission is larger than 20 megabytes, the submission may be split and sent as separate emails (e.g., an email for Module 1, and another email for Module 2/3). The subject line of the emails should clearly link to each other (e.g., "Email 1 of 2" in the relevant subject line)
- A duplicate copy must not be provided by mail
- The submission should be organized in folders and the body of the email should only contain the zipped regulatory submission
- Zipped files and documents contained in the email should not be password protected
The G-Non-eCTD provides additional information on emailing other clinical trial submissions, including responses to a clarification request, responses to a no objection letter, notifications, and development safety update reports.
Ethics Review Submission
As indicated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, all research involving human participants in Canada must be reviewed by an institutional ethics committee (EC). (Note: institutional ECs are referred to as Research Ethics Boards (REBs) in Canada.) Because the submission process at individual institutional ECs will vary, applicants should review and follow their institution’s specific requirements. Further, Canadian provinces may have varying requirements, and, therefore, the sponsor should consult with the applicable province(s) for more information. CAN-35 delineates submission requirements to the joint HC-Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)’s EC. This joint EC reviews all research involving human subjects that is carried out by HC or PHAC researchers on the premises or in collaboration with external researchers.
Overview
As delineated in 21CFR312, USA-42, and USA-52, the United States (US) requires the sponsor to submit an investigational new drug application (IND) for the Food & Drug Administration (FDA)'s review and authorization to obtain an exemption to ship investigational drug or biological products across state lines and to administer these investigational products in humans. Per 21CFR312 and the G-IND-Determination, whether an IND is required to conduct an investigation of a drug to be marketed (this includes biological products under the FDCAct) primarily depends on the intent of the investigation, and the degree of risk associated with the use of the drug in the investigation. See the Scope of Assessment section for more information.
In addition, per 21CFR56 and 21CFR312, institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the US) review of the clinical investigation may be conducted in parallel with the FDA review of the IND. However, EC approval must be obtained prior to the sponsor being permitted to initiate the clinical trial.
Regulatory Submission
According to 21CFR312, meetings between a sponsor and the FDA may be useful in resolving questions and issues raised during the course of a clinical investigation. The FDA encourages such meetings to the extent that they aid in the evaluation of the drug and in the solution of scientific problems concerning the drug, to the degree the FDA's resources permit. See 21CFR312 for more information on meetings with the FDA.
A sponsor who is conducting a clinical trial to support a future marketing application may ask to meet with the FDA for a special protocol assessment (SPA) to help ensure the clinical trial can support the application. For more information, see G-SPA.
Additionally, the G-FDAComm describes the FDA’s philosophy regarding timely interactive communication with IND sponsors, the scope of appropriate interactions between review teams and sponsors, the types of advice appropriate for sponsors to seek from the FDA in pursuing their drug development programs, and general expectations for the timing of FDA response to sponsor inquiries. See the G-FDAComm for more information.
According to the G-PharmeCTD, which implements FDCAct requirements, and as described in USA-34 and USA-53, commercial IND submissions must be submitted in the Electronic Common Technical Document (eCTD) format. Noncommercial INDs are exempt from this eCTD format submission requirement. “Noncommercial products” refer to products not intended to be distributed commercially, including investigator-sponsored INDs and expanded access INDs (e.g., emergency use and treatment INDs). However, the G-AltrntElecSubs indicates that sponsors and applicants who receive an exemption or a waiver from filing in eCTD format should still provide those exempted or waived submissions electronically, in an alternate format.
As stated in USA-34, the electronic submission of eCTD v4.0 to the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) or Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER) is supported for new INDs, as well as certain other submission types, beginning September 16, 2024. Only new applications may be submitted in v4.0, and forward compatibility functionality is not yet available. Electronic submissions made in eCTD format must utilize either v3.2.2 or v4.0, which are both currently supported by the FDA.
The G-AltrntElecSubs and USA-35 indicate that for both eCTD and alternate electronic formats, submissions should include only FDA fillable forms and electronic signatures. Scanned images of FDA fillable forms should not be submitted. In addition, before making an electronic submission, a pre-assigned application number should be obtained by contacting CBER or CDER. See USA-35 for more information on requesting an application number.
For more information and detailed requirements on eCTD submissions, see the G-PharmeCTD, USA-34, USA-35, and USA-36. Additionally, the G-CBER-ElecINDs provides instructions on how to submit an IND using an electronic folder structure on a CD-ROM.
According to the G-eCTDspecs, eCTD submissions sized 10 GB and under for most applications must be submitted via the Electronic Submissions Gateway (ESG), and the FDA also recommends the use of the ESG for submissions greater than 10 GB when possible. However, USA-44 specifies that the Electronic Submissions Gateway Next Generation (ESG NextGen) should be utilized for all electronic submissions to the FDA. See USA-102 for the ESG NextGen Unified Submission Portal (USP) Login and USA-37 for ESG NextGen submission user guides.
As indicated in the G-eCTDspecs, the FDA also accepts physical electronic media on a USB drive for submissions greater than 10 GB. For specific instructions on how to submit physical electronic media, email CDER at esub@fda.hhs.gov or CBER at esubprep@fda.hhs.gov. See the G-eCTDspecs for additional physical electronic media information.
The IND must be submitted in English. As indicated in 21CFR312, the sponsor must submit an accurate and complete English translation of each part of the IND that is not in English. The sponsor must also submit a copy of each original literature publication for which an English translation is submitted.
Based on information provided in 21CFR312, for paper IND submissions, the sponsor must submit an original and two (2) copies, including the original submission and all amendments and reports. According to USA-41 and USA-94, paper submissions of INDs should be sent to CDER or CBER at the following locations, as appropriate:
Drugs (submitted by Sponsor-Investigators):
Food and Drug Administration
Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER)
Central Document Room
5901-B Ammendale Rd.
Beltsville, MD 20705-1266
Therapeutic Biological Product (submitted by Sponsor-Investigators):
Food and Drug Administration
Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER)
Therapeutic Biological Products Document Room
5901-B Ammendale Rd.
Beltsville, MD 20705-1266
Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research-Regulated Products:
Food and Drug Administration
Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER)
Document Control Center
10903 New Hampshire Avenue
WO71, G112
Silver Spring, MD 20993-0002
(Note: Per USA-94, CBER also accepts electronic media via mail, but electronic or email submission is preferred.)
For more information on CDER and CBER internal policies and procedures for accepting and reviewing applications, see USA-96 and USA-95, respectively.
Ethics Review Submission
Each EC maintains its own procedures and processes for review. Consequently, there is no stated regulatory requirement for clinical trial submission processes.
Regulatory Authority Requirements
As set forth in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, Health Canada (HC) requires the sponsor to apply for clinical trial authorization by submitting a clinical trial application (CTA) to HC. As specified in the G-CanadaCTApps and the G-QCM-PharmCTAs, the CTA should be organized into three (3) modules in Common Technical Document (CTD) format:
- Module 1 - Administrative and clinical information about the proposed trial
- Module 2 - Quality (Chemistry and Manufacturing) summaries about the drug product(s) to be used in the proposed trial
- Module 3 - Additional supporting quality information
Per the CanadaFDR, the clinical trial application form (CAN-4) and the following information and documents must be submitted:
- Protocol
- Summary of potential risks/benefits
- Clinical trial attestation that includes drug information (chemistry, names, classifications, dosage, therapeutic purpose, human-sourced excipient, drug identification number or notice of compliance, manufacturing information); sponsor’s contact information; if the drug is to be imported, contact information for the sponsor’s representative in Canada who is responsible for the sale of the drug; and contact information for the qualified investigator at each site, if known at the time of submittal
- Contact information for each institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada) that approved the protocol, if known at the time of submitting the application (provided in the required Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) form (CAN-6))
- Contact information of any institutional EC that previously refused to approve the protocol, its reasons, and refusal date
- Investigator’s Brochure (IB)
- Informed consent form (ICF)
- Information about use of a human-sourced excipient
- Chemistry and manufacturing information
- Proposed date for trial commencement at each site, if known
Per the Mdrn-CTFrmwrk, for multi-site trials operating within a streamlined multi-site ethics review process, sponsors sometimes identify the same EC for all clinical trial sites. When providing information on a new site through CAN-6, sponsors only need to include the contact information for an EC once, as long as:
- The same EC has previously been identified as having approved other sites in that trial
- The EC's contact information has already been provided to HC in the context of the clinical trial, and continues to be up to date
Accordingly, as indicated in the Mdrn-CTFrmwrk, the form's section on EC approval may only contain the name of the approving board and the date of its approval.
Refer to the CanadaFDR, the G-FDR-0100, the G-CanadaCTApps, the G-DrugApp, the G-QltyBioCTs, and the G-QCM-PharmCTAs for detailed submission information.
Ethics Committee Requirements
Each institutional EC has its own application form and clearance requirements, which can differ significantly regarding the number of copies to be supplied and application format requirements.
The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ECs, requires clinical trial researchers to submit their research proposals for EC review and approval of their ethical acceptability prior to the start of recruitment of participants, data collection, access to data or collection of human biological materials. Researchers must submit sufficient details to enable the EC to make an informed review of the ethical acceptability of the research. In addition, they should include a plan for monitoring safety, efficacy/effectiveness (where feasible), and validity in their proposal for EC review. This plan must describe:
- How participant safety will be monitored and what actions will be taken in the event of a threat to participant safety
- How intervention efficacy will be monitored (where feasible) and what actions will be taken if efficacy is found to be greater than expected
- The criteria by which participants may be removed from a study for safety reasons
- The study-wide stopping rules (if any) by which studies may be stopped or amended due to evidence of inferior safety, superior efficacy or futility
- The reporting procedure that will be followed to ensure any information relevant to participant welfare or consent is reported clearly and in a timely fashion to the EC
See CAN-35 for submission requirements to the joint HC-Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)'s REB. This joint EC reviews all research involving human subjects that is carried out by HC or PHAC researchers, on the premises, or in collaboration with external researchers.
Clinical Protocol
The CanadaFDR requires submission of a clinical trial protocol. Per G-FDR-0100, a protocol should describe the objectives, design, methodology, statistical considerations and organization of a clinical trial, and it should be consistent with the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52). The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence. CAN-50 indicates that HC adopted CAN-52.
Regulatory Authority Requirements
As specified in 21CFR312, an investigational new drug application (IND) to the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) must include the following documents, in the order provided below:
- Cover sheet (Form FDA 1571 (USA-76)) (including, but not limited to: sponsor contact information, investigational product (IP) name, application date, phase(s) of clinical investigation to be conducted, and commitment that the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) will conduct initial and continuing review and approval of each study proposed in the investigation)
- Table of contents
- Introductory statement and general investigational plan
- Investigator’s brochure (IB)
- Protocols
- Chemistry, manufacturing, and control data
- Pharmacology and toxicology data
- Previous human experience with the IP
- Additional information (e.g., drug dependence and abuse potential, radioactive drugs, pediatric studies)
- Relevant information (e.g., foreign language materials and number of copies - see Submission Process section for details)
For detailed application requirements, see 21CFR312. In addition, see USA-40 for other IND forms and instructions. Also see USA-100 for Phase 1 IND resources, and USA-39 for information on first in human Phase 1 INDs.
Furthermore, for information on the appropriate use of adaptive designs for clinical trials and additional information to provide to the FDA to support its review, see G-AdaptiveTrials.
The G-RWDRWE-Doc states that to facilitate the FDA’s internal tracking of submissions that include real-world data (RWD) and real-world evidence (RWE), sponsors and applicants are encouraged to identify in their submission cover letters certain uses of RWD/RWE. For more information, see the G-RWDRWE-Doc.
According to the G-PedStudyPlans, a sponsor who is planning to submit to the FDA a marketing application (or supplement to an application) for a new active ingredient, new indication, new dosage form, new dosing regimen, or new route of administration is required to submit an initial pediatric study plan (iPSP), if required by the Pediatric Research Equity Act (PREA). An exception to this is if the drug is for an indication granted an orphan designation. For additional details and recommendations to sponsors regarding the submission of an iPSP, see the G-PedStudyPlans.
See 21CFR312 and the G-IPCharge for additional submission requirements if a sponsor is seeking FDA authorization to charge for the use of its own IP in a clinical trial.
Ethics Committee Requirements
Each EC has its own application form and clearance requirements, which can differ regarding application content requirements.
Clinical Protocol
Per the NIHNotice17-064, and as provided in USA-29 and USA-27, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and the FDA developed a clinical trial protocol template with instructional and example text for NIH-funded investigators to use when writing protocols for phase 2 and 3 clinical trials that require IND applications.
Additionally, the G-DecentralCT provides FDA recommendations for clinical trials with decentralized elements. According to the G-DecentralCT, the protocol should include specific instructions for limiting variability in the data collected. The protocol should specify which visits will be conducted at traditional clinical trial sites, which visits will be conducted remotely, and which visits can be left to participants’ choice. See the G-DecentralCT for additional guidance.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on clinical protocol contents.
Overview
As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, the review and approval of a clinical trial application (CTA) by Health Canada (HC) and an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada) may be conducted in parallel. However, per the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, CAN-6, and CAN-30, HC will not authorize the sponsor to begin the clinical trial until an institutional EC approval (provided in the required Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) form) for each participating trial site is submitted. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
Regulatory Authority Approval
According to the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, an authorized clinical trial is one that has been filed with HC and has not received an objection within 30 days. All CTAs are subject to the 30-day default period from the date of receipt of the completed application at the appropriate Directorate within HC’s Health Products and Food Branch (HPFB). While the Directorates can establish shorter administrative targets of seven (7) days for the review of bioequivalence trials, the 30-day default system remains the regulatory requirement. Applications to conduct Phase I clinical trials using somatic cell therapies, xenografts, gene therapies, prophylactic vaccines, or reproductive and genetic technologies are not included in the seven-day target system. Please see the G-CanadaCTApps for special requirements regarding reviews of comparative bioavailability studies and joint reviews of clinical trials covering a combination of devices, biologics, and pharmaceuticals.
As specified in the G-CanadaCTApps and the G-MDSA, during the review period, the Directorate may request additional information from the sponsor, who has two (2) calendar days to provide such information. The G-MDSA clarifies that, where warranted, HC can adjust the timelines to be longer or shorter based on the complexity of the request, communications with the sponsor, and/or circumstances of the review, including pausing the clock during the scientific review. The G-CanadaCTApps also states that HC will issue a Not Satisfactory Notice (NSN) if a timely response to requested information has not been provided. The G-MDSA indicates that the review of the submission will stop on the date the NSN is sent.
Ethics Committee Approval
The EC review and approval process timeline varies by institution. The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ECs, recommends a proportionate approach to ethics review—the lower the level of risk, the lower the level of scrutiny (delegated review); the higher the level of risk, the higher the level of scrutiny (full board review). In either case, pursuant to the G-TCPS2, the institutional EC should make its decisions in an efficient and timely manner.
See CAN-35 for ethics review timelines with the joint HC-Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC)'s EC. This joint EC reviews all research involving human subjects that is carried out by HC or PHAC researchers, on the premises, or in collaboration with external researchers.
Overview
As delineated in 21CFR56 and 21CFR312, institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) review of the clinical investigation may be conducted in parallel with the Food & Drug Administration (FDA)'s review of the investigational new drug application (IND). However, EC approval must be obtained prior to the sponsor being permitted to initiate the clinical trial.
Regulatory Authority Approval
Per the FDCAct and 21CFR312, initial INDs submitted to the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research (CDER) or Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER) automatically go into effect in 30 calendar days, unless the FDA notifies the sponsor that the IND is subject to a clinical hold, or the FDA has notified the sponsor earlier that the trial may begin. As indicated in 21CFR312, the FDA will provide the sponsor with a written explanation of the basis for the hold as soon as possible, and no more than 30 days after the imposition of the clinical hold. See 21CFR312 for more information on clinical hold timelines. For more information on CDER and CBER internal policies and procedures for reviewing applications, see USA-96 and USA-95, respectively.
According to USA-41 and USA-42, clinical studies must not be initiated until 30 days after the FDA receives the IND, unless the FDA provides earlier notification that studies may begin.
Ethics Committee Approval
Each EC maintains its own procedures and processes for review. Consequently, there is no stated regulatory requirement for a standard timeline of review and approval of the clinical trial.
Overview
In accordance with the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, a clinical trial can only commence after the sponsor receives authorization from both Health Canada (HC) and an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada). No waiting period is required following the applicant’s receipt of these approvals. CAN-30 specifies that for purposes of the Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) Form (CAN-6), the trial commencement date is the date when the clinical trial site is ready to enroll participants. The commencement date is a date after which the sponsor has both the HC authorization from the appropriate Directorate (date on the No Objection Letter (NOL) or the date of the Notice of Authorization) and approval from the relevant EC. Further, the commencement date would be the date when the sponsor implements the protocol, which includes the screening period that occurs prior to the check-in date. See the Scope of Review section for detailed institutional EC requirements, and the Submission Content section for additional HC approval information. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
In addition, per the G-CanadaCTApps, if a sponsor (Canadian or foreign) wants to import a drug into Canada to conduct a clinical trial, a copy of HC’s clinical trial authorization (i.e., the NOL) must be included with the drug shipment. According to the G-CanadaCTApps and CAN-32, if a sponsor plans to import investigational drugs directly to each trial site, then the sponsor must also authorize the importer (i.e., the clinical trial site) when submitting the clinical trial application using Appendix I of HC’s Drug Submission Application Form (CAN-4). See the Manufacturing & Import section for detailed import requirements.
Clinical Trial Agreement
Prior to initiating trial activities, as delineated in the G-FDR-0100, agreements made by the sponsor with the qualified investigator, institution, service providers, and any other parties (e.g., independent data monitoring committee or adjudication committee) involved with the clinical trial should be documented. The sponsor is also responsible for obtaining agreements from all involved parties to permit monitoring and auditing by sponsors, inspections by regulatory authorities (domestic and foreign) and review by ECs, including providing direct access to source records and facilities, including those of service providers. Any of the sponsor's trial-related activities that are transferred to and assumed by a service provider should be documented in an agreement. The sponsor's trial-related activities that are not specifically transferred to and assumed by a service provider are retained by the sponsor.
In accordance with the G-CanadaCTApps, prior to initiating a clinical trial, the sponsor must ensure that a Qualified Investigator Undertaking (QIU) form (CAN-37 or similar documentation that meets the CanadaFDR requirements) has been completed and is kept on file by the sponsor. Per the CanadaFDR, the form certifies that the QI will conduct the clinical trial in accordance with good clinical practice and will immediately inform trial participants and the institutional EC of trial discontinuance and the reason for this discontinuance. If there is a change in the QI at a site, a new CTSI Form must be submitted to HC, and a new QIU form must be maintained by the sponsor.
G-Dcntrl indicates that sponsors and QIs are responsible for ensuring that all agreements supporting decentralized trial activities clearly define roles, responsibilities, and oversight expectations. Trial-related activities delegated to service providers should be documented in written agreements that establish how tasks will be performed, supervised, and documented; investigational products and data will be managed; and compliance with regulations and good clinical practice will be maintained.
See CAN-6, CAN-8, and CAN-19 for additional clinical trial forms. Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Clinical Trial Registration
As per the CT-Rgstrn, sponsors should register their clinical trial before it has opened for enrollment in Canada but no later than 21 calendar days after the date of enrollment of the first participant. HC considers the registration date as the date when the clinical trial registration materials are first submitted to a registry. For a multi-national clinical trial with one (1) or more Canadian sites, sponsors should add the Canadian site(s) to their existing registry record. Ideally, this should be done before opening for enrollment, but no later than 21 calendar days after the date of enrollment of the first participant at the Canadian site(s). Sponsors should register their clinical trial with an international clinical trial registry that complies with World Health Organization (WHO) international standards, including the International Clinical Trials Registry Platform (ICTRP) (CAN-60). Two (2) widely used registries that are publicly accessible and part of the WHO network are ClinicalTrials.gov (CAN-45), and the International Standardized Randomized Controlled Trial Number (ISRCTN) Registry (CAN-46). Sponsors should include the protocol code/number in their registry record.
Also see HC’s Clinical Trial Search Portal (CAN-59), which is a search tool to find information about Canadian clinical trials. It is not a registry, but some of the information is collected directly from international registries.
Overview
In accordance with 21CFR312, USA-41, and USA-42, a clinical trial can only commence after the investigational new drug application (IND) is reviewed by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA), which will provide a written determination within 30 days of receiving the IND. No waiting period is required following the 30-day FDA review period, unless the agency imposes a clinical hold on the IND or sends an earlier notification that studies may begin. Per 21CFR312 and 21CFR56, ethics approval from an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) is also required before a clinical trial can commence.
As per 21CFR312, once an IND has been submitted and following the 30-day review period, the sponsor is permitted to import an investigational product (IP). (See the Manufacturing & Import section for additional information).
See the G-CTPrtcptn for FDA guidance on enrollment practices to enhance participation in clinical trials.
Clinical Trial Agreement
Prior to the trial’s commencement, as addressed in the 21CFR312 and the G-1572FAQs, the sponsor must obtain from the investigator(s) a signed Statement of Investigator, Form FDA 1572 (USA-77). This form serves as the investigator’s agreement to provide certain information to the sponsor and to ensure compliance with the FDA’s clinical investigation regulations. Refer to the 21CFR312, the G-1572FAQs, and USA-40 for further information.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on clinical trial agreements.
Clinical Trial Registration
The FDAMA, the FDAAA, and 42CFR11 require the responsible party, either the sponsor or the principal investigator (PI) designated by the sponsor, to register electronically with the ClinicalTrials.gov databank (USA-78). Per the FDAAA and 42CFR11, the sponsor/PI must register no later than 21 calendar days after the first human participant is enrolled in a trial.
42CFR11 expands the legal requirements for submitting clinical trial registration information and results for investigational products that are approved, licensed, or cleared by the FDA. See the G-3674Cert for additional FDA guidance on certifying compliance with applicable requirements, including the requirement to register applicable clinical trials.
The National Institutes of Health (NIH) issued NIHTrialInfo to complement 42CFR11 requirements. This policy requires all NIH-funded awardees and investigators conducting clinical trials, funded in whole or in part by the NIH, regardless of study phase, type of intervention, or whether they are subject to the regulation, to ensure that they register and submit trial results to ClinicalTrials.gov (USA-78). See USA-98 for the NIH’s definition of a clinical trial.
See 42CFR11, the NIHTrialInfo, and USA-49 for detailed information on ClinicalTrials.gov (USA-78). See also the FDA’s G-DataBankPnlty for clarification on the types of civil money penalties that may be issued for failing to register a clinical trial.
Safety Reporting Definitions
According to the CanadaFDR and G-CanadaCTApps, the following definitions provide a basis for a common understanding of Canada’s safety reporting requirements:
- Adverse Event (AE) – Any adverse occurrence in the health of a clinical trial participant who is administered a drug that may or may not be caused by the administration of the drug, and includes an adverse drug reaction.
- Adverse Drug Reaction (ADR) – Any noxious and unintended response to a drug that is caused by the administration of any dose of the drug.
- Serious Adverse Drug Reaction (SADR) or Serious Adverse Event (SAE) – Any untoward medical occurrence that at any dose: results in death, is life threatening, requires hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization, results in persistent or significant disability or incapacity, or causes a congenital anomaly/birth defect.
- Serious, Unexpected ADR – A serious ADR that is not identified in nature, severity, or frequency in the risk information set out in the investigator’s brochure or on the label of the drug.
The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ethics committees (ECs), requires researchers to promptly report new information revealed during the conduct of the trial that might affect the welfare or consent of participants to the EC, to a publicly accessible registry, and to other appropriate regulatory or advisory bodies. In addition, when new information is relevant to participants’ welfare, researchers must promptly inform all participants to whom the information applies (including former participants). Researchers must work with their ECs to determine which participants must be informed, and how the information should be conveyed.
For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100. Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Safety Reporting Requirements
Investigator Responsibilities
Per the G-FDR-0100, the collection, assessment, and reporting of AEs is a critical component of the conduct of any clinical trial. The assessment of the site AEs should be done by the qualified investigator (QI) or the delegated sub-investigator(s) for seriousness, expectedness, and causality determination, when they become aware. All SAEs should be reported immediately (after the QI reasonably becomes aware of the event) to the sponsor. The QI should also include an assessment of causality. In accordance with applicable regulatory requirements, the protocol may identify SAEs not requiring immediate reporting; for example, deaths or other events that are endpoints. Subsequent information should be submitted as a follow-up report, as necessary.
Sponsor Responsibilities
As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, the sponsor is required to expedite reports of ADRs to HC that meet these three (3) criteria: serious, unexpected, and having a suspected causal relationship. ADR reports that are expected or unexpected, but not serious, should not be reported to HC, but rather monitored and tracked by the sponsor. As specified in the G-CanadaCTApps, when evaluating whether an AE is serious and unexpected, the QI’s and sponsor’s determination of causality is important. Only serious and unexpected ADRs found to have a reasonable suspected causal relationship with the drug should be reported by the sponsor to HC.
Per the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, during a clinical trial, the sponsor is required to inform HC of any serious, unexpected ADR that has occurred inside or outside Canada. An ADR report must be filed in the following specified timelines:
- When the ADR is neither fatal nor life-threatening, within 15 days after becoming aware of the information
- When it is fatal or life-threatening, immediately when possible and, in any event, within seven (7) days after becoming aware of the information
- Within eight (8) days after having informed HC of the ADR, submit a report that includes an assessment of the importance and implication of any findings
Other Safety Reports
The G-DSUR delineates that the development safety update report (DSUR) and the DSUR Checklist (CAN-38) should be provided when requested by HC. A DSUR may be submitted voluntarily to HC when important new safety information on a drug needs to be conveyed by a clinical trial sponsor. In these cases, a rationale/justification for the filing of the DSUR should be included in the cover letter. For additional details, see the G-DSUR.
The G-DSUR-CanUK describes the region-specific requirements for DSURs submitted to the regulatory authorities of Canada and the United Kingdom. This guidance applies to both marketed and non-marketed drugs that are used in clinical trials and applies to DSURs prepared by the manufacturer and/or marketing authorization holder of the investigational drug.
Form Completion & Delivery Requirements
As per the G-CanadaCTApps, all serious and unexpected ADRs should be reported individually to HC. According to CAN-48 (which Canada adopted pursuant to CAN-50), at a minimum, the report should include an identifiable patient, the name of a suspect medicinal product, an identifiable reporting source, and an event or outcome that can be identified as serious and unexpected and for which, in clinical investigation cases, there is a reasonable suspected causal relationship. The G-CanadaCTApps requires the sponsor to complete the expedited reporting form (CAN-5) and the CIOMS Form I (CAN-7) and fax them to the appropriate HC Directorate: BRDD Fax: 613-957-0364; PDD Fax: 613-941-2121.
Additionally, the G-DSUR indicates that HC recommends that DSURs in electronic Common Technical Document (eCTD) format be submitted via the Common Electronic Submissions Gateway (CESG) (CAN-25). For information on eCTD format, refer to the ElecSubms. For technical questions on eCTD filings, contact ereview@hc-sc.gc.ca as instructed in the G-DSUR.
Safety Reporting Definitions
In accordance with 21CFR312, the G-SpnsrRpt, the G-InvstRpt, the US-ICH-E2A, 42CFR11, and USA-99, the following definitions provide a basis for a common understanding of safety reporting requirements in the United States (US) (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
- Adverse Event – Any untoward medical occurrence associated with the use of a drug in humans, whether or not considered drug related
- Suspected Adverse Reaction – Any adverse event where there is a reasonable possibility that the drug caused the adverse event
- Adverse Reaction – Any adverse event caused by a drug. Adverse reactions are a subset of all suspected adverse reactions where there is reason to conclude that the drug caused the event
- Serious Adverse Event (SAE)/Serious Suspected Adverse Reaction – An adverse event/suspected adverse reaction that results in death, is life-threatening, requires inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization, causes persistent or significant disability/incapacity, results in a congenital anomaly/birth defect, or leads to a substantial disruption of the participant’s ability to conduct normal life functions
- Unexpected Adverse Event/Unexpected Suspected Adverse Reaction – An adverse event/suspected adverse reaction that is not listed in the investigator’s brochure (IB), or is not listed at the specificity or severity that has been observed in the study population; or if an IB is not required or available, is not consistent with the risk information described in the general investigational plan or elsewhere in the application
- Life-threatening Adverse Event/Life-threatening Suspected Adverse Reaction – An adverse event/suspected adverse reaction is considered “life-threatening” if, in the view of either the investigator or sponsor, its occurrence places the participant at immediate risk of death. It does not include an adverse event/suspected adverse reaction that, had it occurred in a more severe form, might have caused death
According to the G-HHS-AEReqs, the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)’s 45CFR46 regulations (the Pre2018-ComRule, the RevComRule, and 45CFR46-B-E) do not define the terms “adverse event” or “unanticipated problems.” However, the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule do contain requirements relevant to reviewing and reporting these incidents. See the G-HHS-AEReqs, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule for further information.
See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
Additionally, see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for guidance on safety reporting.
Safety Reporting Requirements
Investigator Responsibilities
As delineated in 21CFR312 and the G-InvstRpt, the investigator must comply with the following reporting requirements:
- SAEs, whether or not considered drug related, must be reported immediately to the sponsor
- Study endpoints that are SAEs must be reported in accordance with the protocol unless there is evidence suggesting a causal relationship between the drug and the event. In that case, the investigator must immediately report the event to the sponsor
- Non-SAEs must be recorded and reported to the sponsor according to the protocol specified timetable
- Report promptly to the ethics committee (EC) all unanticipated problems involving risk to human participants or others
The G-InvstRpt adds that although the investigator must immediately report any SAE to the sponsor, more data may be collected and submitted after submitting the initial report. For the purposes of the G-InvstRpt, the FDA interprets “immediately” to be as soon as feasible after the investigator recognizes an event is an SAE and obtains relevant information for the sponsor. The FDA recommends that this timeframe for submitting initial information also be specified in the protocol and anticipates that the timeframe for submission of initial information will generally not exceed one (1) calendar day.
Sponsor Responsibilities
As delineated in 21CFR312, the G-SpnsrRpt, and USA-99, the sponsor must report in an investigational new drug application (IND) safety report any suspected adverse reaction or adverse reaction that is both serious and unexpected. An adverse event is only required to be reported as a suspected adverse reaction if there is evidence to suggest a causal relationship between the drug and the adverse event. The sponsor is required to notify the FDA and all participating investigators in a written safety report of potential serious risks, from clinical trials or any other source, as soon as possible, but no later than 15 calendar days after the sponsor determines the information qualifies for reporting. Additionally, the sponsor must notify the FDA of any unexpected fatal or life-threatening suspected adverse reaction as soon as possible, but no later than seven (7) calendar days following receipt of the information. Any relevant information obtained by the sponsor that pertains to a previously submitted IND safety report must be submitted as a follow-up IND safety report. This report should be submitted without delay, as soon as the information is available, but no later than 15 calendar days after the sponsor initially receives the information.
Per 21CFR312, the G-SpnsrRpt, and USA-99,the sponsor must also report the following to the FDA in an IND safety report:
- Any findings from animal or in vitro testing, epidemiological studies, pooled analyses of multiple studies, or clinical studies (other than those reported in the safety report) that suggest a significant risk in humans exposed to the drug, regardless of whether they are conducted under the IND or by the sponsor
- Any clinically important increase in the rate of a serious suspected adverse reaction over that listed in the protocol or IB
In each IND safety report, the sponsor must identify all IND safety reports previously submitted to the FDA concerning a similar suspected adverse reaction and must analyze the significance of the suspected adverse reaction in light of previous, similar reports, or any other relevant information. Refer to 21CFR312, the G-SpnsrRpt, and USA-99 for more details on these safety reporting requirements.
The G-SpnsrRpt notes that the sponsor is ultimately responsible for evaluating the available information and deciding whether there is a reasonable possibility that the drug caused the adverse event, and therefore that the event meets the definition of a suspected adverse reaction. Aggregate analyses are needed for (1) anticipated SAEs for which it is difficult or impossible to make a causal determination based on a single case or a small number of cases; or (2) expected serious suspected adverse reactions that must be reported if there is a clinically important increase in the rate over that described in the protocol or IB. See the G-SpnsrRpt for additional FDA guidance on aggregate analyses.
The FDA’s G-DecentralCT indicates that to protect the safety and welfare of trial participants in a decentralized clinical trial, sponsors should implement a safety monitoring plan that takes the decentralized nature of the clinical trial into account and ensures that adverse events and medication errors are appropriately collected and adequately addressed. As in any clinical trial, the safety monitoring plan should describe how participants are expected to respond to and report adverse events, including where to seek medical assistance locally when necessary, and where to receive follow-up care. See the G-DecentralCT for more information.
As part of the clinical trial results information submitted to ClinicalTrials.gov (USA-78), 42CFR11 requires the responsible party, either the sponsor or the principal investigator (PI) designated by the sponsor, to submit three (3) tables of adverse event information. The tables should consist of the following summarized data:
- All SAEs
- All adverse events, other than SAEs, that exceed a frequency of five (5) percent in any arm of the trial
- All-cause mortalities
Per 42CFR11, this information must be submitted no later than one (1) year after the primary completion date of the clinical trial. Submission of trial results may be delayed as long as two (2) years if a responsible party submits a certification that: 1) the FDA has not approved, licensed, or cleared the investigational product (IP) being studied for any use before the primary completion date of the trial; and 2) the sponsor intends to continue with product development and is either seeking, or may at a future date seek, FDA approval.
See 42CFR11 for detailed adverse event reporting requirements.
Form Completion & Delivery Requirements
The G-SpnsrRpt indicates that as of April 1, 2026, IND safety reports of serious and unexpected suspected adverse reactions (which contain individual data from one (1) or more participants) should be submitted as individual case safety reports (ICSRs) to the FDA’s Adverse Event Monitoring System (AEMS) (formerly FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS)) (USA-50). As per the G-SpnsrRpt, the G-INDElecSubs, and USA-46, sponsors must submit such IND safety reports to USA-50 using either the Electronic Submissions Gateway Next Generation (ESG NextGen) or the Safety Reporting Portal (SRP) (USA-51). See USA-102 for the ESG NextGen Unified Submission Portal (USP) Login, as well as USA-37 and USA-44 for more information on ESG NextGen. Also see USA-46 for more information on making submissions to USA-50.
The G-SpnsrRpt notes that other types of required IND safety reports (overall findings or pooled analyses from published and unpublished in vitro, animal, epidemiological, or clinical studies and reports of increased rates of occurrences of expected serious suspected adverse reactions) should be submitted by the sponsor in a narrative format in electronic common technical document (eCTD) format, and should not be submitted to USA-50.
See USA-99 for additional information on submitting IND safety reports.
According to the G-SpnsrRpt and the G-INDElecSubs, submissions regarding non-commercial INDs are exempt from the above electronic submission requirements. The G-SpnsrRpt states that sponsors with INDs that are exempted from the electronic submission requirement, and who are not submitting IND safety reports of serious and unexpected suspected adverse reactions to USA-50 or the other types of IND safety reports with eCTD format submission requirements, should submit IND safety reports in an alternate electronic format or using other means of rapid communication. When utilizing an alternate electronic format (see the G-AltrntElecSubs) or other means of rapid communication, Form FDA 3500A (USA-75) may be used. For additional information on other reporting using Form FDA 3500A (USA-75), see the G-SpnsrRpt and USA-48.
Per USA-90, fatality reports to the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER) should be sent to fatalities2@fda.hhs.gov.
Interim and Annual Progress Reports
Pursuant to the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, investigators and sponsors share responsibility for submitting interim and annual reports on the status of a clinical trial. The investigator is required to provide annual progress reports to the institutional ethics committee (EC) and submit interim progress reports to the EC and Health Canada (HC) if there are any significant changes affecting the trial or risk to participants. The sponsor is required to submit annual reports (in the form of an updated Investigator’s Brochure (IB)) to HC. Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence. For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
According to the G-TCPS2, investigators must report new information that may affect the welfare or consent of participants to the institutional EC, HC, and other appropriate regulatory or advisory entities. When new information is relevant to participants’ welfare, researchers must promptly inform all participants to whom the information applies (including former participants). Researchers should work with their ECs to determine which participants must be informed, and how the information should be conveyed. New information may comprise a range of issues, including, but not limited to:
- Changes to the research design
- Evidence of any new risks
- Unanticipated issues that have possible health or safety consequences for participants
- New information that decisively proves the benefits of one (1) intervention over another
- New research findings, including relevant non-trial findings
- Unanticipated problems
- Closure of trials at other sites for reasons that may be relevant to the welfare or consent of participants in the ongoing trial
Final Report
While the CanadaFDR does not require submission of a final study report to HC, the CT-Rgstrn states that HC’s policy for reporting summary results aligns with international initiatives, including the Declaration of Helsinki (CAN-58). Sponsors should submit the summary results of their clinical trial within 12 months following primary study completion, which is the final study visit for collection of data on the primary outcome for the last participant in a global study, whether the clinical trial concluded according to the pre-specified protocol or stopped early. For clinical trials with more than one (1) primary outcome measure with different completion dates, the primary study completion is the date when data collection is completed for all primary outcome measures. In cases where submission of summary results within one (1) year of primary study completion will jeopardize the scientific integrity of the clinical trial, summary results may be submitted within one (1) year of study completion, which is the final study visit for collection of data on any remaining secondary outcome measures and adverse event information for the last participant in the global study, whether the clinical trial concluded according to the pre-specified protocol or stopped early. If a sponsor intends to apply for market authorization for the product studied or a new condition of use, the sponsor may defer submitting summary results until 30 calendar days after HC renders a decision on the application or the sponsor cancels or withdraws it, or up to 36 months following primary study completion, whichever is earlier. HC does not support deferral for products or new conditions of use that the sponsor does not intend to market or for which product development has stopped. Sponsors should submit the summary results of their clinical trial to the same registry where their trial is registered. (See Initiation, Agreements & Registration section for information on clinical trial registration.)
Per the G-CanadaCTApps, the sponsor should notify the HC Directorate when a clinical trial is completed or a clinical trial site is closed. A study is considered to be completed after the last participant globally completes the "end of study" visit as defined in the protocol. The "end of study visit" is the final visit for study-related tests and procedures, including the capture of any final potential study-related adverse events, and usually occurs after the participant has completed/discontinued study drug administration. The "end of study visit" is normally an in-person visit, but for some studies it can also be carried out over the telephone. There may be certain scenarios (e.g., gene therapies, drugs with very long half-lives) where a study may be ongoing well beyond the period of study treatment, i.e., where long-term safety monitoring and reporting would be required. The reporting requirements with regard to such long-term follow-up of safety are normally specified in the study protocol and agreed to between the sponsor and HC prior to the authorization of the clinical trial in Canada.
Interim and Annual Progress Reports
As specified in 21CFR312, the investigator must furnish all reports to the sponsor who is responsible for collecting and evaluating the results obtained. In addition, per 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) must have written procedures for determining which projects need verification from sources other than the investigator that no material changes have occurred since the previous EC review.
21CFR312 states that the sponsor must submit a brief annual progress report on the investigation to the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) within 60 days of the anniversary date that the investigational new drug went into effect. The report must contain the following information for each study:
- Title, purpose, and description of patient population, and current status
- Summary of the participants screened (e.g., failed screenings; participants enrolled, withdrawn, or lost to follow-up; and other challenges)
- Summary information - including information obtained during the previous year’s clinical and nonclinical investigations
- Description of the general investigational plan for the coming year
- Updated investigator’s brochure, if revised
- Description of any significant Phase 1 protocol modifications not previously reported in a protocol amendment
- Brief summary of significant foreign marketing developments with the drug
- A log of any outstanding business for which the sponsor requests a reply, comment, or meeting
As indicated in 42CFR11, trial updates must be submitted to ClinicalTrials.gov (USA-78) according to the following guidelines:
- Not less than once every 12 months for updated general trial registration information
- Not later than 30 calendar days for any changes in overall recruitment status
- Not later than 30 calendar days after the trial reaches its actual primary completion date, the date the final participant was examined or received an intervention for the purposes of final collection data for the primary outcome
Additionally, see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for guidance on clinical trial reports.
Final Report
As indicated in 21CFR312, an investigator must provide the sponsor with an adequate report shortly after completion of the investigator’s participation in the investigation. There is no specific timeframe stipulated for when the report should be completed.
Additionally, per 42CFR11, the responsible party must submit results for applicable investigational product (IP) clinical trials to USA-78 no later than one (1) year following the study’s completion date. Submission of trial results may be delayed as long as two (2) years if the responsible party submits a certification that indicates: 1) the FDA has not approved, licensed, or cleared the IP being studied for any use before the primary completion date of the trial; and 2) the sponsor intends to continue with product development and is either seeking, or may at a future date seek, FDA approval. The clinical trial results information must include data on the following:
- Participant flow
- Demographic and baseline characteristics
- Outcomes and statistical analysis
- Adverse event information
- The protocol and statistical analysis plan
- Administrative information
See USA-49 for more information and 42CFR11 for more detailed requirements. See NIHTrialInfo for specific information on dissemination of NIH-funded clinical trial data. See the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH)’s E3 Structure and Content of Clinical Study Reports (US-ICH-E3 and the US-ICH-E3-QA) for additional guidance on report structure.
As per the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, a sponsor is defined as an individual, corporate body, institution, or organization that conducts a clinical trial. In accordance with the G-FDR-0100, a sponsor may transfer any or all of the sponsor's trial-related activities to a service provider in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements. However, the ultimate responsibility for the sponsor's trial-related activities, including protection of participants' rights, safety, and well-being and reliability of the trial data, resides with the sponsor.
According to the CanadaFDR and G-CanadaCTApps, a sponsor may be domestic or foreign. A foreign sponsor is required to have a senior medical or scientific officer who is residing in Canada who will represent the sponsor, and sign and date the application and the clinical trial attestation form.
For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
As per 21CFR312 and 21CFR50, a sponsor is defined as a person who takes responsibility for and initiates a clinical investigation. The sponsor may be an individual or pharmaceutical company, governmental agency, academic institution, private organization, or other organization. The sponsor does not actually conduct the investigation unless the sponsor is a sponsor-investigator. 21CFR312 and 21CFR50 define a sponsor-investigator as an individual who both initiates and conducts an investigation, and under whose immediate direction the investigational product is administered or dispensed.
In addition, 21CFR312 states that a sponsor may transfer responsibility for any or all obligations to a contract research organization (CRO). Any trial-related responsibilities transferred to and assumed by a CRO must be described in writing, and those obligations not covered by the written description will be deemed not to have been transferred. Further, a CRO that assumes any sponsor obligations must comply with the specific regulations delineated in 21CFR312 and will be subject to the same regulatory action as the sponsor for failure to comply with any obligation assumed under these regulations.
As indicated in 21CFR312, a sponsor may be either domestic or foreign.
Overview
Per the CanadaFDR and the G-FDR-0100, every sponsor must ensure that a clinical trial is conducted in accordance with good clinical practice (GCP) and must also ensure that:
- At each clinical trial site, there is no more than one (1) qualified investigator (QI)
- At each clinical trial site, medical care and medical decisions, in respect of the clinical trial, are under the supervision of the QI
- Each individual involved in the conduct of the clinical trial is qualified by education, training, and experience to perform the tasks
The G-FDR-0100 explains that the sponsor’s selection and oversight of QIs and service providers are fundamental features of the oversight process. As stated in Mdrn-CTFrmwrk, a "qualified investigator" may be:
- A physician or dentist who is authorized under CanadaFDR to act as a qualified investigator
- An individual who has the education, training, and experience required to conduct the clinical trial in accordance with regulatory requirements, despite not meeting the regulatory requirement to be a physician or dentist in CanadaFDR
Mdrn-CTFrmwrk further specifies that in clinical trials where the investigator is not a physician or dentist, medical decisions with respect to the trial that are outside the licensed scope of practice of the investigator must be made by a qualified physician or dentist on the clinical trial team who is:
- Licensed to practice in the province or territory where the site is located
- Responsible for medical oversight and participant care, including medical decisions with respect to the trial
In accordance with the G-CanadaCTApps, prior to initiating a clinical trial, the sponsor must ensure that a Qualified Investigator Undertaking (QIU) form (CAN-37) (or similar documentation that meets the CanadaFDR requirements) has been completed and kept on file by the sponsor; it should be retained by the sponsor for 15 years. Per the CanadaFDR, the form certifies that the QI will conduct the clinical trial in accordance with GCP, and, if the trial is discontinued, will immediately inform trial participants and the institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Boards in Canada) of the discontinuance, and the reason for it. (See the Submission Content section for additional information on clinical trial application requirements). For HC’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
Per G-Dcntrl, for clinical trials with decentralized elements, sponsors and QIs should assess whether decentralized locations have sufficient funding, time, equipment, and staff to support trial conduct that complies with GCP. Considerations include local care and institutional practices, provincial or territorial requirements, training needs, and coordination and communication across locations. The main location and remote locations supervised by one (1) QI constitute a single clinical trial site. The main location must be identified on the Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) form (CAN-6) and receive EC approval before trial initiation.
For additional guidance on investigator selection, qualifications, and training, see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Per CAN-11, the Canadian Clinical Trials Asset Map (CCTAM) (CAN-26) is a pan-Canadian research inventory of investigators, clinical research sites, and other resources across the country. Sponsors can use CCTAM to identify potential sites and investigators, which may expedite study feasibility and start-up timelines. To view the CCTAM, the user must register and create an account.
Foreign Sponsor Responsibilities
According to the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, a sponsor may be domestic or foreign. A foreign sponsor is required to have a senior medical or scientific officer residing in Canada to represent the sponsor, and sign and date the application and the clinical trial attestation form.
Data and Safety Monitoring Board
The G-TCPS2 provides the following considerations to help researchers and ECs determine whether a Data and Safety Monitoring Board (DSMB) (known as an Independent Data-Monitoring Committee in Canada) is needed:
- The magnitude of foreseeable research-attributable harms to participants
- Whether the circumstances of the participants make them vulnerable in the context of research
- The feasibility of interim data analysis
- The complexity of the study
- Conflicts of interest
Also see CAN-52 for ICH guidance on DSMBs.
Multicenter Studies
The CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, require the sponsor to complete and retain the Research Ethics Board (REB) Attestation (CAN-8) and Qualified Investigator Undertaking (QIU) (CAN-37) forms at each trial site, while submitting in electronic format CAN-6 to the appropriate HC Directorate for each trial site.
The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ECs, provides that in multi-site clinical trials, a lead principal investigator (PI) is a designated PI who is responsible for the ethical conduct of the study for all sites. The lead PI is responsible for communicating any changes to the study, new information, and/or unanticipated events to the EC, to the sponsor, and to local site PIs.
Per CAN-50, Canada has implemented the ICH Guidance E17: Multi-Regional Clinical Trials (CAN-40), which describes general principles for the planning and design of multi-regional clinical trials with the aim of increasing the acceptability of these trials in global regulatory submissions. HC recognizes that the scope and subject matter of current HC guidance may not be entirely consistent with ICH guidance. In such circumstances, HC-implemented ICH guidance takes precedence.
Overview
As set forth in 21CFR312, the sponsor is responsible for selecting the investigator(s) for the clinical trial and for ensuring that the investigator(s) are qualified by training and experience. Prior to permitting an investigator(s) to conduct a study, the sponsor must obtain the following:
- Signed investigator’s statement (Form FDA 1572 (USA-77))
- Curriculum vitae
- Clinical protocol
- Financial disclosure information
As addressed in the G-1572FAQs, Form FDA 1572 (USA-77) serves as the investigator’s agreement to provide certain information to the sponsor and to assure compliance with the Food & Drug Administration (FDA)'s clinical investigation regulations. Refer to the G-1572FAQs and USA-40 for further information.
In addition, 21CFR312 indicates that prior to the start of the study, the sponsor must provide the investigator(s) with the investigator’s brochure. The sponsor is also responsible for providing the investigator(s) with the information needed to conduct an investigation properly.
See G-InvstgtrResp for more information on investigator responsibilities.
As per the G-InvstgtrAdmin, the FDA may disqualify a clinical investigator from receiving investigational drugs (including biologics) if the FDA determines that the investigator has repeatedly or deliberately violated the agency’s regulations, or submitted false information to the sponsor or FDA in any required report. See the G-InvstgtrAdmin for more details.
The G-DecentralCT provides FDA recommendations for clinical trials with decentralized elements. The G-DecentralCT notes that because decentralized clinical trials may involve many contracted services, sponsors should ensure proper coordination of decentralized elements (e.g., use of remote trial personnel for at-home visits, use of local health care providers (HCPs), direct shipping of the investigational product to participants, etc.). Such contracted services may be performed by networks of local HCPs (e.g., local clinic networks, pharmacy chains). Sponsors should ensure these networks of local HCPs are qualified to perform the contracted activities. Sponsors should also keep a record of these networks and other contracted service providers, including their roles and assigned activities. See the G-DecentralCT for additional guidance.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on investigator selection, qualifications, and training.
Foreign Sponsor Responsibilities
No information is currently available.
Data and Safety Monitoring Board
As per 21CFR50, Data and Safety Monitoring Boards (DSMBs), (also known as Data Monitoring Committees (DMCs)), are not required by FDA regulations, except in the case of research conducted in emergency settings in which fulfilling the informed consent requirement is unfeasible. In this case, the FDA requires the establishment of an independent data monitoring committee to exercise oversight of the clinical investigation.
Additionally, the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule indicate that for all human subjects research funded and/or sponsored by a Common Rule department/agency (as identified in USA-18 and USA-65), the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) must ensure that, when appropriate, the research plan makes adequate provisions for monitoring the data collected during the study to ensure participant safety. Moreover, per the NIHDataSftyMntrng and USA-72, all National Institutes of Health (NIH)-funded clinical trials require a Data and Safety Monitoring Plan and monitoring should be commensurate with risk. DSMBs are also required for multi-site clinical trials with interventions that involve potential participant risk. See the NIHDataSftyMntrng and USA-72 for detailed Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)/NIH requirements.
Multicenter Studies
The RevComRule delineates that for all human subjects research funded and/or sponsored by a Common Rule department/agency, institutions that are located in the US and engaged in multicenter research/cooperative research studies must use a single EC to review the research. See the Scope of Review section, the RevComRule, the G-CentralIRB, and G-CoopRes for additional information.
See US-ICH-E17 for additional FDA guidance related to multi-regional clinical trials.
Insurance
The CanadaFDR does not require the sponsor to provide insurance coverage to investigators, institutions, or trial participants. However, the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50, guides sponsors on providing insurance. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Compensation
Injury or Death
The Canadian regulations do not require compensation for trial participants in the event of trial-related injuries or death. However, the G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ethics committees (ECs) (known as Research Ethics Boards in Canada), provides that, during informed consent, participants should be given information about any payments, including compensation for injury.
Trial Participation
The Canadian regulations do not require compensation for trial participation. However, as per the G-TCPS2, the informed consent form (ICF) should contain a statement with a description of the anticipated prorated payment to the participant(s) that is reasonably expected for participation in the trial. Any compensation or incentive to participants must not be so excessive that it may unfairly influence participants or cause them to overlook important facts and risks.
Also see CAN-52, which guides sponsors on providing compensation.
Insurance
The United States (US) regulations do not require insurance.
Compensation
The G-IRBFAQs state that institutional policy, not Food & Drug Administration (FDA) regulation, determines whether compensation and medical treatment(s) will be offered and the conditions that might be placed on participant eligibility for compensation or treatment(s). Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, which guides sponsors on providing compensation.
Injury or Death
As specified in 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, for research involving more than minimal risk, participants must be informed as to whether any compensation or medical treatments are available in the event of trial-related injuries. See the Required Elements section for additional information.
Trial Participation
As per the FDA’s G-SbjctPayment, compensation for participation is considered a recruitment incentive and not a benefit, and is often offered when the participant’s health benefits are remote or non-existent. Payment amounts and schedules should be presented to the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the US) at the time of the initial review. The EC should ensure the payment amount and the proposed method and timing of disbursement are not coercive or present undue influence and are also included in the informed consent document. Payment to participants who withdraw may be made at the time that they would have completed the study. While the entire payment should not be contingent upon completion of the entire study, a small payment provided as an incentive for completion is acceptable to the FDA. Further, the FDA does not consider reimbursement for travel expenses to and from the clinical trial site and associated costs such as airfare, parking, and lodging to raise issues regarding undue influence.
Quality Assurance/Quality Control
As stated in the CanadaFDR, the sponsor must ensure that a clinical trial is conducted in accordance with good clinical practice and must ensure, among other things, that the trial is scientifically sound and clearly described in a protocol; the trial and use of the drug comply with the protocol and the CanadaFDR; and systems and procedures that assure the quality of every aspect of the trial are implemented. Regarding quality, the G-FDR-0100 explains that the sponsor is responsible for the establishment of a quality management system consisting of documented procedures (standard operating procedures (SOPs), protocol procedures, etc.) to assure the quality of every aspect of a clinical trial. The range and extent of oversight measures should fit the purpose and be tailored to the complexity of and risks associated with the trial. Quality management includes the design and implementation of efficient clinical trial protocols, including tools and procedures for trial conduct (including data collection and management), to ensure the protection of participants' rights, safety, and well-being, and the reliability of trial results. The sponsor should adopt a proportionate and risk-based approach to quality management, which involves incorporating quality into the design of the clinical trial (i.e., quality by design) and identifying those factors that are likely to have a meaningful impact on participants' rights, safety, and well-being, and the reliability of the results. The sponsor should describe the quality management approach in the clinical trial report.
In addition, G-FDR-0100 states that risks to critical-to-quality factors should be managed proactively and adjusted when new or unanticipated issues arise once the trial has begun. Risk review is a key component to risk-based quality management systems, and Health Canada (HC) expects that sponsors will be able to demonstrate that risk control measures are periodically reviewed and remain effective and relevant, considering emerging knowledge and experience throughout the trial.
Per G-Dcntrl, for trials with decentralized elements, sponsors and qualified investigators (QIs) should collaborate with trial sites and service providers to implement a quality management system covering decentralized activities and supporting compliance with HC regulations and the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. Processes should identify, evaluate, control, communicate, and review risks affecting participant safety or the reliability of results, including risks arising from decentralized elements. Additional training, continuing quality checks, and competency assessments may be needed beyond SOPs. See G-Dcntrl for additional details.
Further, CAN-50, Canada implements the ICH Guidance E8(R1): General Considerations for Clinical Studies (CAN-49), which provides guidance on conduct during the clinical trial. Other relevant ICH guidance adopted per CAN-50 are the guidance on statistical principles for clinical trials (CAN-53) and the addendum on estimands and sensitivity analysis (CAN-39). The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Monitoring Requirements
As indicated in the G-FDR-0100, the sponsor should determine the appropriate extent and nature of monitoring based on identified risks. Factors to consider include the objective, purpose, design, complexity, blinding, number of trial participants, investigational product, current knowledge of the safety profile, and endpoints of the trial. Monitoring may include site monitoring (performed onsite and/or remotely) and centralized monitoring. The frequency of monitoring activities should also be determined based on identified risks. Monitoring activities and their frequency should be modified as appropriate using knowledge gained. Centralized monitoring processes provide additional monitoring capabilities that can complement and reduce the extent and/or frequency of site monitoring or be used on its own. Use of centralized data analytics can help identify systemic or site-specific issues, including protocol noncompliance and potential unreliable data. In addition to monitoring, a sponsor should perform audits in a manner that is proportionate to the risk associated with the conduct of the trial. See CAN-52 for additional guidance on sponsor responsibilities involving monitoring and auditing.
Further, per the G-FDR-0100, it is critical to include processes that will be followed to address situations of non-compliance, as well as to identify events that would require either a review or revision of the monitoring plan. HC expects these components to be clearly documented in risk-based monitoring plans. The sponsor should describe the requirements of monitoring reports (including their content and frequency) in the standard procedures. Reports of site and/or centralized monitoring should be provided to the sponsor in a timely manner for review and follow up. When needed, the report should describe findings requiring escalation for action and resolution. The sponsor should decide on the appropriate action to be taken, and these decisions and the resolution of the actions involved, where needed, should be recorded. For additional information on monitoring reports, refer to the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA)’s Guidance for Industry: A Risk-Based Approach to Monitoring of Clinical Investigations Questions and Answers.
Next, per the G-FDR-0100, if it is discovered that noncompliance significantly affects or has the potential to significantly affect human participant protection or reliability of trial results, the sponsor should perform a root cause analysis, implement appropriate corrective and preventive actions, and confirm their adequacy, unless otherwise justified. Where the sponsor identifies issues that are likely to significantly impact the rights, safety, or well-being of the trial participant(s) or the reliability of trial results (i.e., serious noncompliance), the sponsor should notify the HC and the institutional ethics committee (known as Research Ethics Boards in Canada).
Per the HCNotice-ICH-E19, HC adopted and implemented ICH guidance on selective safety data collection in specific late stage pre-approval or post-approval clinical trials (CAN-15). Selective safety data collection refers to the recording of certain data by investigators in case report forms. It does not affect the monitoring and clinical care of individual trial participants or documentation of their adverse events in medical records. See the HCNotice-ICH-E19 and the CAN-15 for more information.
Per G-Inspections, regulated parties (sponsors, qualified investigators, contract research organizations, and any other party involved in the conduct of clinical trials) have mandatory responsibilities under the CanadaFDA and can be inspected. Foreign entities that conduct regulated activities in Canada, or in relation to a product imported in Canada, are also subject to Canadian law. During an inspection or a compliance verification, a regulated party is required to provide all reasonable assistance and information necessary for the HC inspector to perform their duties, including providing evidence that its facility, equipment, and practices and procedures meet the applicable requirements. As indicated in G-Dcntrl, sponsors should oversee decentralized elements in clinical trials across all locations, including remote locations, with monitoring directed toward potential safety concerns, data quality, and reliable results. See the Risk-Insp for HC’s risk classification guide for observations related to inspections of clinical trials of human drugs.
Premature Study Termination/Suspension
The CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps state that if a trial is prematurely terminated or suspended, the sponsor should inform HC no later than 15 days after the termination or suspension. In addition, the sponsor should provide HC with the reason(s) for the termination or suspension and its impact on the proposed or ongoing clinical trials related to the drug in Canada by the sponsor. The sponsor should also promptly notify the qualified investigators of the termination or suspension and advise them in writing of any potential risks to the participants’ health. Further, the G-CanadaCTApps states that the sponsor’s notification to HC should include confirmation that the sale or importation of the drug to the discontinued sites has been stopped and that reasonable measures to ensure the return of all unused quantities of the drug will be taken. This notification must also be submitted for premature discontinuation of a clinical trial or clinical trial site outside Canada where there are ongoing trials with the drug in Canada. See G-FDR-0100 for additional information and interpretation of discontinuation, suspension, and cancellation. CAN-52 also provides guidance on premature termination or suspension.
Quality Assurance/Quality Control
Per the US-ICH-E19, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has adopted the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH)’s E19 guidance, A Selective Approach to Safety Data Collection in Specific Late-Stage Pre-Approval or Post-Approval Clinical Trials. The document describes circumstances in which it may be appropriate to reduce the collection of safety data in late-stage pre-approval and post-approval clinical trials, e.g., long-term outcome trials, when appropriate and with agreement from regulatory authorities. See the US-ICH-E19 for more information.
Furthermore, the FDA’s G-CTEmrgncy provides general considerations to assist sponsors, institutional ethics committees (ECs) (institutional review boards (IRBs) in the United States (US)), and clinical investigators in assuring the safety of trial participants, maintaining compliance with good clinical practice (GCP), and minimizing risks to trial integrity during disasters and public health emergencies that may lead to a major disruption of clinical trial conduct and operations. See the G-CTEmrgncy for more information.
The G-DecentralCT provides FDA recommendations for clinical trials with decentralized elements. The G-DecentralCT states that to account for multiple sources of data collection in a decentralized clinical trial, the sponsor should include at least the following in a data management plan or other trial-related documents: data origin and data flow from all sources to the sponsor (e.g., a diagram that depicts the flow of data from creation to final storage); methods and technologies used for remote data acquisition from trial participants, trial personnel, and contracted service providers (e.g., local clinical laboratory facilities and local health care providers who perform trial-related activities); and a list identifying service providers for data collection, handling, and management.
The G-DecentralCT further indicates that to protect the safety and welfare of trial participants in a decentralized clinical trial, sponsors should implement a safety monitoring plan that takes the decentralized nature of the clinical trial into account and ensures that adverse events and medication errors are appropriately collected and adequately addressed. When applicable, the safety monitoring plan should describe the type of information that will be collected by a digital health technology, how that information will be used and monitored, and what action trial participants or personnel should take in response to abnormal findings or electronic alerts. See the G-DecentralCT for additional information.
See the G-eHealthRecords for the FDA’s guidance related to the use of electronic health records in clinical research, and see the G-RemoteData for recommendations on the use of digital health technologies for remote data acquisition from participants in clinical investigations that evaluate medical products. Furthermore, see the G-ESourceData for FDA guidance regarding the capture, review, and retention of electronic source data, particularly for use in filling the predefined fields in an electronic case report form.
Additionally, the G-CovariatesCT provides the FDA’s recommendations for the use of covariates in the analysis of randomized, parallel group clinical trials that are applicable to both superiority trials and noninferiority trials. See the G-CovariatesCT for more information.
The G-RWDRWE-Reg, issued as part of the FDA’s Real-World Evidence (RWE) Program (see USA-17), discusses the applicability of the 21CFR312 investigational new drug application (IND) regulations to various clinical study designs that utilize real-world data (RWD). See the G-RWDRWE-Reg for more information.
See the FDA’s G-EnrchStrat for enrichment strategies that can be used in clinical investigations intended to demonstrate the effectiveness of drug and biological products, and the G-DataCollect for recommendations on the use of a standardized approach for collecting and reporting race and ethnicity data in submissions for clinical trials.
Additionally, see USA-47 for a list of FDA clinical trials related guidance documents.
See USA-97 for information on the National Institutes of Health (NIH)’s data management and sharing policy, the NIHDataMngmnt, which applies to all research that is funded or conducted in whole or in part by the NIH, and results in the generation of scientific data. Additionally, see USA-6 for other scientific data sharing policies, including genomic data.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on sponsor responsibilities involving quality management, assurance, and control. Additionally, see USA-69 for 10 guiding principles that industry and product developers can consider when using artificial intelligence (AI) to advance drug and biological product development.
Monitoring Requirements
The FDA’s G-RiskMntrng states that for each clinical trial, the sponsor should develop a monitoring plan that describes the monitoring methods, responsibilities, and requirements for the trial. The monitoring plan should include a brief description of the study, its objectives, and the critical data and study procedures, with particular attention to data and procedures that are unusual in relation to clinical routine. The monitoring plan should also require training of study site staff. Additionally, the plan should communicate the specific risks to be addressed by monitoring and should provide those involved in monitoring with adequate information to effectively carry out their duties. The FDA also encourages greater use of centralized monitoring practices, where appropriate, with correspondingly less emphasis on on-site monitoring. Centralized monitoring techniques should be used to the extent appropriate and feasible to:
- Supplement or reduce the frequency and extent of on-site monitoring with monitoring activities that can be done as well or better remotely, or with monitoring activities that can be accomplished using centralized processes only. Examples include monitoring data quality through routine review of submitted data, as well as completing administrative and regulatory tasks.
- Target on-site monitoring by identifying higher-risk clinical sites (e.g., sites with data anomalies or a higher frequency of errors, protocol violations, or dropouts relative to other sites).
For more FDA guidance on a risk-based approach to monitoring and monitoring plans, see the G-RiskMntrng and the G-RiskMntrngQA. Also see the ICH’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on sponsor responsibilities involving monitoring and auditing.
Premature Study Termination/Suspension
As delineated in 21CFR312, if the sponsor determines the investigational product (IP) presents an unreasonable and significant risk to the participants, the sponsor must discontinue the associated study as soon as possible, and no later than five (5) working days after making the determination. The sponsor must also notify the FDA, all ECs, and all investigators who have participated in the study about the termination. Additionally, the sponsor must ensure the disposition of all remaining stock of the IP and provide the FDA with a full report on the sponsor’s actions.
The G-InfrmdCnsnt, which is the FDA’s discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50, further states that if a study is terminated, participants should be provided with as much information as possible regarding the reason for the termination. Such a discussion provides an opportunity to address questions that participants may have about an IP that was administered to them (e.g., immediate safety concerns, ability to participate in another clinical trial, and appropriate waiting period to do so) and what long-term follow up may be available or necessary.
21CFR312 indicates that if the FDA terminates an IND based on deficiencies in the IND or in the conduct of an investigation under an IND, the sponsor must end all clinical investigations conducted under the IND and recall or otherwise provide for the disposition of all unused supplies of the drug. See 21CFR312 for more information on FDA termination.
Also see the ICH’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on sponsor responsibilities involving premature termination or suspension of a trial.
Electronic Data Processing System
The G-FDR-0100 states that systems and processes that aid in data capture, management, and analyses, as well as those that help ensure the quality of the information generated from the clinical trial, should fit the purpose of the trial, capture the data required by the protocol, and be implemented in a way that is proportionate to the risks to participants and the importance of acquired data. Quality should be addressed in the design or adaptation of electronic systems for clinical trial purposes to ensure the integrity of relevant trial data. Any electronic system used to capture, process, manage, and/or archive clinical trial information should be adequately validated, and evidence of validation should be retained and readily available for inspection by Health Canada (HC) inspectors. The approach for validation should be based on a risk assessment that considers the intended use of the system; the purpose and importance of the data/record that are collected/generated, maintained, and retained in the system; and the potential of the system to affect the well-being, rights, and safety of trial participants and reliability of trial results. The responsibilities of the sponsor, qualified investigator (QI), and other parties with respect to the use of these computerized systems should be clear, and the users should be provided with training in their use. The sponsor should periodically review the risk control measures to ascertain whether the implemented systems remain effective and relevant, considering experience and emerging knowledge.
Per the G-FDR-0100, any modifications or additions made to the electronic system (for example software upgrades or migration of data) can impact its intended functions by altering the quality of validated applications and the system itself. This may affect the integrity of electronic information and the reliability of the system. Therefore, adequate documented assessment and approval of changes to hardware or software during the clinical trial are required. The impact of such a change should be evaluated and documented, and partial validation of some components of the electronic system may be required.
G-Dcntrl states that computerized systems and digital health technologies used in decentralized activities should be suitable for their intended use and validated through a risk-based approach consistent with the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. Sponsors should address data transfer integrity, security, interoperability, audit trails, and cybersecurity, with documented procedures and training supporting system development, maintenance, and use. See G-Dcntrl for additional details.
For additional information on computerized system validation and electronic records, see CAN-52. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Records Management
As set forth in the CanadaFDR and the CanadaFDR1024, the sponsor must record, handle, and store all trial-related information to allow complete and accurate reporting, interpretation, and verification. The CanadaFDR requires the sponsor to maintain all trial-related records for a period of 15 years. Per the G-FDR-0100, the electronic system should allow for the retrieval of records and the generation of complete and accurate paper copies of the electronic source data. The system should provide audit trails for the entire 15-year record retention period. Records created, maintained, and processed by outsourced systems are subject to the same requirements as the data/records generated by company-owned systems.
Pursuant to CanadaFDR1024, the sponsor must submit requested records to HC within 48 hours if safety concerns arise. Additionally, to facilitate inspection of a site, the sponsor must submit information to HC within seven (7) days of a request. Per CAN-8, an attestation must be completed by the institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Boards in Canada) that reviewed and approved the clinical trial. The completed attestation must be retained by the clinical trial sponsor for a period of 15 years. The attestation should not be submitted to HC unless requested.
G-Dcntrl states that records of agreements and contracts (paper or electronic) must be available or accessible from the main location of the clinical trial site. Per the Mdrn-CTFrmwrk, the sponsor is responsible for obtaining and retaining records for all EC approvals that may be required for participating sites, in accordance with applicable local requirements. The sponsor must retain records of all approvals for verification during clinical trial inspections. To meet this requirement, the sponsor must maintain complete and accurate records demonstrating EC approval for research undertaken at a clinical trial site.
Also see CAN-52 for additional guidance.
Electronic Data Processing System
As per the Food & Drug Administration (FDA)’s G-DecentralCT, electronic systems can be used to perform multiple functions to manage decentralized clinical trial (DCT) operations. Training should be provided to all parties (e.g., trial personnel, local health care providers, and trial participants) who are using electronic systems to support the conduct of DCTs. Electronic systems that are used to produce and process trial records required by the FDCAct and FDA regulations are subject to 21CFR11. These systems must ensure data reliability, security, privacy, and confidentiality.
See 21CFR11 and the G-Part11 for general FDA regulations and guidance on electronic records and systems. Additionally, see the G-ElecSyst for guidance specific to clinical investigations.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for guidance on data handling and processing, including the use of computerized systems.
Records Management
According to 21CFR312, the sponsor must maintain complete and accurate records showing financial interest paid to clinical investigators by the sponsor, as well as records concerning all other financial interests of investigators.
As set forth in 21CFR312, the sponsor must retain the above records and reports for at least two (2) years after a marketing application (known as a new drug application (NDA)) is approved for the drug; or if an NDA is not approved, until two (2) years after shipment and delivery of the IP is discontinued and the FDA has been notified. Additionally, upon request from the FDA, the sponsor must permit an officer or employee to access, copy, and verify any records and reports relating to the clinical investigation. Upon written request by the FDA, the sponsor must also submit the records or reports (or copies of them) to the agency.
Also see the ICH’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on record keeping and management.
Responsible Parties
The G-TCPS2, which sets the ethical benchmark for all Canadian institutional ethics committees (ECs), states that where researchers seek to collect, use, share, and access different types of information or data about participants, they should determine whether the information or data proposed in research may reasonably be expected to identify an individual. Researchers and ECs must consider whether information is identifiable or non-identifiable. Researchers, ECs, and institutions share the responsibility for protecting participant confidentiality.
Data Protection
Per CAN-42, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada provides advice and information for individuals about protecting personal information, and enforces the two (2) federal privacy laws that set out the rules for how federal government institutions and certain businesses must handle personal information, including health data. The PrivAct covers the personal information-handling practices of federal government departments and agencies in Canada, and the PIPEDA regulates private businesses’ data protection practices. In addition, some provinces and territories have laws that deal specifically with the protection of personal health information. See CAN-43 for a list of provincial and territorial privacy laws and webpages.
Per the G-TCPS2, in the research context, the most simplified method to protect participants is through the collection and use of anonymous or anonymized data. When anonymized data is not possible or desirable, a next best alternative is to use de-identified data, which is provided to the researcher in de-identified form and the existing key code is accessible only to a custodian or trusted third party who is independent of the researcher. Where it is not feasible to use anonymous or anonymized data for research, the ethical duty of confidentiality and the use of appropriate measures to safeguard information become paramount. Researchers should consult their ECs if they are uncertain about whether information proposed for use in research is identifiable (e.g., when proposing to link anonymized or coded data sets).
G-Dcntrl states that for decentralized data collection through wearables, digital platforms, or remote monitoring, sponsors should consider where data is stored, who may access it, and how to prevent unauthorized sharing or reuse.
Consent for Processing Personal Data
Both PIPEDA and the PrivAct require consent for the use of personal data, including health data, except under prescribed conditions, such as for research or during emergencies. Also see CAN-43 for provincial and territorial privacy laws.
The G-TCPS2 states that to seek broad consent for the storage and future unspecified use of data, researchers must provide prospective participants, or authorized third parties, with applicable information as set out in the informed consent requirements. See the Informed Consent topic, as well as the following details:
- The type, identifiability, and amount of data being collected and stored for re-use, and for what potential purpose
- The voluntariness of the participant’s consent, including any limitations on the feasibility of withdrawal
- A general description of the nature and types of future research that may be conducted, including whether the research might be conducted outside of Canada (if known)
- The risks and potential benefits of data storage and use in future unspecified research, including areas of uncertainty where risks cannot be estimated
- Access to a general description of the repository and its governance
- A statement regarding participants’ preference to being contacted for additional future research
- Whether the data could be shared with researchers who are not subject to the G-TCPS2
- Whether the research will (if known) or might include whole genome sequencing or similar technologies that may pose a substantial risk of re-identification of the participant or identification of material incidental findings (when appropriate)
- Whether linkage of data gathered in the research with other data about participants – either contained in public or personal records – is anticipated
- Separate options for consenting to participate in a specific research project and for consenting to the storage of data for future unspecified research
See Brd-Cnst for additional clarifications on broad consent for the storage and future unspecified use of data.
Per G-Dcntrl, when using digital tools for decentralized activities, there may be concerns about data storage, access, and reuse or sharing without consent. Sponsors and qualified investigators can work collaboratively with participants to ensure informed consent is maintained.
Responsible Parties
As stated in USA-86, the HIPAA Privacy Rule establishes the conditions under which protected health information (PHI) may be used or disclosed by covered entities for research purposes (Per USA-87, the Privacy Rule is located at 45CFR160 and Subparts A and E of 45CFR164; see USA-87 for more information). The Privacy Rule builds upon protections, described in Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) (the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule) and Food & Drug Administration (FDA) (21CFR50 and 21CFR56) regulations, that help ensure the privacy of participants and the confidentiality of information. (Please note: ClinRegs does not provide information on state-level personal data protection requirements.)
Per the Privacy Rule, a covered entity means: a health plan; a healthcare clearinghouse; or a healthcare provider who transmits any health information in electronic form in connection with a transaction covered by the Privacy Rule.
Data Protection
According to the FDA’s G-CertCnfdntlty, a Certificate of Confidentiality (CoC) is intended to help protect the privacy of human subject research participants from whom identifiable, sensitive information is being collected or used in furtherance of the research. CoCs must be issued for federally funded human subject research that collects or uses identifiable, sensitive information (mandatory CoCs). For non-federally funded research, issuance of CoCs is not required but may be issued at the discretion of the FDA (discretionary CoCs). If an institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) determines that data collected in a clinical trial are sufficiently sensitive to warrant requesting a CoC, then the EC may request that a CoC be obtained in order to secure EC approval. Any disagreement between an EC, sponsor, and/or investigators regarding the need to request a CoC for a study should be resolved by communications among the parties. See the G-CertCnfdntlty for more information on CoCs.
28CFR202 prohibits certain data transactions that involve giving a country of concern or covered person access to: 1) bulk US sensitive personal data that involves bulk human ‘omic data; or 2) to human biospecimens from which bulk human ‘omic data could be derived. Human ‘omic data includes human genomic data, human epigenomic data, human proteomic data, and human transcriptomic data. However, 28CFR202 notes that there is an exemption for data transactions involving regulatory approval data, which refers to sensitive personal data that is de-identified or pseudonymized and that is required to be submitted to a regulatory entity, or is required by a regulatory entity to be submitted to a covered person, to obtain or maintain authorization or approval to research or market a drug, biological product, device, or combination product. Data transactions that are necessary to obtain or maintain regulatory authorization or approval to research or market a drug, biological product, device, or combination product may also be exempt. See 28CFR202 for more information on countries of concern, exempt transactions, and reporting requirements.
NIH Privacy Requirements
The NIHPrvcy indicates that the HHS’ National Institutes of Health (NIH) follows the PrvcyAct, which includes procedures for: 1) protecting records that can be retrieved by personal identifiers such as a name, social security number, or other identifying number or symbol, and 2) persons to access their identifiable records and to request correction(s) of these records. See the NIHPrvcy and the PrvcyAct for more information.
Consent for Processing Personal Data
Per USA-86, the Privacy Rule defines the means by which individuals will be informed of uses and disclosures of their medical information for research purposes, and their rights to access information about themselves held by covered entities. Researchers may obtain, create, use, and/or disclose individually identifiable health information in the course of conducting research. Under the Privacy Rule, covered entities are permitted to use and disclose PHI for research with individual authorization, or without individual authorization under limited circumstances. To use or disclose PHI without authorization by the research participant, a covered entity must obtain one (1) of the following:
- Documented EC or privacy board approval
- Representations from the researcher that the use or disclosure of the PHI is solely to prepare a research protocol (or for similar purposes preparatory to research), the researcher will not remove any PHI from the covered entity, and PHI for which access is sought is necessary for the research purpose
- Research on protected health information of decedents
- Limited data sets with a data use agreement
- Research use/disclosure with individual authorization
- Accounting for research disclosures
See USA-86 for more information on these circumstances.
Obtaining Consent
In all Canadian clinical trials, a freely given informed consent is required from each participant in accordance with the requirements set forth in the CanadaFDR and the G-TCPS2. Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence. For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
As per the CanadaFDR and the G-TCPS2, the informed consent form (ICF) is viewed as an essential document that must be reviewed and approved by an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as a Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada) and provided to HC with the clinical trial application (CTA). (See the Required Elements section for details on what should be included in the form.)
The G-TCPS2 states that the qualified investigator (QI) must provide detailed research study information to the participant or legal representative/guardian. The ICF content should be in plain language (i.e., non-technical and easy to understand) and provided in a format that facilitates understanding. For example, written documentation may be supplemented with audio and/or visual aids. The participant and legal representative/guardian should also be given adequate time to consider whether to participate.
As stated in Mdrn-CTFrmwrk, HC is moving from “written” to “documented” informed consent to allow new approaches for obtaining consent (e.g., remote or electronic platforms, electronic signatures, and documentation of consent where it is provided orally). Informed consent requirements will be considered met by HC where processes:
- Are appropriately documented
- Comply with good clinical practice and CAN-52 principles
- Ensure that consent is informed and given in accordance with the applicable laws governing consent
Per G-Dcntrl, sponsors must inform participants of the potential risks and anticipated benefits of any decentralized elements in a clinical trial. In designing and implementing consent processes across locations, sponsors should consider whether the approach may introduce additional cognitive or emotional demands for participants. Reasonable steps should be taken to minimize unnecessary burden while supporting informed and voluntary decision-making. Virtual meeting platforms and electronic signatures may make the informed consent process more efficient for those who live in remote areas. However, participants may face additional challenges in providing informed consent remotely. Sponsors and QIs should be careful not to create a disadvantage for those who face barriers such as reliable private internet access, digital literacy, or comfort with virtual tools, or prefer not to use virtual platforms. Trial-related documentation should support any proposed delegation of duties related to the informed consent process to trial personnel or other third party, any proposed virtual meeting to obtain informed consent, and the proposed medium of the documented record of participants providing their consent (for example, written, video, audio). The following should also be considered:
- Providing different methods of informed consent to those who request them, including in-person consent meetings and physical copies of the ICF
- Using virtual meeting platforms that include both audio and video features so that QIs (or delegated persons) and participants can take part in the informed consent process and discussion in real time, and interact virtually with a real person
Further, the G-FDR-0100 indicates that a clinical trial participant cannot be involved in any aspect of a clinical trial until they have gone through the informed consent process, with a trial staff member (doctor, study nurse, clinical trial coordinator, etc.) and signed the document indicating that they understand the information and have agreed to participate in the trial. Neither the QI, nor the QI site staff, should coerce or unduly influence a participant to participate or to continue their participation in a trial. A qualified physician should be available to answer any medical questions that the participant may have regarding their participation in the trial. Information should be as clear and concise as possible, use simple language, and avoid unnecessary volume and complexity. See CAN-52 for additional information.
For guidance from Canadian researchers on the core elements for obtaining consent to ensure transparency and improve participants’ understanding of their involvement in research studies, see CAN-57.
Re-Consent
Per the G-TCPS2, consent must be maintained throughout the research project. Researchers have a continuous duty to provide participants with all information relevant to their ongoing consent to participate in the research. Consent begins with the initial contact (e.g., recruitment) and carries through to the end of participation in the study. Throughout the clinical trial, researchers have a continuous responsibility to provide participants and ECs with all information relevant to participants’ ongoing consent to participate in the research. The researcher must also notify participants of any changes to the research project that may affect them. These changes may have ethical implications, may be relevant to their decision to continue in the study, or may be unique to the particular circumstances of individual participants. Specifically, researchers must disclose changes to the risks or potential benefits of the research.
The G-TCPS2 indicates that rather than an age-based approach to consent, researchers should use an approach based on decision-making capacity in compliance with any laws governing research participation. This includes those whose decision-making capacity is in the process of development, those whose decision-making capacity is diminishing or fluctuating, and those whose decision-making capacity remains only partially developed. Mechanisms should be in place from the outset to identify and address any changes that could affect consent. A change in participant capacity is an important element of ongoing consent.
Further, the G-TCPS2 states that within the limits of consent provided by the participant, researchers should disclose to the participant any material incidental findings discovered in the course of research. Incidental findings are considered to be material incidental findings if they are reasonably determined to have significant welfare implications for the participant or prospective participant. Where material incidental findings are foreseeable, researchers should inform participants during the initial consent process. In addition, researchers should develop a management plan for review by the EC. For more information on how to address material incidental findings, see G-ConsentMatIncFindings.
See CAN-52 for additional information.
Language Requirements
Per the G-FDR-0100, the ICF must be made available for each participant in either official language (French or English) or other language as appropriate. The G-TCPS2 requires the ICF to be presented in plain language that the participant is able to understand. If there is a language barrier, the QI should select an intermediary who has the necessary language skills to ensure effective communication.
Documenting Consent
As per the G-TCPS2, the participant or legal representative/guardian, as well as the QI, must sign and date the ICF. The G-FDR-0100 states that the QI should retain the signed ICF.
The G-TCPS2 further indicates that researchers can use a range of procedures to seek and document consent, including oral consent documented in field notes, and other forms of recording (e.g., a consent log, audio or video recordings, or other electronic means). Evidence of consent may also be documented via completed questionnaires (in person, by mail, by email, or other electronic means). ECs should consider the power relationship that might exist between researchers and participants, and whether a waiver of the requirement for signed written consent may affect the welfare of the participants. If researchers plan to obtain non-written consent, they must explain their strategy to the EC.
See CAN-52 for additional information.
Waiver of Consent
As explained in the G-TCPS2, there are research situations that call for alterations of consent. The EC may approve research that involves an alteration to the consent requirements if the EC is satisfied, and documents that all of the following apply:
- The research involves no more than minimal risk to the participants
- The change to consent requirements is unlikely to adversely affect the welfare of participants
- It is impossible or impracticable to carry out the research and to address the research question properly, given the research design, if the prior consent of participants is required
- In the case of a proposed alteration, the exact nature and extent of any proposed alteration is defined
- There is a plan to brief participants and offer the option of refusing consent and/or withdrawing data and/or human biological materials
Obtaining Consent
In all United States (US) clinical trials, a freely given informed consent is required to be obtained from each participant in accordance with the requirements set forth in 21CFR50 for Food & Drug Administration (FDA) regulated clinical trials, and the Pre2018-ComRule or the RevComRule for federally funded or sponsored clinical trials. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on agency-specific compliance.) Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)-funded or sponsored clinical trials must also comply with 45CFR46-B-E.
As per 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the informed consent form (ICF) is viewed as an essential document that must be reviewed and approved by an institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the US).
Per the G-RevComRule-FDA, the informed consent requirements of the RevComRule are not inconsistent with FDA regulations. Therefore, there may not be a need for sponsors or investigators to develop, and have ECs review, two (2) separate ICFs for research that must comply with both the RevComRule and FDA regulations. (See the Required Elements section for ICF content details.) Per the RevComRule, which took effect January 21, 2019, for each clinical trial conducted or supported by a federal department or agency, one (1) EC-approved ICF used to enroll subjects must be posted by the awardee or the federal department or agency component conducting the trial on a publicly available federal website that will be established as a repository for such ICFs. According to USA-12, two (2) federal websites have been identified to meet this requirement: ClinicalTrials.gov (USA-78) and a docket folder on Regulations.gov (USA-79). According to the RevComRule, if the federal department or agency supporting or conducting the clinical trial determines that certain information should not be made publicly available on a federal website (e.g., confidential, commercial information), such federal department or agency may permit or require redactions to the information posted. The ICF must be posted on the federal website after the clinical trial is closed to recruitment and no later than 60 days after the last study visit by any subject, as required by the protocol.
According to 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, no investigator may involve a human being as a participant in research unless the investigator has obtained the legally effective informed consent of the participant or the legal representative/guardian. The participant or the legal representative/guardian should also be given adequate time to consider whether to participate to minimize the possibility of coercion or undue influence.
As indicated in 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, no informed consent, whether oral or written, may contain any language that causes the participant or the legal representative/guardian to waive or appear to waive legal rights, or that releases or appears to release the investigator, sponsor, institution or its agents from liability for negligence.
Additionally, per the RevComRule, participants must be provided with the information that a “reasonable person” would want to have in order to make an informed decision and an opportunity to discuss that information. Furthermore, the RevComRule requires that the informed consent, except for broad consent, must begin with a concise and focused presentation of the key information and organized to facilitate comprehension. Broad consent may be obtained in lieu of informed consent only with respect to the storage, maintenance, and secondary research uses of private identifiable information and identifiable biospecimens.
In addition, per 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the ICF may be presented as either a full length written ICF or as a short form stating the consent requirements have been presented orally. The full length written ICF may be presented orally but must then be provided to the participant or a legal representative/guardian to read before it is signed.
As per the FDA’s G-DecentralCT, obtaining informed consent remotely may be considered as part of a decentralized clinical trial. EC oversight is required to ensure the process is adequate and appropriate. See the G-DecentralCT for more information.
See the FDA’s G-ElectronicIC for recommendations on the use of electronic systems and processes that may employ multiple electronic media to obtain informed consent for both HHS-regulated human subject research and FDA-regulated clinical investigations of medical products.
See the G-InfrmdCnsnt for the FDA’s discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50. Also, see USA-60 for additional information regarding informed consent.
Additionally, see the FDA’s G-SEInfrmdCnsnt for guidance intended to help small businesses better understand the informed consent requirements set forth in 21CFR50.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on obtaining consent.
Re-Consent
According to 21CFR50 and the G-IRBFAQs, participants who are enrolled and actively participating in a study must be informed of significant new findings which may relate to their willingness to continue participation in the study.
The G-IRBFAQs indicates that the FDA does not require re-consenting of participants who have completed their active participation in the study, or of participants who are still actively participating when the change will not affect their participation. One such case is when the change will be implemented only for subsequently enrolled participants.
Language Requirements
21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule state that any information provided must be in a language understandable to the participant or the legal representative/guardian.
As delineated in the FDA’s G-InfrmdCnsnt, when non-English speaking participants are enrolled in a study, ECs and investigators must ensure that the information provided to prospective participants or their legal representative/guardian is in a language that is understandable to them. The EC must review and approve all consent documents that are to be used by investigators to document the informed consent. When translation and interpretation are needed for written and oral information to be presented to participants, the FDA recommends that the EC review and approve reasonable procedures for ensuring that the translations will be prepared by a qualified individual or entity, and that interpretation assistance is available. The FDA also recommends that whenever non-English speaking participants are enrolled in a study, appropriate interpreter services be made available throughout the course of the study.
USA-63 also states that when an oral presentation of the ICF is provided, the witness present should be fluent in both English and the participant’s language, and the translator may serve as the witness. See the G-InfrmdCnsnt and USA-63 for detailed information.
Documenting Consent
As set forth in 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the participant or a legal representative/guardian must sign and date an EC-approved written ICF. A written copy of the form must be given to the participant or a legal representative/guardian. In addition, the RevComRule explicitly allows electronic signatures for consent documentation.
Per 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, if the consent information is only presented orally using the short form, the participant or the legal representative/guardian must sign the form, the witness must sign both the short form and a copy of the summary once consent has been provided, and the person obtaining the consent must sign a copy of the summary. A copy of both the summary and the short form must be given to the participant or the legal representative/guardian.
The FDA’s G-InfrmdCnsnt further states that participants who cannot write can instead indicate their consent by "making their mark" on the consent document. In these situations, a note should be included in participant case histories indicating the reason for the lack of a signature and date as required in 21CFR50. The date consent was obtained should be recorded in this note. See 21CFR11 and the G-Part11 for general FDA regulations and guidance on electronic signatures. Additionally, see the G-ElecSyst for guidance specific to clinical investigations.
Waiver of Consent
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, the EC may waive the requirement to obtain a signed ICF if it finds any of the following:
- The ICF would risk a breach of confidentiality by linking the participant to the study
- The research presents minimal risk and involves no procedures for which written consent is required outside of the study
The RevComRule also adds that the EC may waive the requirements to obtain a signed ICF if the participants are part of a distinct cultural group or community in which signing the form is not the norm, the research presents minimal risk, and there is an alternative approach to document informed consent.
The Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule further indicate that in cases where the documentation requirement is waived, the EC may require the investigator to provide the participant or the legal representative/guardian with a written statement regarding the research.
In addition, 21CFR50, the RevComRule, and the Pre2018-ComRule state that for an EC to approve a general waiver or alteration of consent, the EC must find that:
- The research involves no more than minimal risk
- The research could not practicably be carried out without the requested waiver or alteration
- The waiver or alteration will not adversely affect the rights and welfare of the participants
- Whenever appropriate, the participant or the legal representative/guardian will be provided with additional pertinent information after participation
21CFR50 and the RevComRule also state that for an EC to approve the general waiver or alteration of consent, the EC must find that if the research involves using identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens, the research could not practicably be carried out without using such information or biospecimens in an identifiable format.
Furthermore, the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule specify that although voluntary informed consent is always a requirement for every trial, the EC may approve a waiver or alteration of consent if the study involves a public benefit and service program conducted by or subject to the approval of state or local officials and could not be carried out without the waiver or alteration.
Based on the CanadaFDR and the G-TCPS2, the informed consent form (ICF) should generally include the following statements or descriptions in plain language, as applicable (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in both sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
- Information that the individual is being invited to participate in a research project
- The study involves research and an explanation of its purpose and duration
- The identity of the researcher and the funder/sponsor
- The procedures to be followed
- The participant’s responsibilities
- Any reasonably foreseeable risks or anticipated benefits to the participant and in general
- Information about any payments, including incentives for participants, reimbursement for participation-related expenses, and compensation for injury
- An assurance that prospective participants are under no obligation to participate and are free to withdraw at any time without prejudice to pre-existing entitlements
- An assurance that prospective participants will be given, in a timely manner throughout the course of the research project, information that is relevant to their decision to continue or withdraw from participation
- An assurance that prospective participants will be given information on their right to request the withdrawal of data or human biological materials, including any limitations on the feasibility of that withdrawal
- Information concerning the possibility of commercialization of research findings, and the presence of any real, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest on the part of the researchers, their institutions, or the research sponsors
- The measures to be undertaken for dissemination of research results and whether participants will be identified directly or indirectly
- The identity and contact information of a qualified designated representative who can explain scientific or scholarly aspects of the research to participants
- The identity and contact information of the appropriate individual(s) outside the research team whom participants may contact regarding possible ethical issues in the research
- An indication of what information will be collected about participants and for what purposes
- An indication of who will have access to information collected about the identity of participants
- A description of how confidentiality will be protected
- A description of the anticipated uses of data
- Information indicating who may have a duty to disclose information collected, and to whom such disclosures could be made
- A statement to the effect that, by consenting, participants have not waived any rights to legal recourse in the event of research-related harm
- Information on stopping rules and when researchers may remove participants from trial
- All other aspects of the clinical trial that are necessary for a person to make the decision to participate in the clinical trial
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Based on 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the informed consent form (ICF) must include the following statements or descriptions, as applicable (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
- The study purpose, procedures, and expected duration of the trial
- Identification of any experimental procedures
- Any expected risks or discomforts to the participant, and when applicable, to an embryo or fetus
- Any expected benefits to the participant
- Disclosure of appropriate alternative procedures that might be advantageous to the participant
- The extent, if any, to which confidentiality of records identifying the participant will be maintained and the possibility that the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) may inspect the records
- Compensation and/or treatment available for the participant in the case of trial-related injury
- Contact information for relevant individuals to contact in the event of a trial-related injury
- That participation is voluntary, that refusal to participate will involve no penalty or loss of benefits to which the participant is otherwise entitled, and that the participant can withdraw from the trial at any time without penalty or loss of otherwise entitled benefits
- Foreseeable circumstances under which the investigator may remove the participant without consent
- Any additional costs to the participant that may result from participation in the research
- The consequences of a participant’s decision to withdraw from the study, and procedures for orderly withdrawal by the participant
- Any significant new findings developed during the study that may affect a participant’s willingness to continue participation
- Approximate number of participants in the study
The RevComRule also requires the following statements to be included in the ICF:
- Whether research results will be disclosed to participants
- Whether or not the participant’s information or biospecimens will be used or distributed for future research
- That participant’s biospecimens (even if identifiers are removed) may be used for commercial profit and if the participant will share in this profit
- Whether biospecimens research may include whole genome sequencing
See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
As per 21CFR50, for certain research involving drugs for serious or life-threatening diseases and conditions, the following statement must be included on the informed consent documents: “A description of this clinical trial will be available on https://www.ClinicalTrials.gov, as required by U.S. Law. This Web site will not include information that can identify you. At most, the Web site will include a summary of the results. You can search this Web site at any time.”
In the G-InfrmdCnsnt, the FDA also recommends the consent document advise participants that data collected on them up until the point of their withdrawal from a study will remain part of the study database and may not be removed. See the G-InfrmdCnsnt for additional FDA discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50.
Additionally, the G-DecentralCT provides FDA recommendations for clinical trials with decentralized elements. The G-DecentralCT indicates that, as applicable, the informed consent process in a decentralized clinical trial should inform trial participants: whether local healthcare providers will be used in the conduct of the trial; which trial activities will take place at their homes; and who will have access to their protected health information.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on the informed consent discussion and materials that should be provided to participants.
Compensation Disclosure
The FDA’s G-InfrmdCnsnt further states that if no compensation in the event of injury is available, the consent process should include a statement informing the participant. See the G-InfrmdCnsnt for an example statement.
Overview
In accordance with the CanadaFDR and the G-TCPS2, Canada’s ethical standards promote respect for all human beings and safeguard the rights of research participants. The G-TCPS2 states that a participant’s rights must be clearly addressed in the informed consent form (ICF) and during the informed consent process. For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
The Right to Participate, Abstain, or Withdraw
As stated in the G-TCPS2, the participant or legal representative/guardian should be informed that participation is voluntary, that they may withdraw from the research study at any time, and that refusal to participate will not involve any penalty or loss of benefits to which the participant is otherwise entitled.
The Right to Information
As per the G-TCPS2, a potential research participant or legal representative/guardian has the right to be informed about the nature and purpose of the research study, its anticipated duration, study procedures, any potential benefits or risks, any compensation or treatment in the case of injury, and any significant new information regarding the research study.
The Right to Privacy and Confidentiality
According to the G-TCPS2, all participants must be afforded the right to privacy and confidentiality, and the ICF must provide a statement that recognizes this right.
The Right of Inquiry/Appeal
The G-TCPS2 states that the research participant or legal representative/guardian should be provided with contact information for the individual responsible for addressing trial-related inquiries and/or the participant’s rights.
The Right to Safety and Welfare
The G-FDR-0100 upholds the Declaration of Helsinki (CAN-58), which states that a research participant’s right to safety and the protection of their health and welfare must take precedence over the interests of science and society.
Overview
In accordance with 21CFR50, 21CFR312, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, the United States’ (US) ethical standards promote respect for all human beings and safeguard the rights of research participants. A participant’s rights must also be clearly addressed in the informed consent form (ICF) and during the informed consent process.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on participant rights.
The Right to Participate, Abstain, or Withdraw
As set forth in 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, a potential participant or legal representative/guardian must be informed that participation is voluntary, that the participant may withdraw from the research study at any time, and that refusal to participate will not involve any penalty or loss of benefits to which the participant is otherwise entitled.
The Right to Information
As delineated in 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, a potential research participant or legal representative/guardian has the right to be informed about the nature and purpose of the research study, its anticipated duration, study procedures, any potential benefits or risks, any compensation for participation or injury/treatment, and any significant new information regarding the research study.
The Right to Privacy and Confidentiality
As per 21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, participants must be given a statement describing the extent, if any, to which confidentiality of records identifying them will be maintained.
The RevComRule does allow the use of identifiable private information or biospecimens in instances where the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the US) determines the research could not practicably be carried out without the information. Furthermore, it removes the requirement for the investigator to seek a waiver of informed consent to obtain information or biospecimens to screen, recruit, or determine eligibility of prospective participants. See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and see the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
The G-InfrmdCnsnt, which is the FDA’s discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50, delineates how data should be handled when an enrolled participant decides to withdraw from a trial. Data collected on participants up to the time of withdrawal from clinical investigations of drugs conducted under an investigational new drug application (IND) must remain in the study database to maintain the scientific validity of the research. The FDA recommends that participants be advised in the consent document that the data collected on them up until the point of their withdrawal will remain part of the study database and may not be removed. If a participant withdraws from the interventional portion of the clinical investigation but agrees to continued follow-up not addressed in the original consent document, the investigator must obtain the participant’s informed consent for this limited participation using an EC-approved consent document. If a participant withdraws from the interventional portion of a clinical investigation and does not consent to continued follow-up of associated clinical outcome information, the investigator must not access the participant’s medical record or other confidential records that would require additional consent from the participant. However, such records may be accessed consistent with the original consent process, without additional consent, to obtain information collected prior to the participant’s withdrawal from the study. See the G-InfrmdCnsnt and the G-DataReten for additional information.
The Right of Inquiry/Appeal
21CFR50, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule state that the research participant or legal representative/guardian must be given an explanation of whom to contact for answers to pertinent questions about the research and the participants’ rights, and whom to contact in the event of a research-related injury.
The Right to Safety and Welfare
21CFR50 indicates that compliance with FDA regulations, including 21CFR50, is intended to protect the rights and safety of participants involved in investigations filed with the FDA. As per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, an EC may require that additional information be given to participants if the EC determines the information would meaningfully add to the protection of the rights and welfare of participants.
G-FDR-0100 states that in emergency situations, when prior consent of the participant is not possible, the consent of the participant's legal representative/guardian (as defined by provincial requirements), if present, should be requested. When prior consent of the participant is not possible, and the participant's legal representative/guardian is not available, enrollment of the participant should require measures described in the protocol and/or elsewhere, with documented approval by the ethics committee (EC) (known as a research ethics board in Canada), to protect the participant's rights, safety, and well-being, and to ensure compliance with applicable regulatory requirements. The participant or the participant's legal representative/guardian should be informed about the trial as soon as possible, and consent should be requested as appropriate.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which Canada has implemented per CAN-50. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Per G-TCPS2, research involving medical emergencies must be conducted only if it addresses the emergency needs of the individuals involved, and then only in accordance with criteria established in advance of such research by the EC. The EC may allow research that involves medical emergencies to be carried out without the consent of participants, or legal representatives/guardians, if all of the following apply:
- A serious threat to the prospective participant requires immediate intervention
- Either no standard efficacious care exists, or the research offers a realistic possibility of direct benefit to the participant in comparison with standard care
- Either the risk is not greater than that involved in standard efficacious care, or it is clearly justified by the prospect of direct benefits to the participant
- The prospective participant is unconscious or lacks capacity to understand the risks, methods, and purposes of the research project
- Authorization from the legal representative/guardian cannot be secured in sufficient time, despite diligent and documented efforts to do so
- No relevant prior directive by the participant is known to exist
The G-TCPS2 states that consent will not apply to public health activities undertaken by federal, provincial, and territorial public health officials operating under statutory powers during publicly declared health emergencies. The Ethcs-Emrgcy is an educational resource that provides ethical considerations, including for consent, to help institutions, ECs, and researchers protect participants and uphold public trust in the ethics review and conduct of research during publicly declared emergencies. It includes examples of practical applications from various publicly declared emergency contexts.
21CFR50, 21CFR56, and the G-ICEmrgncyReqs make provisions to protect the rights of a research participant during the informed consent process when the procedure is complicated by life-threatening medical emergencies, public health emergencies, or military operations.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on obtaining consent in emergency situations.
Medical Emergencies
Emergency Use Situation
21CFR56 describes emergency use as the use of a test article, such as an investigational product (IP), on a human participant in a life-threatening situation in which no standard acceptable treatment is available, and in which there is not sufficient time to obtain institutional ethics committee (EC) (referred to as an institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) approval.
21CFR50 and the G-EmrgncyUse indicate that even in an emergency use situation, obtaining participant consent is required unless the investigator and a physician not participating in the trial certify in writing the following:
- The participant is confronted by a life-threatening situation
- Informed consent cannot be obtained due to an inability to communicate with the participant
- Time is insufficient to obtain consent from the participant’s legal representative/guardian
- No alternative methods of approved or generally recognized therapy are available
Per 21CFR50 and the G-EmrgncyUse, if immediate use of the IP is, in the investigator's opinion, required to preserve the participant’s life and time is not sufficient to obtain an independent physician’s determination prior to using the IP, the investigator’s determinations should be carried out. However, within five (5) working days following the use of the IP, the investigator’s decision must be reviewed and evaluated in writing by a physician not participating in the investigation. According to 21CFR50, 21CFR56, and the G-EmrgncyUse, the investigator must also notify the EC within five (5) working days.
21CFR56, the G-EmrgncyUse, and the G-IRBFAQs further state that following emergency use of the IP, EC review and approval is required for any subsequent use of the IP.
Emergency Research
The G-ICEmrgncyReqs defines emergency research as a planned clinical investigation that requires prior written FDA authorization to proceed, and involves participant(s) who are in a life-threatening situation for which available treatments or in vitro diagnostic tests are unproven or unsatisfactory.
21CFR50 and the G-ICEmrgncyReqs delineate that for emergency research, the EC may approve the investigation without requiring the consent of all the participants if the EC (with the concurrence of a licensed physician who is an EC member or EC consultant, and not otherwise participating in the investigation) finds and documents the following:
- The participants are in a life-threatening situation, available treatments are unproven or unsatisfactory, and the collection of valid scientific evidence is necessary to determine the safety and effectiveness of particular interventions
- Obtaining informed consent is not feasible because: (i) the participants will not be able to give their informed consent as a result of their medical condition; (ii) the intervention under investigation must be administered before consent from the participants’ legal representative/guardian is feasible; and (iii) there is no reasonable way to identify prospectively the individuals likely to become eligible for participation in the clinical investigation
- Participation in the research holds out the prospect of direct benefit to the participants
- The clinical investigation could not practicably be carried out without the waiver
- The proposed investigational plan defines the length of the potential therapeutic window based on scientific evidence, and the investigator has committed to attempting to contact a legal representative/guardian for each participant within that window of time and, if feasible, to asking them for consent within that window rather than proceeding without consent
- The EC has reviewed and approved informed consent procedures and an informed consent document consistent with 21CFR50
- Additional protections of the rights and welfare of the participants will be provided
See 21CFR50 and the G-ICEmrgncyReqs for more details.
USA-60 notes that in certain emergency circumstances, the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) Secretarial waiver of informed consent under 46.101(i) of the RevComRule may be applicable. The HHS waiver applies to research that may be carried out in human participants who need emergency therapy and for whom, because of the participants’ medical condition and the unavailability of the participants’ legal representative/guardian, no legally effective informed consent can be obtained. Furthermore, if the research is regulated by the FDA, the HHS waiver permits the research to be conducted under a comparable provision. See the G-HHS-Emrgncy for additional guidance, USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the RevComRule applies to research.
Military Operations
21CFR50 and 10USC55 indicate that in the case of IP administration to a member of the armed forces in connection with participation in a particular military operation, the requirement for the member’s prior consent may be waived only by the US President. The US President may grant the waiver only after determining, in writing, that obtaining consent is not feasible; is contrary to the best interests of the military personnel; or is not in the interests of national security. See 21CFR50 and 10USC55 for detailed requirements.
Overview
Per the G-FDR-0100, the responsibility of an institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as a research ethics board in Canada) is to protect the rights, safety, and well-being of all human participants. An EC should pay special attention to trials that may include vulnerable human participants (elderly, children, mentally ill, prisoners, etc.). The G-TCPS2 states that in all Canadian clinical trials, research participants selected from vulnerable populations must be provided additional protections to safeguard their health and welfare during the informed consent process.
See the Children/Minors; Pregnant Women, Fetuses & Neonates; and Mentally Impaired sections for additional information about these vulnerable populations.
Overview
As per 21CFR56, the Pre2018-ComRule, and the RevComRule, in all United States (US) clinical trials, research participants selected from vulnerable populations must be provided additional protections to safeguard their health and welfare during the informed consent process. Institutional ethics committees (ECs) (institutional review boards (IRBs) in the US) must pay special attention to protecting such participants. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
Per 21CFR56, vulnerable populations may include children, prisoners, pregnant women, handicapped, or mentally disabled persons, or economically or educationally disadvantaged persons. The Pre2018-ComRule describes children, prisoners, pregnant women, handicapped persons, mentally disabled persons, or economically or educationally disadvantaged persons as vulnerable populations. The RevComRule describes children, prisoners, individuals with impaired decision-making capacity, or economically or educationally disadvantaged persons as vulnerable populations.
For more guidance documents related to vulnerable populations, see USA-64.
See the Children/Minors; Pregnant Women, Fetuses, & Neonates; Prisoners; and Mentally Impaired sections for additional information about these vulnerable populations.
Per CAN-35, because the G-TCPS2 does not specify an age of consent for children, the decision on whether to seek consent from children is based on whether they have the capacity to understand the research and the risks and benefits of their participation. Youth who have not reached the age of majority (either 18 or 19 depending on the province or territory) may still be old enough to provide their own consent. For children who are not sufficiently mature to provide consent but are able to understand the nature of study participation, researchers must obtain the child’s assent in addition to the consent of an authorized third party. The decision of a child not to assent must be respected regardless of whether third-party consent was obtained. (Note: CAN-35 offers practical guidance that is consistent with the G-TCPS2, but it is only required for research reviewed by the joint Health Canada (HC)-Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) Research Ethics Board (REB).)
CAN-35 provides the following criteria for determining whether participants can provide their own consent, or whether an authorized third party should be involved:
- The risk level associated with the research project
- The legal requirements for age of consent in that jurisdiction
- The characteristics of the research participant (e.g., maturity level)
- In certain cases, the topic of the research itself
CAN-35 states that it is generally accepted that youth can consent to minimal risk studies at 16 years of age, and that assent should be sought from children beginning at approximately seven (7) years of age. However, it is ultimately up to the researcher to determine whether to obtain assent or consent from children, and to provide the rationale for this decision to the ethics committee (EC) (known as a Research Ethics Board in Canada). Researchers should also consider that within a single research project, some minors may be capable of consenting while others may not. See CAN-35 for additional details regarding obtaining consent from minors.
As per the G-TCPS2, when the research participant is a child, the informed consent form (ICF) must be signed by the child’s parent/legal guardian. All pediatric participants, however, should be informed to the extent compatible with the child’s understanding, and if capable, the pediatric participant should sign and personally date the ICF.
As stated in G-TCPS2, children should only participate in clinical studies when the research objective cannot be achieved with adult participants only. When considering the inclusion of children in research, the investigators and ECs must consider a child’s stage of physical, physiological, psychological, and social development to ensure adequate protections for the child’s welfare.
Assent Requirements
G-FDR-0100 states that if minors are to be included in a trial, the EC should review the assent information considering the age, maturity, and psychological state of the minor population intended to be enrolled, as well as applicable regulatory requirements. Where a minor is to be included as a participant, age-appropriate assent information should be provided and discussed with the minor as part of the consent process, and assent from the minor to enroll in the trial should be obtained as appropriate. A process for consent should be considered if, during the trial, the minor reaches the age of legal consent, in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements.
Per G-TCPS2, where a child has some ability to understand the significance of the research, the researcher must ascertain the wishes of that individual with respect to participation. Children—whose decision-making capacity is in the process of development—may be capable of verbally or physically assenting to, or dissenting from, participation in research. While their assent would not be sufficient to permit them to participate in the absence of consent by the child’s parent/legal guardian, their expression of dissent must be respected. See TCPS2-InterpCnsnt for additional information.
Further, according to CAN-12, which offers best practices and guidance to researchers and ECs in pediatric research and complements the G-TCPS2, provincial laws in Canada vary as to when a child is presumed to be legally competent to provide informed consent. Some provinces use age while others use a competence-based evaluation.
As per CAN-12, if the pediatric participant has the capacity for assent, then affirmative assent is required to participate in a study according to the participant’s level of development and capacities. When the child develops the legal capacity to provide informed consent or attains the legal age of majority (which depends on the province), researchers should obtain an informed consent. Regarding dissent, CAN-12 states that the researchers must respect the dissent of a child who is capable of understanding.
For more details and guidance about best practices for research involving pediatric participants, see CAN-12.
As set forth in 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E, children are defined as persons who have not attained the legal age for consent to treatments or procedures involved in the research, under the applicable law of the jurisdiction in which the study will be conducted. USA-25 further states that the age of majority in most states is 18 and therefore for legal purposes, children are those individuals who have not reached the age of 18. See USA-25 for a table delineating the legal age of majority by state in the United States (US).
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, children require additional safeguards to be included in any research study in order to protect their rights and welfare. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
For all clinical trials that do not involve greater than minimal risk, 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E state that a study may only be conducted if adequate provisions are made to obtain the child’s assent and the permission of their parent/legal guardian.
For all clinical trials that involve greater than minimal risk but present the prospect of direct benefit to the child, 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E indicate that a study may only be conducted if the following applies:
- The risk is justified by the anticipated benefit to the child
- The anticipated benefit is greater than or equal to the available alternative approaches
- Adequate provisions are made to obtain the child’s assent and the permission of their parent/legal guardian
For all clinical trials involving children/minors that involve greater than minimal risk and do not present the prospect of direct benefit to the child, but will likely result in increased knowledge about the child’s disorder or condition, 21CFR50 and the 45CFR46-B-E state that a study may only be conducted if the following applies:
- The risk is slightly greater than minimal
- The trial presents experiences that are similar to those associated with the child’s actual or expected medical, dental, psychological, social, or educational situation
- Adequate provisions are made to obtain the child’s assent and the permission of their parent/legal guardian
For all clinical trials that present a reasonable opportunity to further understand, prevent, or alleviate a serious problem affecting the health or welfare of children/minors but is not otherwise approvable per 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E, a study may only be conducted if the following applies:
- The institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the US) finds that the investigation presents a reasonable opportunity to further the understanding, prevention, or alleviation of a serious problem affecting the health or welfare of children, and,
- The Commissioner of Food and Drugs consults with an expert panel and has an opportunity for public review and comment to determine that the investigation satisfies the conditions of one (1) of the other earlier described research types, or the following conditions are met: the investigation will be conducted in accordance with sound ethical principles and adequate provisions are made for soliciting the assent of children and the permission of their parent/legal guardian
Per the RevComRule, certain exemptions may apply to observational research involving children. See the RevComRule for details.
For additional Food & Drug Administration (FDA) guidance on clinical research in children, see US-ICH-E11, the G-ChldrnSfgrd, and USA-60. Additionally, see the G-InfrmdCnsnt for FDA discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50.
Assent Requirements
Per 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E, when determining whether children/minors are capable of providing assent, the EC must consider their age, maturity, and psychological state. Assent from a child/minor is not necessary for proceeding with the clinical trial if the following applies:
- The capability of some or all of the children/minors is so limited that they cannot reasonably be consulted
- The trial presents a potential direct benefit that is important to the health or well-being of the children/minors and is only available through the investigation
Further, the EC may waive assent, even if the children/minors are capable of providing assent, if it finds and documents the following:
- Trial involves no more than minimal risk
- The waiver will not negatively affect the rights and welfare of the children/minors
- The trial could not be implemented without the waiver
- The children/minors will be given additional information after participation, whenever appropriate
When parent/legal guardian permission is necessary, the EC must determine whether the permission of one (1) parent/legal guardian is sufficient, or if permission from both is required. If the EC determines assent is required, it must also determine whether and how assent must be documented. 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E do specify, however, that the consent of both parents/legal guardians is required in the following cases:
- When there is greater than minimal risk to the child with no direct benefit to the child, but the study will likely result in increased knowledge about the child’s disorder or condition
- Research that presents an opportunity to understand, prevent, or alleviate a serious problem affecting the health or welfare of children/minors, but is not otherwise approvable
Exceptions to the consent requirement involving both parents/legal guardians include when one (1) parent/legal guardian is deceased, unknown, incompetent, or not reasonably available, or, when only one (1) parent/legal guardian has legal responsibility for the care and custody of the child.
The G-InfrmdCnsnt indicates that when obtaining parent/legal guardian permission, in the event that the parent/legal guardian of a child does not understand English, the permission must be obtained and documented in a language that is understandable to the parent/legal guardian. The child who will be participating in the research should not be used as an interpreter for the parent/legal guardian, even if the child is fluent in English and may be able to assent. Further, parent/legal guardian permission and child assent should be viewed as an ongoing process throughout the duration of a clinical investigation. If and when a child who was enrolled in a clinical investigation with parent/legal guardian permission reaches the legal age of consent, that participant no longer meets the definition of a child under 21CFR50, and the investigator should obtain the participant’s informed consent prior to performing any further research interventions and/or procedures involving that participant. See the G-InfrmdCnsnt for additional FDA discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50.
As per the G-TCPS2, studies involving women of childbearing age, or who are pregnant, require additional safeguards to ensure that the research assesses the risks to the women and the fetuses. The following guidance applies to research involving materials related to human reproduction:
- Research using materials related to human reproduction in the context of an anticipated or ongoing pregnancy must not be undertaken if the information can reasonably be obtained by alternative methods
- Materials related to human reproduction for research use must not be obtained through commercial transaction, including exchange for services
Per the G-TCPS2, research on in vitro embryos already created and intended for implantation to achieve pregnancy is acceptable if:
- The research is intended to benefit the embryo
- Research interventions will not compromise the care of the woman, or the subsequent fetus
- Researchers closely monitor the safety and comfort of the woman and the safety of the embryo
- Consent was provided by the gamete donors
According to the G-TCPS2, research involving embryos that have been created for reproductive or other purposes permitted by law, but are no longer required for these purposes, may be ethically acceptable if:
- The ova and sperm from which they are formed were obtained in accordance with the G-TCPS2
- Consent was provided by the gamete donors
- Embryos exposed to manipulations not directed specifically to their ongoing normal development will not be transferred for continuing pregnancy
- Research involving embryos will take place only during the first 14 days after their formation by combination of the gametes, excluding any time during which embryonic development has been suspended
Per the G-TCPS2, research involving a fetus or fetal tissue:
- Requires the consent of the woman
- Must not compromise the woman’s ability to make decisions regarding continuation of her pregnancy
As per 21CFR50 and 45CFR46-B-E, for studies involving women of childbearing age or who are pregnant, a statement should be provided in the informed consent form (ICF) indicating that the treatment or procedure may involve risks to the participant, embryo, or fetus, which are currently unforeseeable.
Per the Pre2018-ComRule, pregnant women require additional safeguards to be included in any research study in order to protect their rights and welfare. Furthermore, according to the RevComRule, all of the available exemptions of the RevComRule for observational research may be applied to research involving pregnant women, fetuses, and neonates. See the RevComRule for details. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
All Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)-sponsored or -funded research involving pregnant women, human fetuses, neonates of uncertain viability, or nonviable neonates must comply with subpart B of 45CFR46-B-E.
Pregnant Women and Fetuses
As per 45CFR46-B-E, pregnant women and fetuses may participate in research if all of the following criteria are met:
- Preclinical and clinical studies have been conducted and provide data for assessing potential risks, where scientifically appropriate
- Risk to the fetus is caused solely by procedures that provide potential direct benefit to the woman or fetus. If there is no potential direct benefit, then the risk to the fetus cannot be greater than minimal, and the intent of the study is to develop important biomedical knowledge that cannot be obtained otherwise
- Least possible risk involved for achieving the research objectives
- Consent is obtained from the woman for studies that provide potential direct benefit to the pregnant woman and/or fetus, and studies with minimal risk to the fetus conducted to develop important biomedical knowledge that cannot be obtained otherwise
- Consent is obtained from the pregnant woman and the father if the study provides potential direct benefit solely to the fetus. Paternal consent is not required if the father is unavailable, incompetent, temporarily incapacitated, or the pregnancy was a result of incest or rape
- All individuals providing consent are fully informed about the foreseeable impact on the fetus or neonate
- No inducements will be offered to terminate a pregnancy
- Participants will not be involved in determining the timing, method, or procedures for terminating a pregnancy
- Participants will not be involved in determining the viability of a neonate
Neonates
45CFR46-B-E states that neonates may not be involved in research unless all of the following criteria are met:
- Preclinical and clinical studies have been conducted and provide data for assessing potential risks, where scientifically appropriate
- All individuals providing consent are fully informed about the foreseeable impact on the neonate
Neonates of uncertain viability may not be involved in research unless the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) determines the following additional conditions are met:
- Research provides the potential for increasing the probability of survival to the point of viability, and involves the least possible risk
- The purpose is to develop important biomedical knowledge that cannot be obtained otherwise and there is no added risk resulting from the research
- Informed consent is obtained from either parent, or if neither parent is able to provide consent, then consent is obtained from the neonate’s legal representative/guardian. Paternal consent is not required if pregnancy was a result of incest or rape.
Nonviable neonates may not be involved in research unless the following additional conditions are met:
- Vital functions will not be maintained artificially
- Research will not terminate the heartbeat or respiration
- The purpose is to develop important biomedical knowledge that cannot be obtained otherwise, and there is no added risk resulting from the research
- Consent is obtained from both parents. If neither parent is able to provide consent, then informed consent of one (1) parent will suffice. Paternal consent is not required if pregnancy was a result of incest or rape. Consent of a legal representative or guardian of either or both parents will not suffice.
Viable neonates may only be included in research to the extent permitted by and in accordance with the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, as applicable, and subpart D of 45CFR46-B-E.
According to the G-TCPS2, prisoners are considered vulnerable because incarceration could affect their ability to make a voluntary decision regarding participation in research. A research study involving prisoners should ensure that these prospective participants are informed and are given the opportunity to make their own decisions without any interference from a higher authority.
As set forth in 45CFR46-B-E, a prisoner is defined as any individual involuntarily confined or detained in a penal institution. Prisoners are considered vulnerable because incarceration could affect their ability to make a voluntary decision regarding participation in research.
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, prisoners require additional safeguards to be included in any research study in order to protect their rights and welfare. As delineated in the RevComRule, none of its observational research exemptions may be applied to research involving prisoners, except for research aimed at involving a broader subject population that only incidentally includes prisoners. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
45CFR46-B-E states that prisoners may participate in nonexempt biomedical or behavioral research conducted or supported by the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) only if the following criteria are met:
- The institution conducting the research has certified to the HHS Secretary that the research has been approved by the institutional ethics committees (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)); research involves minimal risk; and studies focus on the possible causes, effects, and processes of incarceration and criminal behavior, prisons as institutional structures, or prisoners as incarcerated persons
- Research should focus on conditions specifically affecting prisoners as a class, or practices that have the intent and likelihood of improving the health or well-being of participants only after the HHS Secretary has consulted the appropriate experts, and a Federal Register notice is published indicating intent to approve such research
See USA-62 for more HHS information on prisoner research.
As per 45CFR46-B-E, ECs have additional approval responsibilities when reviewing research studies involving prisoners. An EC must only approve these studies if it determines that:
- The research under review represents one (1) of the permissible categories of research delineated in Subpart C
- The prisoner’s judgement will not be impaired by any possible advantages accruing to the prisoner through participation in the research, when compared to the general living conditions, medical care, quality of food, amenities, and opportunity for earnings in the prison
- Research risks are commensurate with those that would be accepted by non-prisoner volunteers
- Procedures for participant selection within the prison are fair to all prisoners and immune from arbitrary intervention by prison authorities or prisoners
- Information is presented in a language understandable to the prisoner population
- Adequate assurance exists that parole boards will not take into account a prisoner's participation in the research in making decisions regarding parole, and each prisoner is clearly informed in advance that participation in the research will have no effect on parole
- As needed, adequate provisions have been made for follow-up examination or care of participants, taking into account the varying lengths of individual prisoners' sentences, and for informing participants of this fact
See Subpart C of 45CFR46-B-E for additional EC requirements related to prisoner research.
According to the G-TCPS2, the ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Board in Canada) must approve the participation of research participants who are mentally or physically incapable of giving consent.
The G-TCPS2 indicates that for research involving individuals who lack the capacity, either permanently or temporarily, to decide for themselves whether to participate, the EC must ensure that, at a minimum, the following conditions are met:
- The researcher involves participants who lack the capacity to decide on their own behalf to the greatest extent possible in the decision-making process
- The researcher seeks and maintains consent from the participant’s legal representative/guardian in accordance with the best interests of the persons concerned
- The legal representative/guardian is not the researcher or any other member of the research team
- The researcher demonstrates that the research is being carried out for the participant’s direct benefit, or for the benefit of other persons in the same category; if the research does not have the potential for direct benefit to the participant but only for the benefit of the other persons in the same category, the researcher must demonstrate that the research will expose the participant to only a minimal risk and minimal burden, and demonstrate how the participant’s welfare will be protected throughout the participation in research
- When authorization for participation was granted by a legal representative/guardian, and a participant acquires or regains decision-making capacity during the course of the research, the researcher must promptly seek the participant’s consent as a condition of continuing participation
The G-TCPS2, the participant’s legal representative/guardian can provide consent for adults who lack the capacity to decide on their own behalf in accordance with the best interests of the persons concerned. In such cases, participants should still be involved to the greatest extent possible in the decision-making process, and their assent to participate must be obtained if they are capable of expressing their wishes in a meaningful way (whether verbally or physically). Importantly, when authorization for participation was granted by the participant’s legal representative/guardian and a participant acquires or regains decision-making capacity during the course of the research, the researcher must promptly seek the participant’s consent as a condition of continuing participation.
According to the G-InfrmdCnsnt, which is the Food & Drug Administration (FDA)’s discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50, impaired consent capacity may involve partial impairment, impairment that fluctuates over time, or complete impairment. Consent capacity can be affected by a wide range of disorders and conditions, such as dementia, stroke, traumatic brain injury, intellectual and developmental disabilities, serious mental illness, intoxication, and delirium.
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, mentally disabled persons/individuals with impaired decision-making capacity require additional safeguards to be included in any research study to protect the rights and welfare of participants likely to be vulnerable to coercion or undue influence. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.)
USA-60 further indicates that while Department of Health & Human Services (HHS) regulations do not provide specific procedures, it is expected that for research involving adult participants with mental illnesses or cognitive impairments, the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) and investigator(s) must be knowledgeable about the condition and any level of impairment that is likely to be present in the participant population.
As stated in the FDA’s G-InfrmdCnsnt, ECs and investigators should carefully consider whether the inclusion in research of individuals who lack consent capacity is ethically appropriate and scientifically necessary. Considerations that may help address these challenges and provide additional safeguards include:
- Assessing consent capacity of prospective participants, for example, through use of an independent, qualified professional
- Establishing a waiting period in the decision-making process to allow additional time for decision-making
- Using methods to enhance consent capacity, for example through (1) simplification and/or repetition of information, (2) involvement of a participant advocate or trusted family member/friend to assist when sharing information about the clinical investigation, and (3) refraining from discussions during periods of heightened impairment, when possible
- Assessing a participant’s understanding after information about the clinical investigation has been imparted, for example, through use of a questionnaire
- Re-assessing consent capacity after initiation of the clinical investigation for participants with progressive disorders whose cognition may decline
- Involving a legally authorized representative and/or guardian either initially or later in the clinical investigation if consent capacity diminishes
- Assessing whether prospective participants who cannot provide legally effective consent on their own behalf may nonetheless be able to provide some form of oral agreement at the outset of the study and, as appropriate, throughout the course of the research (e.g., for participants with progressive disorders), and how such oral agreement would be documented
- Emphasizing the voluntary nature of the decision to participate and the right to withdraw at any time
- Determining whether the EC or a third party should observe the consent process
See the G-InfrmdCnsnt for additional information and FDA discussion of the regulations in 21CFR50.
As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-GMP-Annex13, an investigational product is defined as a pharmaceutical form of an active ingredient or placebo being tested or used as a reference in a clinical trial, including a product with a marketing authorization when used or assembled (formulated or packaged) in a way different from the approved form.
For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
As delineated in 21CFR312, an investigational new drug is defined as a new drug or biological drug that is used in a clinical investigation. This includes a biological product that is used in vitro for diagnostic purposes. The terms ‘investigational drug’ and ‘investigational new drug’ are deemed to be synonymous for the purposes of 21CFR312.
Manufacturing
As specified in the CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps, Health Canada (HC) authorizes the manufacture of investigational products (IPs) in Canada. HC approves the manufacture of IPs as part of the clinical trial application (CTA) approval. The G-QCM-PharmCTAs provides guidance and templates to assist sponsors in completing the quality portion of the CTA, which in turn, enables HC to assess IP characteristics adequately. The G-GMP-Annex13 requires the sponsor to ensure that IPs for clinical trials are manufactured and imported in accordance with its provisions and with CanadaFDR requirements. Per the G-CanadaCTApps, sponsors must file amendments or notifications to a previously authorized CTA when manufacturing changes are proposed that may affect the quality or safety of the clinical trial drug or biologic supplies.
Per G-GMP-Annex13, during development, critical parameters and in-process controls should be identified, adapted based on production experience, and justified by the knowledge available at the time. Although the manufacturing process need not be validated to the extent necessary for routine production, premises and equipment are expected to be validated in accordance with applicable good manufacturing practice (GMP) principles. Manufacturers must identify process steps that ensure participant safety and the reliability and robustness of clinical trial data and maintain written cleaning procedures and analytical methods to prevent cross-contamination. For sterile products, controls and processes related to sterility should meet the same standards as those for marketed products; where required, virus inactivation/removal and removal of other biological impurities should be demonstrated, with enhanced attention to aseptic-process validation and operator training. If a drug is modified, data such as stability, comparative dissolution, or bioavailability should demonstrate that the changes do not significantly alter its original quality characteristics; the sponsor should justify an appropriate retest date, and a reference sample of the comparator product should be retained following repackaging or over-encapsulation. For blinded products, systems should maintain the blind while permitting rapid product identification when necessary; where the manufacturer generates randomization codes, unblinding information should be available to the person in charge of quality control before the drugs are supplied, and the expiry assigned to all products should correspond to that of the shortest-dated product. See the G-GMP-Annex13 for additional details.
Per CAN-55, HC is a member of the Pharmaceutical Inspection Co-operation Scheme (PIC/S) and meets international GMP standards.
Per CAN-50, Canada has implemented the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which provides additional guidelines on manufacturing IPs. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Import
Per the CanadaFDR and the G-FDR-0100, HC authorizes the sponsor to import an IP. A sponsor who is not based in Canada must have a Canadian representative who is responsible for the import of the IP and demonstrates compliance with the applicable regulatory requirements. This representative should be the sponsor’s senior medical or scientific officer residing in Canada and is responsible for providing an attestation with respect to the CTA at the time of filing. Per the G-CanadaCTApps, the G-DrugApp, and CAN-4, if clinical trial drugs are to be imported into Canada, the authorization template (Appendix 1) in CAN-4 should be completed and submitted for each importer in Canada. The G-DrugApp states that Canadian importer(s) must be located within Canada. As additional importers are identified, additional copies of the authorization template in CAN-4 should be provided to HC.
The G-FDR-0100 provides additional guidance on requirements if a sponsor plans to send the clinical trial IP(s) directly to each trial site:
- A No Objection Letter (NOL) has been issued by HC authorizing the importation of the clinical trial material in Phase I-III trials; no clinical trial drugs should be imported prior to the NOL issuance and the NOL should accompany the package at the time of the importation
- Each party, including individual Canadian clinical trial sites, importing drugs directly (i.e., receiving drug shipments directly from outside of Canada) is identified on Appendix 1 of the Drug Submission Application Form (HC/SC 3011 form) (CAN-4)
- Clinical Trial Site Information (CTSI) forms (CAN-6) for each Canadian site conducting the clinical trial are submitted to HC for Phase I-III trials, prior to the start of the study
- Systems are in place, when appropriate, to monitor the transportation and storage conditions from the foreign source to the various clinical trial sites across Canada
- There is documented accountability of the imported drugs used in clinical trials and distributed to various clinical trial sites located in Canada, including the disposition of drugs returned from the clinical trial sites
- A written agreement is in place between the sponsor and the qualified investigator (QI) describing their specific responsibilities, and this agreement is available at the clinical trial site
- There is evidence that the drugs used in clinical trials conducted in Canada meet GMP requirements (e.g., certificates of manufacture, certificates of analysis, and/or evidence of approved lot release by a QI)
The G-CanadaCTApps, the G-HlthProdImprtExptReqs, the G-FDR-0100, and CAN-32 state that if a sponsor wants to import a drug into Canada for a clinical trial, a copy of HC’s authorization (i.e., the NOL) issued by either the Pharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (PDD) or the Biologic and Radiopharmaceutical Drugs Directorate (BRDD) must be included for the applicable trial with the shipment. A copy of this authorization must be provided at the port of entry. The G-HlthProdImprtExptReqs states that drugs without a Drug Identification Number may be imported where authorized for a Canadian clinical trial and a NOL was issued. The G-FDR-0100 further states that if 30 days have passed and the NOL was not issued, specific requests to import IPs should be directed to the Health Product Border Compliance Program at the following email account: hpbcp-pcpsf@hc-sc.gc.ca. Note that a sponsor does not have to submit a CTA for authorization to import an IP used in a Phase IV clinical trial.
Per CanadaFDR, the sponsor can make the following changes to the authorized use or importation of drugs if the sponsor notifies HC in writing within 15 days after the date of the change:
- A change to the chemistry and manufacturing information that does not affect the quality or safety of the drug
- A change to the protocol that does not alter the risk to the health of a clinical trial participant
Other changes must follow the amendment requirements delineated in the CanadaFDR. See the G-FDR-0100 for additional HC interpretations of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR.
Manufacturing
According to 21CFR312 and USA-42, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) is responsible for authorizing the manufacture of investigational products (IPs) (also known as investigational new drugs in the United States (US)).
Per 21CFR312, sponsors that use an IP not already subject to a manufacturer’s investigational new drug application (IND) or marketing application are required to provide all of the technical chemistry, manufacturing, and control (CMC) information outlined in the application content and format requirements section of 21CFR312, unless such information may be referenced from applicable scientific literature. Sponsors using an IP already subject to a manufacturer’s application should follow the same general application format but may, if authorized by the manufacturer, refer to the manufacturer’s application to provide the technical (CMC) information supporting the proposed clinical investigation.
Moreover, as stated in 21CFR312, a sponsor may ship an IP to the investigators named in the IND under the following conditions:
- Thirty (30) days after the FDA receives the IND, or
- FDA provides earlier authorization to ship the IP
The sponsor is responsible for complying with the principles of good manufacturing practice (GMP) as specified in 21CFR210, the G-CGMP-Phase1, the G-CMC-Phase2-3, and the G-INDPrep.
Import
As set forth in 21CFR312, the FDA is also responsible for authorizing the import and export of IPs. An IP may be imported into the US if it is subject to an IND that is in effect for it and complies with one (1) of the following requirements:
- The IP consignee is the IND sponsor, or
- The consignee is a qualified investigator named in the IND, or
- The consignee is the domestic agent of a foreign sponsor, is responsible for the control and distribution of the IP, and the IND identifies the consignee and describes what, if any, actions the consignee will take with respect to the IP
See USA-23 for general FDA information on importing human drugs.
Investigator’s Brochure
In accordance with the CanadaFDR, the sponsor is responsible for providing the investigators with an Investigator’s Brochure (IB). The IB must contain all the relevant information on the investigational product(s) (IPs), including significant physical, chemical, pharmaceutical, pharmacological, toxicological, pharmacokinetic, metabolic, and clinical information. The sponsor must ensure that an up-to-date IB is made available to the investigator(s), and the investigator(s) must provide an up-to-date IB to the ethics committee. Per CAN-50, Canada has implemented the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which provides additional guidance on IB development and contents. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence. For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100.
The CanadaFDR requires the IB to provide coverage of the following areas:
- Physical, chemical, and pharmaceutical properties and formulation parameters
- Non-clinical studies (pharmacology, pharmacokinetics, toxicology, and metabolism profiles)
- Effects of IP in humans (pharmacology, pharmacokinetics, metabolism, and pharmacodynamics; safety and efficacy; and regulatory and post-marketing experiences)
- Summary of data and guidance for the investigator(s)
In accordance with the G-CanadaCTApps, the sponsor must submit annually to HC an updated IB, which serves as the annual report, including all safety information and global status. Revisions that are more frequent may be appropriate depending on the stage of development and the generation of relevant new information.
Quality Management
As specified in the G-GMP-CAN and G-GMP-Annex13, the sponsor must ensure that the products are manufactured in accordance with good manufacturing practice (GMP). The G-GMP-CAN requires a quality management system, incorporating GMP, to ensure that IPs are of the quality required for their intended use.
Per the G-GMP-Annex13, the manufacturer’s quality system should be described in written procedures and available to the sponsor, taking into account GMP principles and guidelines. The manufacturer should establish and maintain a quality control system placed under the authority of a person who has the requisite qualifications and is independent of production. Quality control of the clinical trial drug, including that of the comparator product or placebo, should be performed in accordance with the information submitted in the application for the clinical trial, as authorized by the relevant country. Verification of the effectiveness of blinding should be performed and recorded.
Per the G-FDR-0100, if a sponsor plans to send the clinical trial IP(s) directly to each trial site, there should be evidence that the drugs used in clinical trials conducted in Canada meet GMP requirements (e.g., certificates of manufacture, certificates of analysis, and/or evidence of approved lot release by a qualified individual).
Investigator's Brochure
In accordance with 21CFR312, the sponsor is responsible for providing investigators with an Investigator’s Brochure (IB). The IB must contain all of the relevant information on the investigational new drug(s)/investigational product(s) (IPs) obtained through the earlier research phases. The sponsor must also update the IB as significant new information becomes available.
As specified in 21CFR312, the IB must provide coverage of the following areas:
- A brief description of the drug substance and the formulation, including the structural formula, if known
- A summary of the pharmacological and toxicological effects of the drug in animals and, to the extent known, in humans
- A summary of the pharmacokinetics and biological disposition of the drug in animals and, if known, in humans
- A summary of information relating to safety and effectiveness in humans obtained from prior clinical studies
- A description of possible risks and side effects to be anticipated on the basis of prior experience with the drug under investigation or with related drugs, and of precautions or special monitoring to be done as part of the investigational use of the drug
For investigational new drug applications (INDs) that include clinical data provided from studies conducted outside of the United States (US), 21CFR312 states that the sponsor or applicant must submit a description of the actions taken to ensure that the research conformed to good clinical practice (GCP). See Section 312.120 of 21CFR312 for detailed requirements.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on IB development and contents.
Quality Management
According to USA-39, submitting a copy of the Certificate of Analysis of the clinical batch is suggested, but not required by the FDA.
Investigational product (IP) labeling in Canada must comply with the requirements set forth in the CanadaFDR, the G-CanadaCTApps, and the G-GMP-Annex13. The CanadaFDR and the G-CanadaCTApps state that for an IP to be used in a clinical trial, it must be properly labeled in both official languages: English and French. The CanadaFDR requires that IPs be packaged and labelled under the supervision of personnel who have had satisfactory technical, academic, and other training. The packager and/or labeler must have written procedures and ensure that the IP is packaged, labelled, and tested in compliance with those procedures. For Health Canada (HC)’s interpretation of the relevant provisions of the CanadaFDR, see the G-FDR-0100. Per CAN-50, Canada has implemented the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which provides additional guidelines on labeling IPs. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
As delineated in the CanadaFDR and the G-GMP-Annex13, the following information must be included on the IP label:
- A statement indicating that the drug is an IP to be used only by a qualified investigator
- Name, number, or identifying mark
- Expiration date
- Recommended storage conditions
- Lot number
- Sponsor’s name and address
- Protocol code or identification
- Radiopharmaceutical information, if applicable
Per the G-FDR-0100, a label includes any legend, word, or mark attached to, included in, belonging to, or accompanying any drug or package. The sponsor is responsible for ensuring that the labeling of a clinical trial drug meets the requirements of the CanadaFDR, and that the system in place is validated, traceable, and does not compromise participant safety or product quality. The required information must be attached to, included with, or accompany each container of the drug product. If a label provides all the required information in both official languages (English and French), it is considered to have met the requirements of the CanadaFDR. However, traceability to the manufacturing lot should be maintained on the label immediately attached to the IP (i.e., primary container) such that its identity can be determined, and, if necessary, which unit was dispensed to each participant. For blinded clinical trials the sponsor must ensure that labeling information does not compromise the blinding. Labeling of a clinical trial drug with a manufacturer's lot number may compromise a blinded clinical trial. Identifiers other than a "lot" or "(L)" number (for example a batch number, a kit number, or a bar code) may be considered compliant, provided traceability is maintained. Where a bar code is included as the identifier on the label, the code on the drug label should readily link to information (for example, lot number and expiration date) through a validated computerized system. During an inspection, HC may verify that there is a system of traceability in place to ensure participant safety and that the computerized system, if applicable, is fully validated. It is acceptable for a marketed drug used in a clinical trial as a comparator, to be labelled in accordance with its marketing authorization, provided that the label on the marketed drug is appropriate for the trial. However, a marketed comparator drug used off-label must comply with the IP labeling requirements.
With regard to the expiration date, the G-GMP-Annex13 states that if it becomes necessary to change the expiration date, an additional label should be affixed to the IP. This additional label should state the new expiration date and repeat the batch number. It may be superimposed on the previous expiration date, but for quality control reasons, not on the original batch number. This operation should be performed at an appropriately authorized manufacturing site. However, when justified, it may be performed at the investigational site by or under the supervision of the clinical trial site pharmacist or other health care professional in accordance with national regulations and with the sponsor’s requirements. Where this is not possible, it may be performed by the clinical trial monitor(s) who should be appropriately trained. The operation should be performed in accordance with good manufacturing practice (GMP) principles, operating procedures, and applicable contractual provisions, and should be checked by a second person. This additional labeling should be properly documented in both the trial documentation and in the packaging records.
As indicated in the G-FDR-0100, HC may verify that a clinical trial drug has a valid expiration date during an inspection. If stability studies to support the expiration date for an IP are still ongoing at the time of labeling, the following may be considered acceptable in lieu of an expiration date:
- A re-test date on the label if the sponsor has data to support the extended shelf-life of the drug, and
- A manufacturing date is listed on the label, as long as the clinical trial site where the drug is dispensed has a document from the sponsor documenting the shelf-life of the drug
The above process should be documented, and procedures and quality control systems should be in place and in accordance with the approved clinical trial application. This additional labeling information should be properly documented in both the trial documentation and in the packaging records.
Investigational new drug/investigational product (IP) labeling in the United States (US) must comply with the requirements set forth in Section 312.6 of 21CFR312, which include the following:
- The immediate package of an IP intended for human use must bear a label with the following statement: “Caution: New Drug-Limited by Federal (or US) law to investigational use”
- The label or labeling of an IP must not bear any false or misleading statements and must not represent that the IP is safe or effective for the purposes for which it is being investigated
The appropriate Food & Drug Administration (FDA) Center Director may grant an exception or alternative to the requirements above for specific lots, batches, or other units of a human drug or biological product that is or will be included in the Strategic National Stockpile.
Supply, Storage, and Handling Requirements
Per CanadaFDR, drugs must be manufactured, handled, and stored in accordance with good manufacturing practice (GMP). For investigational product (IP) packaging, the G-GMP-Annex13 provides the following guidance:
- The risk of product mix up must be minimized by using appropriate procedures, specialized equipment, and relevant staff training.
- To prevent errors, particularly when IPs are blinded, use heightened precautions, such as label reconciliation, line clearance, and in-process control checks by appropriately trained staff.
- The packaging must ensure that the IP remains in good condition during transport and storage at intermediate destinations; any opening or tampering of the outer packaging during transport should be readily discernible.
The G-Storage provides principles and interpretations on the environmental control of clinical trial drugs during storage and transportation, including packaging. See G-Storage for information regarding compliance with the CanadaFDA and the CanadaFDR, as it relates to packaging clinical trial drugs for human use, such as the role of environmental controls, quality risk management, and special considerations for active pharmaceutical ingredients.
G-Dcntrl states that for decentralized activities, sponsors and qualified investigators (QIs) must ensure GMP- and protocol-compliant transport, storage, and handling of IPs. Sponsors are responsible for preserving product integrity during transport and storage and addressing controlled-substance diversion risks. QI oversight may include maintaining accountability for the IP at decentralized locations. Sponsors should ensure that direct-to-home shipment and dispensing comply with applicable provincial and territorial requirements.
Per CAN-50, Canada has implemented the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3) (CAN-52), which provides additional guidance on IP management. The G-FDR-0100 explains the relationship between the CanadaFDR and CAN-52, including additional guidance where needed or where CAN-52 does not apply. At all times, where the CanadaFDR exceeds the guidance set out in CAN-52, the CanadaFDR takes precedence.
Record Requirements
As set forth in the CanadaFDR, the G-FDR-0100, and the CanadaFDR1024, the sponsor must record, handle, and store all trial-related information to allow complete and accurate reporting, interpretation, and verification. The CanadaFDR states that the sponsor should maintain all trial-related records for a period of 15 years. Pursuant to CanadaFDR1024, the sponsor must submit requested records to HC within 48 hours if safety concerns arise. Additionally, to facilitate inspection of a site, the sponsor must submit information to Health Canada (HC) within seven (7) days of a request.
Per the G-FDR-0100, drug accountability records should include the following information:
- Date of arrival on site
- Quantity received
- Identification (batch/lot number)
- Expiration date
- Quantity and date dispensed and to whom
- Quantity and date returned by participants
- Quantity and date of destruction or return to sponsor
As explained in the G-FDR-0100, to ensure that participants receive the IP according to their randomization, qualified investigators (QIs) should maintain records. The QI and/or a pharmacist or other appropriate individual should maintain records of the product's delivery, the inventory, the use by each participant (including documenting that the participants were provided the doses specified by the protocol), and the return to the sponsor and destruction or alternative disposition of unused product(s). Drug accountability records are required for:
- Drugs that are the subject of the clinical trial, and do not have market authorization
- Drugs that are the subject of the clinical trial, have market authorization, but are used off-label
- Comparator drug, if it does not have market authorization
- Comparator drug, if it has market authorization, but its labeling was changed (for example for blinding purposes)
- Comparator drug, if it has market authorization, but is used off-label (unless it was not considered to be investigational in the context of the particular clinical trial, based on the assessment of the application)
Further, per in the G-FDR-0100, drug accountability records are not required for:
- Drugs that are the subject of a Phase IV clinical trial
- Comparator drug, if it has market authorization, is used on-label, and has not been altered in any manner
- Rescue or concomitant medications, authorized for sale in Canada, that may be used on or off-label but are not the subject of the clinical trial (for example, they are used as supportive medications for known clinical applications)
The G-Storage provides that when contracted parties, such as warehouses or commercial carriers, store or transport drugs, there should be a written agreement that outlines all relevant conditions.
See CAN-52 for additional guidance on IP record keeping.
Supply, Storage, and Handling Requirements
Per 21CFR312, the G-CGMP-Phase1, and the G-CMC-Phase2-3, and the G-INDPrep, the sponsor/manufacturer must ensure the following (Note: Each of the items listed below will not necessarily be found in all sources, which provide overlapping and unique elements):
- Investigational new drug/investigational product (IP) product quality and stability
- IP manufactured according to any applicable good manufacturing practice (GMP)
- Proper coding, packaging, and labeling of the IP(s)
- The return and disposition of all unused supply of the IP
Refer to the G-CGMP-Phase1, the G-CMC-Phase2-3, and the G-INDPrep for detailed IP management requirements.
The FDA’s G-DecentralCT states that in some cases, decentralized clinical trials may involve the direct distribution of IPs to trial participants or local health care providers (HCPs). In these cases, investigators must remain responsible for supervising the supply of IP to trial participants or local HCPs. When applicable, trial personnel should be trained on procedures and appropriate documentation for handling, packaging, shipping, and tracking IPs. See the G-DecentralCT for detailed information.
Also see the International Council for Harmonisation (ICH)’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on IP management.
Record Requirements
According to 21CFR312, the sponsor must maintain adequate records showing the receipt, shipment, or other disposition of the IP. These records are required to include, as appropriate, the name of the investigator to whom the drug is shipped, and the date, quantity, and batch or code mark of each such shipment. Additionally, the investigator(s) is required to maintain adequate records of the disposition of the drug, including dates, quantity, and use by participants. The investigator(s) is also required to prepare and maintain adequate and accurate case histories that record all observations and other data pertinent to the investigation on each individual to which the IP was administered, or who was employed as a control in the investigation. See 21CFR312 for more details.
As per 21CFR312, the sponsor/the investigator(s) must retain the above records and reports for two (2) years after a marketing application (known as a new drug application (NDA)) is approved for the IP; or, if an NDA is not approved, until two (2) years after shipment and delivery of the IP is discontinued for investigational use and the FDA has been so notified.
Also see the ICH’s Guideline for Good Clinical Practice E6(R3), which the FDA has implemented in US-ICH-GCP, for additional guidance on IP record keeping.
In Canada, a specimen is referred to as “human biological material” or “biological material.” According to the G-TCPS2, human biological materials include tissues, organs, blood, plasma, skin, serum, DNA, RNA, proteins, cells, hair, nail clippings, urine, saliva, and other body fluids. The term also comprises materials related to human reproduction, including embryos, fetuses, fetal tissues, and human reproductive materials. The G-TCPS2 breaks down human biological material further into the following categories: anonymized, anonymous, coded, and identified human biological materials. Refer to the G-TCPS2 for more detailed information on these categories.
In addition, CAN-2 defines biological material as pathogenic and non-pathogenic microorganisms, proteins, and nucleic acids, as well as any biological matter that may contain microorganisms, proteins, nucleic acids, or parts thereof. Examples include, but are not limited to, bacteria, viruses, fungi, prions, toxins, genetically modified organisms, nucleic acids, tissue samples, diagnostic specimens, live vaccines, and isolates of a pathogen (e.g., pure culture, suspension, purified spores).
A specimen, referred to as patient specimen in 49CFR173, is defined as human or animal material collected directly from humans or animals and transported for research, diagnosis, investigational activities, or disease treatment or prevention. Patient specimen includes excreta, secreta, blood and its components, tissue and tissue swabs, body parts, and specimens in transport media (e.g., transwabs, culture media, and blood culture bottles).
In addition, 42CFR73 defines specimen as samples of material from humans, animals, plants, or the environment or isolates or cultures from such samples for diagnosis, verification, or proficiency testing.
The RevComRule defines an identifiable biospecimen as one for which the identity of the participant is or may readily be ascertained by the investigator or associated with the biospecimen. (See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the RevComRule applies to research.)
Import/Export
According to the G-HlthProdImprtExptReqs, Health Canada (HC) does not have jurisdiction over human biological materials to be imported for testing or research purposes. The G-HlthProdImprtExptReqs further states that all blood samples as well as cultures, diagnostic specimens, or research tissue may be potential carriers of human or animal pathogens, and are regulated by the Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA). Per CAN-24 and CAN-2, the PHAC’s Centre for Biosecurity oversees the licensing process under the authority of the HPTA and the HPTR. The HPTA states that a license must be issued by the Minister that authorizes the import or export of human pathogens or toxins.
As specified in the HPTA, the HPTR, and CAN-2, individuals planning to conduct controlled activities (including producing, possessing, handling, using, storing, providing access to, transferring, disposing of, releasing, abandoning, or importing/exporting) with a human pathogen or toxin, whether imported or domestically acquired, must obtain a license. Per CAN-2, because all human biological materials are potential carriers of human pathogens, the PHAC has categorized these materials by risk group based on risk to the individual/animal and risk to the community. Risk Group 1 consists of microorganisms, nucleic acids, or proteins that are unable or unlikely to cause human or animal disease so they are generally not considered to be pathogens, and are therefore exempt from the HPTA and the HPTR licensing requirements. Risk groups 2 through 4 are considered to be pathogens or toxins with moderate to high individual risk and low to high community risk, and are subject to the HPTA and the HPTR licensing requirements. See CAN-2 for detailed information and instructions on how to obtain a license for activities associated with Risk Groups 2 through 4.
Other Considerations
Per the G-TCPS2, institutions and researchers that maintain biobanks must ensure that they have or use appropriate facilities, equipment, policies, and procedures to store human biological materials safely, and in accordance with applicable standards. They must also establish appropriate physical, administrative, and technical safeguards to protect human biological materials and any information about participants from unauthorized handling. Procedures for storage and record keeping must include effective measures to ensure that participants’ identities are protected, including the security of facilities and effective procedures for data handling, record keeping, and regulating access to human biological materials and information. Appropriate governance of biobanks is also important for managing access to and use of stored biological materials. The appropriate governance structure and management of a biobank will vary depending on its size and usage. Organizations that maintain biobanks may have their own policies on privacy of, confidentiality of, and access to materials. Researchers should be aware of requirements for compliance with such policies. Identifiable data derived from human biological materials may be linked to other research or public databases. Researchers who propose to engage in data linkage must obtain ethics committee (EC) approval prior to carrying out the data linkage. Where data linkage involves or is likely to produce identifiable information, researchers must show that the data linkage is essential to the research, and appropriate security measures will be implemented to safeguard information.
Import/Export
The import and export of human specimens, also known as patient/diagnostic specimens/substances or human biological materials in the United States (US), is governed by several federal agencies working cooperatively to ensure the safe transport of these materials. These agencies include, but are not limited to, the Department of Transportation (DOT)’s Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration (PHMSA), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)’s Import Permit Program (IPP), the Department of Health & Human Services (HHS), the United States Postal Service (USPS), and the International Air Transport Association (IATA). The IATA has also adopted all of the hazardous materials requirements set forth in the Technical Instructions for the Safe Transport of Dangerous Goods by Air (USA-10) published biannually by the United Nations (UN)’ International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO).
Additionally, 28CFR202 prohibits certain data transactions that involve giving a country of concern or covered person access to: 1) bulk US sensitive personal data that involves bulk human ‘omic data; or 2) to human biospecimens from which bulk human ‘omic data could be derived. See the Personal Data Protection section and 28CFR202 for more information.
Infectious Specimens
Per 49CFR173, 42CFR73, 42CFR71, HzrdsMtrls, USA-21, USA-4, and USA-31, DOT’s PHMSA, IATA, USPS, and CDC’s IPP refer to an infectious specimen/substance as a Division 6.2 material (Category A or Category B), or a select agent, etiologic agent, toxin, or infectious biological agent. The CDC’s IPP is specifically responsible for the importation of infectious specimens/substances/biological agents/vectors of human disease per 42CFR71 and for regulating the possession, use, and transfer of select agents and toxins per 42CFR73. See 42CFR71, 42CFR73, USA-31, and USA-73 for further information and permit applications for these import/transfer programs.
Additionally, the Department of Commerce (DOC)’s Bureau of Industry and Security is responsible for regulating the export of a wide range of infectious specimens that may require a DOC license. Refer to the Commerce Control List (CCL) in 15CFR774 and USA-30 to determine if a DOC export permit is required for specific specimens.
According to 49CFR173, USA-21, and USA-4, certain materials and specimens are exempt from the DOT’s PHMSA, IATA, and USPS requirements for import/export of infectious specimens. As stated in 49CFR173, these include, among others: materials that do not contain infectious substances; non-infectious biological materials from humans, animals, or plants; and materials with a low probability of containing an infectious substance. USA-4 notes that exempt human or animal specimens are not subject to regulation as hazardous materials, but are subject to specific packaging procedures that must be followed when shipped. Please refer to 49CFR173, HzrdsMtrls, USA-21, and USA-4 for detailed DOT, IATA, and USPS shipping instructions.
NIH Specimen Requirements
The HHS’ National Institutes of Health (NIH) researchers must also comply with all applicable federal and international air and ground transport laws and regulations. Researchers must also receive prior authorization from the NIH’s Quarantine Permit Service Office to obtain permits for the import, transfer, or export of all specimens to the NIH. Detailed instructions about how to proceed are outlined in USA-71.
Per the National Cancer Institute (NCI)’s USA-2, a Material Transfer Agreement (MTA) or contract should be used for the transfer of biospecimens and data among academic, nonprofit, and/or industrial organizations. See USA-2 for detailed MTA requirements and Appendix 4 for a sample MTA.
In accordance with the G-TCPS2, prior to collecting, storing, or using a research participant’s biological specimen(s), consent from the participant and/or the legal representative(s) and review/approval from the institutional ethics committee (EC) (known as Research Ethics Board (REB) in Canada) must be obtained. Specifically, consent is required from the following:
- The participant who will be donating biological materials, or an authorized third party on behalf of a participant who lacks capacity, taking into account any research directive that applies to the participant, or
- A deceased participant through a donation decision made prior to death, or by an authorized third party
In addition, the G-TCPS2 states that to seek participant consent to use the participant’s biological materials in research, the investigator(s) must provide the prospective participant or authorized third party with the following information:
- The type and amount of biological materials to be taken
- The manner in which biological materials will be taken, and the safety and invasiveness of the procedures
- The intended uses of the biological materials, including any commercial use
- The measures employed to protect the privacy of and minimize risks to participants
- The length of time the biological materials will be kept, how they will be preserved, location of storage (e.g., in Canada or outside Canada), and process for disposal, if applicable
- Any anticipated linkage of biological materials with information about the participant
- The plan for handling results and findings, including clinically relevant information and incidental findings
- The participant’s right to request the withdrawal of data or human biological materials, including any limitations on the feasibility of that withdrawal
The G-TCPS2 states that to seek broad consent for the storage and future unspecified use of human biological materials, researchers must provide prospective participants, or authorized third parties, with applicable information as set out in the informed consent requirements, as well as the following details:
- The type, identifiability, and amount of human biological materials being collected and stored for re-use, and for what potential purpose
- The voluntariness of the participant’s consent, including any limitations on the feasibility of withdrawal
- A general description of the nature and types of future research that may be conducted, including whether the research might be conducted outside of Canada (if known)
- The risks and potential benefits of storage of human biological materials and of their use in future unspecified research, including areas of uncertainty where risks cannot be estimated
- Access to a general description of the repository and its governance
- A statement regarding participants’ preference to being contacted for additional future research
- Whether the human biological materials could be shared with researchers who are not subject to the G-TCPS2
- Whether the research will (if known) or might include whole genome sequencing or similar technologies that may pose a substantial risk of re-identification of the participant or identification of material incidental findings (when appropriate)
- Separate options for consenting to participate in a specific research project and for consenting to the storage of human biological materials for future unspecified research
See Brd-Cnst for additional clarifications on broad consent for the storage and future unspecified use of data.
See the G-Dcntrl for considerations on collecting specimens during home visits in decentralized clinical trials. Also see the G-TCPS2 for additional details on confidentiality, future use of information, broad consent for the storage of data and human biological materials for future unspecified research, biobanks, and stem cell consent.
As delineated in the G-IC-IVDs, the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) only provides informed consent guidance with respect to its regulations governing the informed consent requirement when human specimens are used for FDA-regulated in vitro diagnostic device investigations.
Informed consent requirements guiding Department of Health & Human Services (HHS)-conducted or -supported research on human research participants is regulated by the Pre2018-ComRule and 45CFR46-B-E.
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the G-SpecimensResrch, the HHS views research involving human subject specimens as research involving human participants and subject to informed consent requirements if the specimens obtained may be classified as identifiable private information. Identifiable private information or identifiable specimens are those that can be linked to specific individuals by the investigator(s) either directly or indirectly through coding systems. The RevComRule further defines an identifiable biospecimen as one for which the identity of the participant is or may readily be ascertained by the investigator. See the Pre2018-ComRule, RevComRule, the G-SpecimensResrch, USA-9, and USA-1 for additional information. See also the G-SpecimensResrch for exemptions to this definition.
Additionally, as defined by the HHS’ National Institutes of Health (NIH) in USA-24, research with specimens, cells, cell lines, or data involves human subjects when:
- The specimens, cells, or data must be or must have been obtained from individuals who are alive, and must be or must have been obtained by an investigator conducting research; and
- The investigator either must be obtaining or must have obtained specimens, cells, or data through interaction or intervention with living individuals, or must be obtaining or have obtained individually identifiable private information.
See USA-24 for detailed frequently asked questions (FAQs) on this topic.
Per the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule, prior to collecting, storing, or using a research participant’s biological specimen(s), consent must be obtained from the participant or legal representative/guardian. See USA-18 and USA-65 for more information on Common Rule departments/agencies, and the Regulatory Authority section for additional guidance on when the Pre2018-ComRule and the RevComRule apply to research.
The RevComRule requires the informed consent form to provide one (1) of the following statements about any research that involves the collection of identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens:
- A statement that identifiers might be removed from the identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens and that, after such removal, the information or biospecimens could be used for future research studies or distributed to another investigator for future research studies without additional informed consent from the subject or the legally authorized representative, if this might be a possibility
- A statement that the subject's information or biospecimens collected as part of the research, even if identifiers are removed, will not be used or distributed for future research studies
- A statement that the subject's biospecimens (even if identifiers are removed) may be used for commercial profit and whether the subject will or will not share in this commercial profit
- Whether the research will (if known) or might include whole genome sequencing (i.e., sequencing of a human germline or somatic specimen with the intent to generate the genome or exome sequence of that specimen)
Furthermore, the RevComRule delineates the requirements of broad consent—an alternative consent process—for the storage, maintenance, and secondary research use of private information or identifiable biospecimens. Broad consent requires that the following information be provided to the participant or legal representative/guardian:
- Certain basic elements from the normal consent process related to risks, benefits, confidentiality, voluntary statement, commercial profit, contact information, and whole genome sequencing elements
- Types of research that may be conducted
- A description of the information or biospecimens that might be used in future research, whether sharing might occur; and the types of institutions or researchers that might conduct research
- A description of the length of time that the information or biospecimens may be stored, maintained, and used
- A statement that participants will or will not be informed of the details of any specific research studies that might be subsequently conducted
- A statement that research results either will or will not be disclosed to participants
- An explanation of whom to contact for answers to questions about the participant's rights and about storage and use of the participant's identifiable private information or identifiable biospecimens, and whom to contact in the event of a research-related harm.
The RevComRule does allow the use of identifiable information or biospecimens in instances where the institutional ethics committee (EC) (institutional review board (IRB) in the United States (US)) determines the research could not practicably be carried out without the information in that form. Furthermore, it removes the requirement for the investigator to seek a waiver of informed consent to obtain information or biospecimens to screen, recruit, or determine eligibility of prospective participants.
The HHS’ G-StoredData-Tissues states that among the basic informed consent elements, clear descriptions of the following should be included for specimen collection and storage:
- The operation of the cell repository and the specific types of research to be conducted
- Conditions under which specimens and data will be released to recipient investigators
- Procedures for protecting the privacy of human research participants and maintaining the confidentiality of data
- The nature and purpose of the research, as specific as possible
- The consequences of DNA typing if human genetic research is anticipated
(See the Required Elements and Participant Rights sections for additional information on informed consent).